Message Board Archives

Windwards all time 11

 
methodic 2016-12-07 20:55:57 

name that stand out off the top of my head

1.Lockheart Sebastien
2.Devon Smith
3.Lance John
4.Irvin Shillingford
5.Shane Julien
6.Junior Murray
7.Darren Sammy
8.Norbert Phillip
9.Shane Shillingford
10.Greason Shillingford
11.Winston Davis

 
Wasp 2016-12-07 21:08:09 

12th man

Danley Joesph
big grin

 
methodic 2016-12-07 21:19:11 

In reply to Wasp

there is a player I am missing. He was a badman on the road. Lara talked about him once.

 
Ragga007 2016-12-07 21:36:22 

Michael Findley and Winston Davis.

 
methodic 2016-12-07 21:44:06 

In reply to Ragga007

Findley replaces Murray, I already have Davis. I am looking for another bat and spinner. I rate Shane over Rawle Lewis.

 
POINT 2016-12-08 09:58:53 

Could you please explain precisely what You mean by Windwards All Time 11
. Because I can name some Players who
were vastly superior to those you have named . I await your response . Thank
You .

 
Kay 2016-12-08 10:09:12 

In reply to POINT

Jeezus shit man!!!

The poster said this in his lead post "name that stand out off the top of my head" which implies it's his team from memory. Now name yours and stop asking stupid questions...

 
doosra 2016-12-08 10:38:26 

Rawle Lewis
Cameron Cuffy
Nixon McLean

 
thefacts 2016-12-08 10:56:58 

In reply to methodic

Cameron Cuffy, would be my first bowling pick, everyone else next

 
thefacts 2016-12-08 11:01:44 

Windwards XI:

Devon Smith
Johnson Charles
Dave Joseph
Andre Fletcher
Darren Sammy (captain)
Junior Murray (wk)
Rawl Lewis
Shane Shillingford
Nixon McLean
Winston Davis
Cameron Cuffy

 
DIEHARD 2016-12-08 11:06:27 

In reply to thefacts

Nobody that stop play before 1990 worthy of selection for you?? lol

 
thefacts 2016-12-08 11:33:13 

In reply to DIEHARD

Davis?

 
Cheeks 2016-12-08 13:25:47 

In reply to thefacts

Dave Joseph??? Windwards??

 
camos 2016-12-08 13:56:02 

De Fraties, guy who played for England.

 
WestDem 2016-12-08 14:45:47 

In reply to methodic

Can this man from St Vincent be considered for the Windwards team? cool

 
methodic 2016-12-08 16:46:05 

In reply to WestDem

he played for Windwards a few times if my memory served me right.

 
methodic 2016-12-08 16:50:23 

In reply to thefacts

I will pick Mclean ahead of Cuffy, Maybe the two of them might partner Davis.

 
doosra 2016-12-08 17:35:48 

In reply to camos

Phillip DeFreitas

 
doosra 2016-12-08 17:37:00 

In reply to methodic

Cuffy when he returned was way better than McLean with his consistency but his pace was down

 
Priapus 2016-12-08 18:47:00 

In reply to methodic

Honorable mentions:

Ignatius Cadette
John Eugene
Julian Charles
Casper Davis
Stanley Hinds
Javan Etienne
Roy Marshall

 
POINT 2016-12-08 18:53:42 

In reply to methodic

It would be remiss of me if I did not state that some of these Players were
essentially barred from getting an opportunity to vie for a place in the
West Indies Team .

This was due to the fact that the WICBC during their time , never considered Players from the Windward
&Leeward Islands . This was changed
due to the influence of Sir Frank Worrell ; who spoke to Frankie Thomas
a Barbadian who lived in SVG for many years , and was responsible for the
building the Arnos Vale Cricket Ground .

Frankie Thomas for many years was the
Captain of the SVG Cricket Team and played in the Local Tournament .

From Grenada the follow players who were not yet listed easily comes to mind .
EVELYN GRESHAM ; a stylish Left
Handed batsman .

JOHN STEELE , a noted Pace Bowler ,

TED WALKER , a Hard hitting left handed batsman .

