Which is the more skillful bowler in red ball cricket? For me, if Keemo was given a look in to the test team, he would open bowling with Jayden and Alzharri would be first change and Shamar second change.

@PalsofMine

i don't think they're competing for the same spot. we can field four seamers and have greaves as the allrounder(i am still suspicious of his competencies on wickets not overwhelmingly in favor of batting but that is another story). mootie should be our spinner when the conditions suit it but you go in with your best bowlers, the bowlers you can guarantee will take 20 wickets

@PalsofMine

Keemo lasting entire test.....it would be miracle.....

I will have Holder above both in all formats...

Greaves bowling is not international standard....apart from few innings...his batting is below par....as of now...he is Mayers 2.0 .....

Keemo is very good bowler....but unproven at international level in all formats.....he was at one point..... taunted as death bowler...in white ball....

Best 4 bowlers in all formats...

Seales

Joseph

Shamar

Holder

In white ball..add on

Forde

Keemo

Both wicket takers

Greaves can be more handy as opener in ODI....

I would like to see keemo in the white ball setup.shamar joseph and jayden seles have leapfrogged alzharri in test cricket time for him to step up

@Onionman0

I guess Anderson Phillip is not good enough to be included in this conversation

@velo

Which suggest he is now the third option. And that's how I see it, he will always be in the top 3 pacers slot.

Keemo Paul is one of the best red ball bowlers in the region... sadly, his body keeps letting him down.

Here are his FC numbers:

Matches - 35

Wickets - 131

Avg. - 20.15

S/r - 38.7

Which other pacer in the region got numbers like that?

Once fit, he should be in or around the test team!

@grugru

In my view, Anderson Phillip, should definitely be in the conversation.

@Fivestar

we have seen anderson phillips in test cricket and he has not looked impressive

@velo

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/RGvW0p7KwCw

yuh cyah be serious homes

you're entitled to territory/island bias......but at least make it conversant with facts nah

@Jumpstart

you put a clip of one good delivery but 6 test matches 10 wkts avg 65 is that great? he might have improved these last few months i don't know we will have to see against quality batsmen not wi fc batsmen .but from what i saw in new zealand it was not impressive

should you not apply the same yardstick to Kemo?

they both played this season and who was the better bowler?

@velo

Kemo take any wickets like that in international cricket? And you forgot to mention how batsman friendly the pitches Anderson Phillips bowled on in nz were, where 400 was breached thrice and 500 once. And ironically Phillips had the best figures for thecWI bowlers in both innings of the 2nd test

@Jumpstart

I agree that Phillips must be part of any conversation and he cant be judged really by the NZ performances where even Seales struggled. In this FC season, he played one more match than Keemo who ironically did not play against the Academy, in theory the weakest team. If I were going for the top 5 seamers currently in the WI, Phillips is there as well as Keemo with Joseph x 2 and Seales. Perhaps what we need to do is rotate this top 5 to prevent over bowling and breakdowns as all of these names have suffered breakdowns in the recent past. My point, to which I would like a response, is that if Keemo is given a test, should he open bowling or come in as a change. I think that he is better with the new ball than either of the josephs

@Jumpstart

You can't be serious... Anderson Phillips nowhere near Keemo when it comes to red ball cricket.

You claiming Keemo never bowled anything close to that delivery.. well take a look at his first test wicket. Cleaned up Tamin with a similar delivery.

Just go to the 30 min mark.. when it comes to red ball Keemo moves it around both ways for fun. Something de others struggle to do. White ball cricket he's a runs truck.

https://youtu.be/7jHXcpNenf4?si=psuX9TPp-SQE2idX

@anthonyp

Dawg you comparing Tamim Iqbal with Kane Williamson? 😂 tamim does average over 40?

@Jumpstart

Lol gone from Keemo never bowled a ball like that in in international cricket to its just "Tamin Iqbal"

WI can't even produce a player of Tamin quality and yet yuh quick to diss de man? Ah guess in titland de likes of Lewis, Silva and Mohammed better 😂

Twist it and turn it all yuh want.. Anderson Phillip not in de same league with Keemo when it comes to red ball cricket.

@anthonyp

it is just tamim iqbal.....i see no lie there

@grugru

Top 4....I said...

Anderson Phillips....a whole hearted cricketer..both with ball and bat......but ranks 5th in hierarchy...a must ..in test XV...

@grugru

Could not agree more, consistently one of the top bowlers in the region but for some reason is very often disregarded.

All he needs is for confidence to be shown in him.

Greaves is kept for his batting ,fielding and general leadership plus being stingy enough when bowling.

@velo

Agreed , a good fc bowler, fit , but some players are not test material.

I really don't know how anyone could compare Keemo and Alzarri with a straight face. However i see this morphed into a more realistic and relevant comparison with Anderson Phillips.

@voiceofreason

...which should be between Kemo and Phillips

the question was if both were playing, who should get the new ball. No one has really responded to that.