Message Board Archives
BeatDballs....Greatest westerns of all time..??
sgtdjones
Apr 6, 2026, 3:34:49 PM
BeatDballs...Greatest westerns of all time...??
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (1966)
Unforgiven (1992)
Once Upon a Time in the West (196
High Noon (1952)
Shane (1953)
Last Train from Gun Hill (1959)
Rio Bravo (1959)
My Darling Clementine (1946)
Warlock (1959)
Viva Zapata! (1952)
CricSham
Apr 6, 2026, 4:03:34 PM
@sgtdjones
Bro, mark me present. The western genre has always been one of my favorite past times.
Please include:
Stagecoach
Sons of Katie Elder
El Dorado
Chisum
Destry rides again
CricSham
Apr 6, 2026, 4:18:24 PM
@sgtdjones
The darn site doesn’t allow you to edit sometimes.
Also:
The magnificent seven
Hour of the gun
Winchester 73
Gun fight at the OK corral
The big country
Destry rides again
No name on the bullet
Jubal
hubert
Apr 6, 2026, 4:57:06 PM
@sgtdjones
There must be a place for Shane 😄
sgtdjones
Apr 6, 2026, 5:00:16 PM
@hubert
Hope your health is improving...good to see you posting.
I have faced such issues, and then my post instantly vanishes when I hit save.
I must sign after 10 minutes on this site; my plea has been ignored by management.
Not one of the treasured posters...😎
hubert
Apr 6, 2026, 5:23:53 PM
@sgtdjones
Health is improved in one big area but not so good in others as is normal at my age...Still vertical and enjoying my Westerns now even more than what passes for cricket and its ???@@* in the Region 😮
FanAttick
Apr 6, 2026, 6:29:31 PM
@sgtdjones
How the hell you left out Blazing Saddles?😀
BeatDball
Apr 6, 2026, 6:45:21 PM
@sgtdjones
these additons - Hour of the Gun & The Outlaw Josey Wales! 😎
VIX
Apr 8, 2026, 12:29:39 AM
@hubert
One of the many signs of self-loathing among older Caribbean people is their obsession with American Westerns. Luckily, that generation dying out. or at least that way of thinking.
In Westerns, the enemy isn't Nazis, monsters, or space invaders. usually Is the local people defending their own homes. The invaders get treated like heroes. The people protecting their land are the villains. The whole thing is that those who fight for what is theirs are wrong, and those who come to take it are right. How dare the natives claim their own land, eh? The invaders are then praised for spreading "freedom."
Palestine much?, where settlers taking land from people who living there for generations. Outsiders cheering the settlers while ignoring or straight up maligning the people getting pushed out. If history repeats itself, future generations of Palestinians could end up cheering movies about how their own land was stolen by the Israelis.
The good news is that younger Caribbean generations seeing this for what it is. Theyre more educated, more aware. They not so quick to rabidly clap for propaganda or celebrate their own people being pushed aside. That awareness is the best protection against repeating the same mistakes the older generations made.
sgtdjones
Apr 8, 2026, 1:09:32 AM
@VIX
The good news is that younger Caribbean generations seeing this for what it is. Theyre more educated, more aware. They not so quick to rabidly clap for propaganda or celebrate their own people being pushed aside. That awareness is the best protection against repeating the same mistakes the older generations made.
Oh, they are more educated, leaving school to join gangs that control blocks selling narcotics. They do not see their relatives killing each other for Grandma's land? Nah, they just shoot up the house and murder their brothers, sisters, and kids.
Did the older generations have 3 murders per day and some years totaling over 600? I am glad that the younger generations are not interested in the old Westerns. They are too busy with murders, rapes, home invasions, and kidnapping in T&T.
You should have stayed in school longer so you would have graduated after completing grade 7.
Classes go higher than 7...🙄
mikesiva
Apr 8, 2026, 2:35:01 AM
@VIX
I rarely watch Westerns these days.
They glorify a group of people who committed a genocide against native Americans.
I prefer to watch films that chronicle the suffering of native Americans. Such as 'Geronimo'.
CricSham
Apr 8, 2026, 6:15:58 AM
@sgtdjones
Young man, why glorify such utterances with a response. What was it my fourth standard teacher Mr Grannum told us “a little learning is a dangerous thing”. Kind of remind us of the person who would tell peoples who were the cradle of civilization that they’ll bomb them into the Stone Age. Socrates, was right. The only sin is ignorance.
JoeGrine
Apr 8, 2026, 9:10:23 AM
1) The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.
2) Shane
3) El Dorado
sgtdjones
Apr 8, 2026, 10:32:28 AM
@mikesiva
That’s a bit ironic since Geronimo was directed by Walter Hill, a filmmaker whose whole career is rooted in the Western genre. He even used some of the exact same filming locations as the old John Ford movies to show how differently those stories could be told.