VESTER CONSTANTINE - Pace Bowler , who was the National GoalKeeper for
Grenada . He went to the West Indies
Regiment that was stationed in Jamaica , and was the Captain of the
Jamaica Football Team .

I am sure that there are others who I
have not remembered .

In St. Vincent & the Grenadines ,
there was ALPHONSO ROBERTS , who was
coached by Everton Weeks , he went on
a Tour to New Zealand with the West Indies Team .

IAN NEVERSON , a prolific batsman , who once hit Truman ; Statham ; and
the English Spinners in their prime
to various parts of the Field . Apparently his batting left an impression on Truman , because the
latter asked about Neverson on his next tour to the Windward Islands .

FRANK MASON , who once clean bowled Frank Worrell for a Duck , in Worrell's prime .

GARNET NILES , undoubtedly the best
Vincentian Wicketkeeper , who was even better than Michael Findlay .

 
POINT 2016-12-08 19:16:55 

From St. Lucia , the legendary " BAM "
CHARLES quickly comes to mind , he got wickets while playing for the Windward Islands , against an International Touring Team , and based on his performance was taken to Jamaica by the WICBC , but did not get on the Team .

There was a guy called ST.ROSE who was very good Player .I am sure there are others who I have not remembered .
In Dominica , A Touring International Team , declared that ALEC REID was the best Wicketkeeper they saw on their Tour to the West Indies . Unfortunately this was prior to Frank Worrell demanding that Players from the Windward & Leeward Islands get an
opportunity to vie for places on the West Indies Team . REID migrated to
England .

Mention has been made of IRVING SHILLINGFORD , who showed promise even at the Schoolboy level in the Windward Islands Secondary Schools Tournament .

I agree with the other selections from Dominica & the other
Windward Islands .

 
POINT 2016-12-08 19:23:05 

In reply to WestDem

There was also another Player from SVG
playing in England around the same time as Slack , his name escapes me , but I believe he played for Essex , and returned to SVG , I believe that he is also now dead .

His name is Neil Fitzgerald Williams .
He died of pneumonia in SVG 3 weeks after suffering a stroke .

 
openning 2016-12-08 19:42:28 

Are we just naming names or selecting who allyuh think would be the best All-time Windward Island regional X1?
Devon Smith has to be in that X1.
Should a player who never represented a regional team be selected?
Hell NO.

 
camos 2016-12-08 20:05:24 

where was Wilfred Slack from?

 
POINT 2016-12-08 20:48:04 

Some People are really SIMPLETONS ,
There were Players from the Windward
Islands WHO NEVER EVER GOT AN

OPPORTUNITY TO VIE FOR SPOTS IN THE

WEST INDIES , BECAUSE THEY WERE LIKE

IT OR NOT DISCRIMINATED BY THE WICBC .


Let me cite the case of IAN NEVERSON ,

HE MADE 90 NOT OUT AGAINST TRUMAN;

STATHAM ; LOCK & LAKER ; IN THEIR

PRIME . THE FACT IS IN THOSE DAYS

THE WICBC REFUSED TO CONSIDER PLAYERS

FROM THE WINDWARD & LEEWARD ISLANDS .

FOR SELECTION ON THE WEST INDIES

TEAM.


NOW THIS IS A FACT IT AINT A FIGMENT

OF MY IMAGINATION . HOW THE HELL CAN

CAN A PLAYER PLAY FOR THE WEST INDIES

IF HE DOES NOT GET AN OPPORTUNITY TO

SHOWCASE HIS ABILITIES ?????

 
Fivestar 2016-12-08 21:34:20 

In reply to POINT

Unfortunately this was prior to Frank Worrell demanding that Players from the Windward & Leeward Islands get an opportunity to vie for places on the West Indies Team.

There was a fast bowler from St Vincent by the name of Frank Mason who rumour has it was very good and should have played for West Indies. Did you ever see him and if so how good was he?

 
POINT 2016-12-08 21:42:14 

Let me cite the case of Charlie Ollivierre of SVG . He & his brother
lived near Victoria Park in Kingstown .The man who was in charge of Victoria
Park not only knew the Ollivierre Brothers , he allowed them & their friends to play in the Park .

