Message Board Archives

WHAT SAY YOU?

WINDIES VS PAKISTAN

In reply to XDFIX

I say drop Bravo, Bishoo and Samuels. How dare they performed in this very experienced, balanced and over-achieving team.

In reply to Priapus Cummins, yes he looked lost.

In reply to Priapus

Samuels really shouldn't be in the team. Running from the ball or stepping back and away from the fast bowlers and then pushing the bat is disgraceful to cricket. Most of his seventy odd runs came from the slower bowlers.

In reply to londoner

Cummins is your frontline pacer...he might not get a wicket in that last test but he wasn't carted around and he is capable of striking.

Certainly wouldn't drop Cummins yet; once he's been identified as a possible Test player he needs to be given an extended run to prove himself one way or another. The step up in quality from domestic to Test level can be a difficult adjustment particularly if the standard of regional cricket isn't that high. All players starting Test cricket for the first time should be given a decent run before being dropped or otherwise you go back to square one with their replacement.

In reply to azadtntAgree. push, prod, then a decent shot

KB
Johnson
Bravo
Blackwood
Chase
Dowrich
Holder
Bishoo
Cummins
Gabriel
Joseph

One change for me. Shai Hope to open instead of Kraigg.

He will either come good in the position or at the least give us the 30 sintin Kraigg is giving us...

In reply to analyst-kid Cummins, will not play in the next test. The off spinner will come in for him. I don't know which test you was Watc
hing. I watch it and he was terrible.

In reply to londoner

We don't have a off spinner on tour neither a replacement batsman. Our selectors are pros!!!

In reply to XDFIX

The only change is an enforced one...Shai Hope in for an injured Shane Dowrich.