Message Board Archives

HEADLINE: Preview: Windies in Bangladesh 2018-11-21 08:13:00 

Cricket West Indies named a fifteen-man Test squad for the full tour of Bangladesh spanning November 21 to December 22, 2018. With the squad announcement, however, came the news that captain Jason Holder, who is nursing a shoulder injury, will miss the entire tour to South Asia, leaving Kraigg Brathwaite with big shoes to fill when he skippers Windies for the third time in 2018. The squad list reads: Kraigg Brathwaite (Cpt), Sunil Ambris, Devendra Bishoo, Roston Chase, Shane Dowrich (wk), Shannon Gabriel, Jahmar Hamilton, Shimron Hetmyer, Shai Hope, Shermon Lewis, Keemo Paul, Kieran Powell, Raymon Reifer, Kemar Roach and Jomel Warrican.

The most obvious replacement for Holder in the XI would be all-rounder Raymon Reifer. Therefore, if West Indies employs similar strategies to those used in Hyderabad (hopefully not) and persists with the extra batsman; they could enter the first Test on Wednesday evening with a bowling attack of Gabriel, Warrican, Bishoo and Reifer. A boost for Windies, would be the availability of Kemar Roach, who was unavailable in Rajkot, but was an inexplicable absence in Hyderabad. This would mean the visitors will have, at their disposal again, the use of their formidable opening bowling partnership—Roach/Gabriel.

Windies might want to press pause on the thought that a bowling attack of two spinners and three seamers should be an either-or situation on the subcontinent. However, the plan of the extra batsman would then have to be thrown through the window. In keeping an eye on the future, would it be that far-fetched to ask Keemo Paul to embrace the ‘Jason-Holder-role’; add extra responsibility to his batting and demand of him to fulfill, at the international level, this all-rounder label that is continuously touted at him? Any takers for a Roach/Gabriel/Paul/Bishoo/Warrican attack?

Perhaps even outweighing the disappointing performances, were some of the off-field decisions (because of their appalling nature) from Stuart Law and his coaching staff throughout the month-long tour of India. With the team already hamstrung by the absence of their leader, one can only hope that whatever was in the water in India hasn’t seeped into Bangladesh’s supply.

The interval between series for both Bangladesh and Windies is no doubt a short one, which makes it all the more intriguing to see some of the Windies batsmen make the transition from the shorter formats of the game to the traditional, especially the likes of Shimron Hetmyer who has previously voiced confirmation of his struggles in finding the balance among formats. Perhaps the timing can be of benefit to the likes of Shai Hope. Hope finished the ODIs against India with an average of 62.5 and may be able to carry that form and confidence into Tests. However confused Caribbean fans are by Law’s sudden disappearance and Pothas’ appointment, hopefully the players are in the know and are not massively affected by the happenings around them.

Bangladesh’s Test Form: DLLLW

Windies’ Test Form: LWWLL

Full Story

Sylobeauty 2018-11-21 12:31:34 

In reply to
It would be a mistake for West Indies to play Bishoo and Warrican, especially with Chase bowling as well as any of them. That being said my final eleven would be: 1.Brathwaite 2. Powell 3. Hope 4. Hetmyer 5. Chase 6. Dowrich 7. Reifer 8. Paul 9. Warrican 10. Roach 11. Gabriel. Reifer in my opinion is a must, to fill up the batting role of Holder and a left arm pacer to add balance to the team. No pick for Bishoo for sure.

openning 2018-11-21 12:46:16 

In reply to Sylobeauty

Bishoo for Warrican

dayne 2018-11-21 18:37:25 

The CWI should be aggressive and play five specialist bowlers, including Reifer against Bangladesh looks like they are afraid.

Sylobeauty 2018-11-21 18:44:28 

In reply to openning I respect your opinion but to me Bishoo doesn't deserve a pick. In fact the last time we were in Bangladesh we had Bishoo as our key spinner and it was Brathwait, a part time spinner that took 6 wickets while Bishoo did not get any. yes that happens all the time but in recent times Bishoo has failed to command a pick on the west Indies team

Sylobeauty 2018-11-21 22:17:11 

I just cannot believe West Indies playing 2 pacers, 2 spinners and 7 batsmen, which means first change is spin. They are definitely in a defensive frame of mind and that is not a good winning strategy. I wish them well

dayne 2018-11-21 22:41:04 

In reply to Sylobeauty

Agree, a very conservative move by the Selectors