The Manager of the Park , subsequently
was employed as the Manager of the Queens Park Oval .When he learned that
there was going to be a maiden Tour of
England , by a West Indies Team , he
told those in charge that they should
invite the Ollivierre Brothers to
assess their Cricket abilities .

So the Ollivierre Brothers went to
Trinidad , and Charlie Ollivierre was
selected to go on the first Tour of
a West Indies Team to England .

CHARLIE OLLIVIERRE is fondly remembered in Derbyshire , where he was called King Charlie . The point
that I am making is that Charlie
Ollivierre & his brother who later was on a West Indies Team that toured
England , got an opportunity to display their Cricket prowess , because they were recommended by the
Manager of the Queens Park Oval , and
their skills were rewarded , by being
selected to go on Tour to England .

CHARLIE OLLIVIERRE WAS THE FIRST &

ONLY BLACK MAN TO GO ON THE WEST

INDIES FIRST TOUR TO ENGLAND .

I invite ALL to Google Cricketer

Charles Ollivierre of St. Vincent .

 
POINT 2016-12-08 21:50:52 

In reply to Fivestar

Frank Mason was very fast , and well known in Windward Islands Cricket , he
was also for some years the Captain of the SVG Team .

As I stated , he did once at the George 5th Playing field clean bowled
Frank Worrell for a duck . Worrell at the time was not an old man .

Mason was probably about 6'-2 , and well built . The tallest fast bowler
from SVG , I believe was Cameron Cuffy .

Yes I knew Mason personally , the last time I saw him we were both at
a Function , where he was being honoured , and my late father was also being honoured . We sat next to each other , and he was telling me about the time during the second World War , while on vacation from secondary School , he went to British Guiana on a boat captained by a Captain who he knew . Well the boat
got to British Guiana , but took a long time getting back to Kingstown , with Rice .

People in SVG believed that the Boat was sunk by a German U-Boat , so when the Boat was sighted , coming into the harbour , there was a massive crowd , shouting for joy , that the boat had not been sunk by A German U-
Boat . He died some years ago .

 
methodic 2016-12-08 22:10:15 

Roy Marshal is the player I was trying to remember.

 
methodic 2016-12-08 22:11:12 

In reply to POINT

thanks for the info, I will like to see your team.

 
openning 2016-12-08 22:27:08 

Some People are really SIMPLETONS ,
There were Players from the Windward
Islands WHO NEVER EVER GOT AN

OPPORTUNITY TO VIE FOR SPOTS IN THE

WEST INDIES , BECAUSE THEY WERE LIKE

IT OR NOT DISCRIMINATED BY THE WICBC .


Still awaiting the best Windward Island team; all other teams selected was base on players playing regional cricket and others going on to represent the WICB, but every players so far played for Barbados, T&T, Jamaica, Guyana and Leewards.
Three players that should make an all star Windward team are;
Devon Smith
Irvine Shillingford
Junior Murray

 
POINT 2016-12-08 22:35:50 

In reply to methodic

I will have to think about the names
. I hope that your criteria is that
they must represent the West Indies .

Let me again repeated what I stated

NO ONE CAN DENY THE FACT THAT THERE

WAS A TIME WHEN PLAYERS FROM THE

WINDWARD & LEEWARD ISLANDS WERE NOT

CONSIDERED TO BE WORTHY OF PLAYING

FOR THE WEST INDIES .

Now when a Touring Team declared that
Alec Reid was the best Wicket Keeper they saw on the Tour to the West Indies ; and Alec Reid never ever got
an opportunity to prove whether this was true or not .

Why the Hell he is being disqualified
because he never played for the West
Indies ?? that in my opinion is pure
unadulterated B.S . This also applies
to Ian Neverson ; and others .

