Message Board Archives
HEADLINE: St. Vincent PM writes to Chairman of Selectors over Sammy?s sacking
CaribbeanCricket.com
Aug 12, 2016, 5:39:08 AM
Mr. Courtney Browne
Chairman of Selectors
West Indies Cricket Board
Barbados
Mr. Darren Sammy, the distinguished West Indian cricketer, has advised me that, in your capacity as Chairman of the Selectors of the West Indies Cricket Team, you peremptorily informed him in a 30 second telephone conversation that he was being removed as the Captain of the West Indies T-20 Team and that his recent performances did not merit him a place on the team for the upcoming T-20 matches against the touring Indian Team.
I find this shabby treatment of Mr. Sammy to be unacceptable; indeed, I am sure that all right-thinking persons are extremely dissatisfied at your unceremonious and summary dismissal of Mr. Sammy as Captain and player. You simply cannot treat a former captain of the West Indies Test Team and a successful captain of two successive World Cup T-20 Championships with such disdain! Further, your sacking of Mr. Sammy, and the manner of his termination, on the eve of a Test Match in Mr. Sammy’s country, St. Lucia, to be played at the stadium which bears his name, display breathtaking insensitivity.
Elemental respect and common decency demand that once the Selectors had decided to remove Mr. Sammy as Captain and as player of the T-20 team, he ought to have been accorded the courtesy of a dignified face-to-face meeting with you, and his support enlisted for the transitioning to the new captain. Does the leadership of the West Indies Cricket Board or Chairman of Selectors have no sense of professionalism or any inkling of what is right or wrong in professional/industrial relations?
read more at StLucianewsonline
Full Story
sunfish
Aug 12, 2016, 5:52:31 AM
In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com
Politicians should NOT get involved with team selection!
bobby
Aug 12, 2016, 5:55:00 AM
In reply to sunfish
Did you read the letter? Can you read? The PM NEVER dealt with selection. The letter is about common decency and respect.
camos
Aug 12, 2016, 5:56:39 AM
In reply to sunfish
that is not the issue dude, few people will argue that Sammy merits a pick.
camos
Aug 12, 2016, 5:57:11 AM
In reply to bobby
thank you!
jacksprat
Aug 12, 2016, 6:08:24 AM
In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com
Elemental respect and common decency demand that once the Selectors had decided to remove Mr. Sammy as Captain and as player of the T-20 team, he ought to have been accorded the courtesy of a dignified face-to-face meeting with you, and his support enlisted for the transitioning to the new captain.
Yeah, like the protocol which was followed by the WICB when Gayle, Sarwan, Ramdin, Adams, Hooper, Ganga, et al, were sacked by them.
Further afield, Rohan Kanhai reportedly learned of his ouster as captain while listening to the BBC News.
NOTHING HAS CHANGED!!!
Discourse
Aug 12, 2016, 6:14:36 AM
In reply to camos
...and he is consistent
Splinter
Aug 12, 2016, 7:04:23 AM
Sammy deserves more than a 30 second phone call.If the WICB continues to discard players like used condoms, then they have no moral authority to question players' loyalty. Our current and upcoming players will seek to become t20 mercenaries and gravitate towards the highest bidder.
TanteMerle
Aug 12, 2016, 7:35:40 AM
To The St. Vincent PM
Re: - Letter to Chairman of Selectors over Sammys sacking.
Mind ya rasshole business and HYMC.
Signed:TanteMerle on behalf of Mr. Brung.
vulcan
Aug 12, 2016, 7:51:29 AM
I hope that you are not being unduly influenced by those whose leadership is akin to the proverbial plantation supervisor, in a brown cork hat, perched on a horse ___ a high horse ___ seeking pitiable revenge against someone on
account of some imagined transgression against massa.
ouch
che
Aug 12, 2016, 8:03:10 AM
Narper
Aug 12, 2016, 8:12:20 AM
Ralphie is a good man...and has the players' welfare at heart...he has been consistent over the years.
Ralphie is right...at least Sammy deserves a face to face meeting...regardless of Sammy's personal contribution with bat or ball...no one can erase the fact that he was the WI cappo who brought home two World Cups...and he has been a long term cappo.
I have followed your cricketing career with great interest and admiration. I have always considered you to be a splendid son of our Caribbean civilisation.
Come on Ralphie....don't mamaguy Brung
And Ralphie....shouldn't WIPA be writing such a letter too?
And BTW Ralphie.....nothing has been done to honour humble servant of WI cricket...Shiv Chanderpaul...who was unceremoniously sent packing too...I was expecting something to be mentioned in this series...at least invite the man to a test match and honour him properly.....with his recent teammates present
camos
Aug 12, 2016, 8:20:36 AM
In reply to Narper
And Ralphie....shouldn't WIPA be writing such a letter too?
didn't Sammy leave WIPA?
tc1
Aug 12, 2016, 8:33:06 AM
[b]In reply to
This fail poltickian is out of place, as bad as WI cricket is, it is still managed better than many of the counties in the region.
Narper
Aug 12, 2016, 8:35:33 AM
In reply to camos
Well...if we take the personality out of the equation...then it's how the cappo of the WI team is fired...and that is the gist of Ralphie's letter.
WIPA should be concerned about this. ALL players should be treated with some respect and dignity.
