Message Board Archives

HEADLINE: Players not playing domestic tournaments ineligble for West Indies: Michael Muirhead

 
CaribbeanCricket.com Feb 19, 2016, 2:25:37 AM 

Despite the numerous players vs board controversies that has inflicted West Indies cricket since the team descended into terminal decline in 1995 - 2015 will have to go down as a champion year in world of off-field controversies.

Events from the embarrassing India tour pull started a chain reaction of endless issues, which commenced with Dwayne Bravo and Kieron Pollard being axed from the 2015 World Cup squad. This followed the first CARICOM government's condemnation of the West Indies Cricket Board (WICB) by Grenada and St.Vincent Prime Ministers Dr Keith Mitchell and Ralph Gonzales, while Dave Cameron was re-elected as president despite majority opposition from Caribbean media and fans.

By mid-2015, the selection panel, led by West Indies legends Clive Lloyd and Courtney Walsh, began to show the first signs that they were losing the plot by axing of Shivnarine Chanderpaul for the home series versus Australia. A host of other shocking selections followed, highlighted most notably by Denesh Ramdin being strangely sacked as Test captain and young Jason Holder given the burden.

The bombs kept going off to end the year with coach Phil Simmons suspended for publicly admonishing the board for "outside interference" in preventing Bravo and Pollard from being picked. Domestically, the Trinidad & Tobago Cricket board, learning from their WICB elders the art of erudite administration, took away the captaincy and contracts from then-captain Rayad Emrit, Kevon Cooper and Evin Lewis due to them playing in the Bangladesh Premier League.

Read the full article at cricbuzz


Full Story

 
cherri Feb 19, 2016, 3:10:51 AM 

All of a sudden this M'head got teet', wings and all, he seem to be making up for the times when he could not even look a mike in the face and smile.......what a ting..........

 
DIEHARD Feb 19, 2016, 3:25:46 AM 

In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com

We are trying to get sponsorship for our domestic tournaments and one of the regular comments we get from potential sponsors is queries whether the notable players will be playing in the tournaments they would sponsor. So, our biggest players have to play in our competitions.


So we ensure that by marginalising them and not selecting for the senior team..so the senior team will also eventually lose sponsors..WICB logic..

These T20 leagues aren't of the best quality and in some cases don't provide adequate preparation for international cricket.
You know what would be a good analysis - why these players perform so much better with those leagues but not in WI colours.


You yourself just said its because the leagues are of such poor quality..maybe i misunderstand the point he was trying to make.

Or did he just want to state the obvious fact that top performers perform better when treated with respect?

More WICB logic

 
brians_da_best Feb 19, 2016, 3:30:21 AM 

He's right. Look around the world, in every country, selection to the national teams is based on participation in domestic tournaments. Why should it be different here?

To get sponsors for domestic tournaments, the big players need to play, in at least part of the season. Along with that, they also have a responsibility to pass tips to the youngsters and help them improve.

I don't see anything wron with whar the CEO is saying.

 
natty_forever Feb 19, 2016, 8:34:07 AM 

In reply to brians_da_best.. well he also noted, inappropriate preparation ... so, I would not have a problem with a youngster/oldster playing in another professional league that offers appropriate preparation while not playing in ours because of a clash of schedule.

I site football as exhibit A.

 
ah806 Feb 19, 2016, 4:59:25 PM 

In reply to brians_da_best

So they just have to participate? I guess that would be accurate since Permaul was not selected for the Aus tour.

 
Kay Feb 19, 2016, 6:44:46 PM 

Fair call....

 
Pacy Feb 19, 2016, 7:55:53 PM 

In reply to brians_da_best


To get sponsors for domestic tournaments, the big players need to play, in at least part of the season. Along with that, they also have a responsibility to pass tips to the youngsters and help them improve.


How are you going to make that happen is what Die hard asks. You know star players are needed to even to secure Local sponsorship. So apart from being vindictive and stating you cant play any cricket if you do not play domestic what other options have you give them?

 
brians_da_best Feb 19, 2016, 9:10:48 PM 

In reply to Pacy

The options are clear. Play domestic cricket to be eligible for international cricket.

Else go to the leagues an stay there an mak your millions.

We need players who take pride in playing for the west indies and also helping develop our cricket.

With the new pcl, the money is also there to play domestic cricket. And check the figures posted by hinds, these guys will all stand to earn hundreds of thousands a year just by playing for the Windies. The good ones, can rake in well over a million.

Look at other countries, their guys play the domestic competitions always. Here, it's just darren bravo who showed intent by playing domestic competitions. We need more like him, and th what is going to get our cricket forward.

Joseph can benefit by playing along side holder, taylor and roach. Paul can use gayle's experience to learn. Springer would do well to spend time with sarwan, chanderpaul, bravo and co.

 
Pacy Feb 20, 2016, 12:29:38 AM 

In reply to brians_da_best

We need players who take pride in playing for the west indies and also helping develop our cricket.


But sponsors do not want to sponsor just for pride as per the CEO.

Take it or leave it makes it easy as they had left it. Series of retirements and no shows. Even Holder who was denied the PCL participation is just at home resting his legs. Does not help anyone

 
Babylon Feb 20, 2016, 1:19:07 AM 

In reply to Pacy

Take it or leave it makes it easy as they had left it. Series of retirements and no shows. Even Holder who was denied the PCL participation is just at home resting his legs. Does not help anyone


Pacy u got a way of putting tings short and sweet. Strait to the point. Yes Sir. Tell de dunces

 
brians_da_best Feb 20, 2016, 4:05:17 AM 

In reply to Pacy

Sponsors sponsor for potential returns and positive value to their brand. Ask any of the companies who sponsor national teams, athletes, etc. The objective is to get visibility for the company, and if the team is depleted, or the athlete doesn't perform, sponsors pull the plug. Does mrf still give lara and sachin money, after they retired and stopped batting in front of millions? Go figure.

If the players choose to leave it, it's their call. They can retire, and go to the leagues. As far as I am aware, the wicb has never denied anyone an noc to play anywhere they have wanted to. But then, don't come and expect to walk into the west indies team.

Let the board get players who are willing to play for pride, for their country and make their money in the process. And during off season, ply their trade in whatever leagues they choose to play in. There are so many now anyways