If the qualification is that they must play for the West Indies , I am not going to participate in this farcical exercise . Because the playing Field surely aint level .

 
methodic 2016-12-08 22:41:02 

In reply to POINT

they must have represented the Windwards or Combine Islands.

 
openning 2016-12-08 22:50:24 

In reply to methodic
I just reviewed Irvine Shillingford first 6 years at the regional level, he scored a ton 4-6 years, thats remarkable
The first combined Island player to score two or more tons in a season was Viv.

 
methodic 2016-12-08 22:58:40 

In reply to openning

I can't remember seeing him, I listened to him playing on the radio.

 
openning 2016-12-08 23:05:20 

In reply to methodic

I remember there was an uproar with him not selected to tour England, some was of the belief, he should had been selected ahead of David Allan
Irvine Theodore Shillingford

 
POINT 2016-12-09 09:37:46 

One year Irving Shillingford , won the prize for being the best batsman in the Regional Tournament by scoring the
most runs , I believe in the Shell Shield .

The BUMS in the WICBC asked Vivian Richards to privately present the prize to Shillingford . In essence
Shillingford was not awarded his Prize during the Regular Ceremony where the Prizes were awarded .

The Priest from Grenada wrote a book on some
Windward Islands Players , and in his book ; on the chapter about Irving Shillingford he mentioned what I have stated above .

 
openning 2016-12-09 22:15:07 

In reply to methodic

In reply to POINT

thanks for the info, I will like to see your team.


Still waiting.

 
methodic 2016-12-09 23:01:27 

In reply to openning

big grin

 
openning 2016-12-12 00:48:51 

In reply to methodic

Still waiting

 
POINT 2016-12-12 11:29:29 

In reply to methodic

Well here are the Players that would
be in my Squad :

IRVING SHILLINGFORD ; ALPHONSO

ROBERTS ;

IAN NEVERSON ; ALEC REID ;

FRANK MASON ; DEVON SMITH ;

NEIL WILLIAMS ; WILFRED SLACK ;

BAM CHARLES ; DARREN SAMMY ;

DAWNLEY JOSEPH ; STANLEY HINDS ;

WINSTON DAVIS .


Other Very notable Players :

GRAYSON SHILLINGFORD ; GARNET NILES ;

WINSTON MAURICETTE ; HOLLIS BRISTOL

AUGUSTUS GREGOR; NORBERT PHILLIPS

LANCE JOHN ; EVELYN GRESHAM .

 
methodic 2016-12-13 00:37:35 

In reply to POINT
Thanks for the team we will discuss the team further in the future

 
Tagwa1 2016-12-13 01:23:12 

In reply to methodic

No Theo Redhead?

No Frank Mason?

No Ox Johnson

No Mindoo Phillip?

No Garnet Niles.

No Gresham.

No Shane Julien

No Wifred Slack

No Ted Walker

No Mignon....WI player early 1900s

Psst..

I don't think Grayson Shillingford gets in.

REDHEAD and Mason opens with Davis first change.

Norbet Phillip plays as allrounder.

Only Irving Shillingford plays in your top five.

Shilly on the Telly is my spinner..beating out Hinds and Joe Gibbs...since no one called him regionally.

Devon Smith may play for his mountain of regional runs..but keep in mind that he may not have made a Grenada much less a Windwards in the 50s.

 
Domic 2016-12-13 03:52:02 

In reply to methodic

Ignatius Cadette he was the best keeper in the caribbean at the time

Thomas Kentish
Clement John

 
POINT 2016-12-13 12:22:40 

In reply to Tagwa1

I forgot about Theo Redhead ; and Ted Walker ; Evelyn Gresham . John Steele.

 
POINT 2016-12-13 12:37:04 

In reply to Domic

When the West Indies went to England ,
the named Wicket Keeper was not Deryck Murray . I do not recall his
name , I however saw him , as I was
living in Barbados at the time .

Both Garnet Niles & Michael Findlay
were together on the same Windward Islands Teams , until Niles migrated to the USA .

I am also very sure that Garnet Niles
was much better than him . My selection of Alex Reid is based on
the fact that an International Touring Team playing in the West Indies stated that Alec Reid was the
Best Wicket Keeper they saw in the Region .

There was a very good Wicket Keeper , in late 1990's & early 2000's ,I believe from Dominica , he was very good but he unfortunately had a drinking Problem .

 
openning 2016-12-13 13:15:29 

It will be interesting to hear Commie, Cheeks and Wesley's teams.