Kay
Aug 12, 2016, 8:36:41 AM
In reply to Narper
Ralphie is a good man...and has the players' welfare at heart...he has been consistent over the years
Consistent? Wasn't Mr. Chanderpaul given his orders via WhatsApp and what did Ralphie seh then?
camos
Aug 12, 2016, 8:38:12 AM
In reply to tc1
This fail poltickian is out of place
what makes Ralpf a failed politician? he is more successful as a politician than Brown was as a cricketer!
vulcan
Aug 12, 2016, 8:38:40 AM
Didn't Brung tell Ramdin the same thing? I heard the great Viv in commentary the other day said, Brung needs to be careful what he is saying....
Raggs
Aug 12, 2016, 8:40:16 AM
poiticians can be such ah jackarse...
Courtesy
Aug 12, 2016, 8:42:45 AM
In reply to tc1
This fail poltickian is out of place, as bad as WI cricket is, it is still managed better than many of the counties in the region.
Bro you have gotten away with this fuckery argumentun ad hominen before now.
You are directing your argument to another agency or person instead of trying to disprove the truth of the assertion. This is invalid because the truth of the assertion does not depend upon the goodness of those asserting it.
JahJah
Aug 12, 2016, 8:44:18 AM
In reply to TanteMerle
tc1
Aug 12, 2016, 10:46:48 AM
In reply to camos
be honest and look at the region and tell what u see
tc1
Aug 12, 2016, 10:59:27 AM
In reply to Courtesy
the regional govt's are managed just like the WI Cricket and many find themselves with similar problems.
BeatDball
Aug 12, 2016, 5:41:09 PM
In reply to jacksprat Jeezas lawd, help WI!
sandisha
Aug 12, 2016, 5:41:59 PM
In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com
Very well said Mr. Gonsalves! I just wish the region had more prime ministers with a passion for cricket like we had in the 80's to late 90's. The way the administrators and selectors are dealing with our cricketers is very bad and that's hurting and killing our cricket. That's how good players like Kanhai, Richards, Robert, Holding, Ambrose, Haynes, Lara, Gayle, Sanwan, Bravo, Chanderpaul and others were treated and nothing has changed. In fact in recent times the only former player that retired with some dignity was Walsh.
I really think the idea of replacing Sammy with Carlos Brathwaite makes some sense but the timing and manner it was handled were terrible. It would have been much better if Sammy was told that the Florida series would be his last one and then, make Brathwaite vice captain. They should use the Florida tour to give Sammy a good fairwell and have him to groom his successor. That would be a better situation for Brathwaite and would spark confidence in the entire team. Mr. Brown and all selectors should resign or get fired.
voiceofreason
Aug 12, 2016, 5:57:28 PM
In reply to Courtesy
You are directing your argument to another agency or person instead of trying to disprove the truth of the assertion. This is invalid because the truth of the assertion does not depend upon the goodness of those asserting it.
Well said.
Pacy
Aug 12, 2016, 8:47:49 PM
In reply to Splinter
Sammy deserves more than a 30 second phone call.If the WICB continues to discard players like used condoms, then they have no moral authority to question players' loyalty. Our current and upcoming players will seek to become t20 mercenaries and gravitate towards the highest bidder.
Spot on... That is the crux of the matter. Respect is mutual. WICB continue to disrespect the players for decades and expect them to be respected and recognised. Bravo, Pollard and Sammy were dropped for the strike and post T20 WC but fact is it was the entire team that was behind them. The feeling is through the team.
I dont think people want to move away from WI cricket but WICB at the end of the day
buds
Aug 12, 2016, 10:56:54 PM
In reply to Pacy
Did scammY respected or show mutual respect for the WICB board when publicly diss his employer on TV? As that failed politician say,respect is mutual and your employer holds the purse string.
scammu was nothing more than a passenger on the WI team...less, yes but nothing more..
Pacy
Aug 12, 2016, 11:16:08 PM
In reply to buds
He was a passenger all along and I had been clear about that all along.
What Lara did, Hooper did, Gayle did, Chanders did, Sarwan did, Bravo did and Sammy did are all reflection of the system.
You can see the dissent consistently getting worse and worse since dissent is not addressed inappropriately and with more disrespect by the board.
I would not be surprised if the next by anyone is even worse. Based on the flag some support WICB or the player involved but the common base is that Board considers players useless and treats them as they feel like and players react.
buds
Aug 13, 2016, 2:38:05 AM
In reply to Pacy
Essentially, he was fired in normal parlance--If people think speaking up against your employer is gonna merit kudos from them its nothing but a pipe dream. Scammy rode his appointment despite his severe limitations and did very well of which I think he is grateful. However, the few who think he was this great leader is delusional and suffering from Trumpism..
The board can do better but, they lack people skills--Plus its the boys club so he really was treated kindly.
Just go and live your life Scammy--He can suck on that bottle as much now..lol
cricketest
Aug 13, 2016, 6:05:42 AM
I really think the idea of replacing Sammy with Carlos Brathwaite makes some sense but the timing and manner it was handled were terrible. It would have been much better if Sammy was told that the Florida series would be his last one and then, make Brathwaite vice captain. They should use the Florida tour to give Sammy a good fairwell and have him to groom his successor. That would be a better situation for Brathwaite and would spark confidence in the entire team. Mr. Brown and all selectors should resign or get fired.
the appointment of ricky as T20 captain makes no sense. yes he did get lucky at the world cup, but has done nothing since.