It's important to watch films that bring those hidden histories to light rather than just the 'cowboys vs. indians' trope. Fair enough, everyone has their own preferences for historical narratives.
sgtdjones
Apr 8, 2026, 10:33:25 AM
@FanAttick
Just saw your post....😂😂
It's the GOAT.😎
KTom
Apr 8, 2026, 10:40:37 AM
Off the top of my head, I would throw in:
1) 3.10 to Yuma (not the remake)
2) Any/all of Ford's Cavalry triology
3) The Searchers
4) The Gunfighter
5) Lonely are the Brave
6) Seven Men From Now
7) The Tall T
Yellow Sky
9) The Fastest Gun Alive
10) Zulu (a British Western)
VIX
Apr 8, 2026, 10:55:33 AM
@mikesiva
Yeah, it has little to do with westerns per se. I expect the elderly Caribbean folks like stupidjones to lap up that nonsense as they grew up not knowing better. But by now they should be able to rethink what they were clapping and bawling for each time an evil Native American was slaughtered.
Self hate is a helluva drug.
Bullying on a grand scale gets turned into heroic storytelling. They come in, take their land, OUR land. Then they control the narrative to make it look justified. Resistance then becomes the crime.
Same bullying manifests itself today in the misfits’ orange god and his puppet master in Israel. Yet we support that mindset. Them white conquerors great. natives bad.
I doubt Bob could have expected that today it would still be so difficult to emancipate ourselves from mental slavery.
KTom
Apr 8, 2026, 11:15:37 AM
@VIX
In Westerns, the enemy isn't Nazis, monsters, or space invaders. usually Is the local people defending their own homes.
In my experience, Injuns are a minority feature in Western films. Sometimes they're just part of the backdrop, but USUALLY (to coin a word) they're absent. By the 1940s, when Hollywood was taking the Western more seriously (big budgets and its biggest stars) what impresses is the wide variety of themes and tropes - the lawman vs outlaws; the range war; cattlemen vs homesteaders, the Civil War and its aftermath, the hero/anti-hero stranger in town. Like police/detective films, the genre had the great advantage that little or no scene-setting or backstory was required - you could start off with a bank hold-up or train robbery and nobody would bat an eyelid. I haven't even started on the aesthetics - horses, gunplay, cowboy gear, Western scenery, and all populated by Hollywood's best looking men. Did I mention the dancing girls?
sgtdjones
Apr 8, 2026, 12:03:01 PM
@KTom
Did I mention the dancing girls?😳
He was only interested in Randolph Scott
KTom
Apr 8, 2026, 12:28:22 PM
@sgtdjones
Scott was a beautiful man - ask Cary Grant - but the older and meaner he got, the better.
sgtdjones
Apr 8, 2026, 12:30:33 PM
@KTom
He wouldn't understand the subtle connotations.😂
KTom
Apr 8, 2026, 1:00:17 PM
From the above lists, it's evident that practically all Hollywood's leading men starred in Westerns - in fact, it's difficult to think of one from the 1940s to 1960s who didn't. My first thought was Bogart, but he did The Treasure of Sierra Madre, which I think definitely counts both as a Western and a top film.
But I've a soft spot for Western regulars, too. If Rod Cameron, Audie Murphy or Rory Calhoun are in the cast, I'm watching regardless.
As for character actors, Walter Brennan, John Carradine, John McIntire, George Gabby Hayes were rootin' tootin' amazing.
sgtdjones
Apr 8, 2026, 1:22:01 PM
@KTom
If you enjoy Audie Murphy's "everyman" hero or his focused, low-budget Westerns, these actors often filled similar niches:
James Stewart: He shared Murphy’s "relatable" quality but often played more neurotically intense characters. They starred together in Night Passage (1957), where Murphy played Stewart's outlaw brother.
Lee Marvin: A real-life war hero like Murphy, Marvin often appeared in Westerns with him (such as The Duel at Silver Creek) before becoming a major star known for his rugged toughness.
Charles Bronson was another veteran-turned-actor who shared Murphy's "quiet strength" and stoic demeanour in numerous "B" and mainstream Westerns.
Dan Duryea: A frequent co-star and foil for Murphy (appearing in Ride Clear of Diablo and Six Black Horses), known for playing charismatic but often sleazy villains that highlighted Murphy's principled characters.
Rory Calhoun was a quintessential Western icon, often described as having "wolfish, Black-Irish good looks." His career spanned over 80 films and 1,000 television episodes, where he specialized in playing stoic, principled, yet morally complex cowboys and gunslingers. He spent time in reform schools and federal prison for stealing cars and robbing jewelry stores before being discovered while horseback riding in the Hollywood Hills by actor Alan Ladd
Yul Brynner (Chris Adams): The shaved-headed leader dressed entirely in black. He brought a "cool, dangerous authority" that anchored the group.
Eli Wallach (Calvera): While not one of the seven, he delivered one of the all-time outstanding villain performances as the charismatic but ruthless bandit leader.
Henry Fonda (Clay Blaisedell): A freelance "town tamer" who is melancholy, laconic, and efficient with his gold-handled colts.
Richard Widmark (Johnny Gannon): A reformed outlaw who becomes the deputy sheriff, playing the role with "sincerity and spunk."
Anthony Quinn (Tom Morgan): Fonda’s club-footed, devoted assistant. Critics have noted the intense, almost "homoerotic" devotion his character has for Blaisedell.
Kirk Douglas (Matt Morgan): An intense U.S. Marshal on a relentless mission to bring his wife’s killer to justice.
Robert Mitchum: Known for his "effortless cool" and world-weary gaze. Like Calhoun, he had a rebellious streak in real life, having spent time in a chain gang as a teenager before becoming a defining star of film noir and Westerns like River of No Return.
Lee Marvin: A decorated Marine who served in WWII, Marvin brought a genuine, gritty intensity to the screen. He often played complex anti-heroes or "vicious characters" in 1950s Westerns before winning an Oscar for his dual role in Cat Ballou.
Charles Bronson: One of 15 children born to a struggling immigrant coal miner, he worked in the mines himself before serving in WWII. His "weather-beaten" features and stoic intensity made him the archetypal screen tough guy in classics like The Magnificent Seven and Once Upon a Time in the West
Joel McCrea: A real-life rancher who shared a love of roping with Will Rogers. He was beloved for playing calm, principled characters with a "straightforward demeanour" and "quiet integrity" both on and off screen.
Gary Cooper: "Coop" was synonymous with the rugged, honourable American hero. His tall stature and "understated acting style" in films like High Noon (1952) set the standard for the strong, silent Western lead
Iconic Leading Ladies
Maureen O'Hara: Often called the "Queen of Technicolour," she was a favourite of John Ford and starred in classics like Rio Grande, McLintock!, and Big Jake.
Barbara Stanwyck: A versatile powerhouse who starred in numerous Westerns, including Forty Guns, Cattle Queen of Montana, and the long-running TV series The Big Valley.
Jane Russell: She gained instant fame in the controversial film The Outlaw and later starred alongside Bob Hope in the popular comedy-western The Paleface.
Grace Kelly: Before becoming a princess, she played the Quaker wife of Gary Cooper in Noon, one of the most celebrated Westerns ever made. She was wow, wow, and more wow
Brigitte Bardot: The French "sex kitten" ventured into the genre in the comedic Western Shalako.
Yvonne De Carlo: Known for Frontier Gal and McLintock!, she later became famous as Lily Munster
Natalie Wood: Played the abducted niece in the legendary film The Searchers.
Raquel Welch: She brought a fierce presence to "Spaghetti Westerns" like 100 Rifles and Hannie Caulder, where she played a woman seeking revenge.
Side kicks
Walter Brennan: Known for his roles as the grizzled, often toothless old-timer, winning multiple Supporting Actor Oscars.
George "Gabby" Hayes: The quintessential 1930s-40s sidekick, recognized for his whiskered, comedic, and loyal characters.
Strother Martin was famous for character roles in the latter part of his career; he brought a distinct flavour to Westerns.
Edgar Buchanan: Known for his gravelly voice and roles in both film and TV Westerns.
Jack Elam: Often played memorable, tough, or eccentric villains and sidekicks.
Woody Strode: A former NFL star and decathlete, Strode became a powerhouse in the genre. He is most renowned for the title role in John Ford's Sergeant Rutledge (1960), where he played a Black cavalry sergeant. He also appeared as one of the four leads in The Professionals (1966) and had a memorable cameo in the opening of Once Upon a Time in the West (196
.
I have over 150 westerns, all owing to my grandfather's introduction to and love of such movies.
googley
Apr 9, 2026, 11:15:40 AM
@VIX
Bullying on a grand scale gets turned into heroic storytelling. They come in, take their land, OUR land. Then they control the narrative to make it look justified. Resistance then becomes the crime.
Nothing changed....in 2026!!!!
Brerzerk
Apr 10, 2026, 9:47:32 PM
@VIX
@sgtdjones
@CricSham
Vixie mi bredrin it's more nuanced than that. We older ones may not have been as aware then. May not have had enough of other means of entertainment, valued the art over the story, and yes revelled in the triumph of di "unda-dawg" as narratives changed to reflect the stories you allude to. (7 mules fuh Sista Sarah, Trinity series, Hills run Red...) And, if you listen the story-lines) of some of the older movies you'll hear sarcastic and even plain digs at that exploitable system of "Pioneers" heading west and stealing lands. "The Sheriff is a N...! says lots more than those words. Buck n The Preacher shows 2 oppressed groups coming together to defeat the oppressor. Watch dem 2 and Dances with Wolf to see where the genre and your ideals meet.
BeatDball
Apr 11, 2026, 5:38:26 AM
@sgtdjones
Trevor Bardette, Arthur Hunnicutt & James Westerfield! 😎
VIX
May 29, 2026, 4:58:16 PM
@Brerzerk
Self hate is the bane of the Caribbean.
you see it everyday pon here.
velo
May 29, 2026, 6:09:36 PM
@VIX
Ithose native americans in those old movies were not really native americans either they were white men or women in wigs with some brown polish on their face and body.some of the most famous white hollywood actors portrayed native american characters.
pure white supremacist propaganda