Today in History
Five days in Hobart and the bottom of the ladder
At 53 for one, West Indies appeared to have survived the awkward part while chasing 161 against Scotland.
Kyle Mayers had gone, but Evin Lewis and Brandon King were finding the boundary. The pitch at Bellerive Oval was offering little dramatic assistance. Scotland were disciplined and confident, yet the two-time world champions still possessed Nicholas Pooran, Rovman Powell, Jason Holder, and a collection of cricketers paid handsomely to solve T20 problems around the world.
West Indies then lost seven wickets for 26. They were bowled out for 118 and beaten by 42 runs. Four days later Ireland chased 147 for the loss of one wicket, sending them home before the tournament's main round.
The shortest format had produced West Indies' most sudden collapse in status.
Scotland supply the first verdict
The 2022 competition required West Indies to qualify through an opening group with Scotland, Zimbabwe, and Ireland. That alone marked decline. The champions of 2012 and 2016 had finished poorly in 2021 and fallen far enough in the rankings to lose automatic passage to the Super 12.
The squad also represented a new era that had not properly begun. Chris Gayle and Dwayne Bravo were gone. Kieron Pollard had retired. Andre Russell and Sunil Narine were outside the group. Pooran, an immensely gifted batsman still finding his authority as captain, led a side caught between generations.
Scotland made 160 for five on 17 October, with George Munsey carrying his bat for 66. Holder took two wickets for 14 and later top-scored for West Indies with 38. Almost nobody else adjusted to Scotland's spinners.
Mark Watt, bowling from well behind the crease and changing angles with relish, took three for 12. Michael Leask copped two for 15. West Indies' middle order played a sequence of ambitious strokes that looked less like a chase than a queue.
Coach Phil Simmons did not hide behind the format. He called out "too many soft dismissals" and said the batsmen needed to wake up and act professionally.
West Indies beat Zimbabwe two days later, leaving all four teams level on points and turning the final match against Ireland into a direct contest for qualification.
Ireland remove the suspense
King made 62 not out, but West Indies only managed 146 for five, batting first. Gareth Delany’s leg-spin took three for 16. West Indies had once again failed to control a match against an associate nation.
Ireland did not stumble under the significance of the chase. Paul Stirling had trumped King’s knock with an unbeaten 66. Lorcan Tucker contributed 45 not out, and the target disappeared in 17.3 overs. The winning margin was a commanding nine wickets.
There was no unlucky boundary count, no rain calculation, and no late panic. Ireland were better.
The result made West Indies the fifteenth-ranked team in a sixteen-team tournament. It was the first time they had failed to reach the principal stage of a T20 World Cup. A competition they had once seemed uniquely qualified to rule no longer reserved them a seat among its leading sides.
Pooran stepped down as white-ball captain a month later. Simmons announced he would leave as coach. Cricket West Indies, in the meantime, commissioned an independent review led by Brian Lara, Mickey Arthur, and Patrick Thompson. The report found a broader failure of preparation, structure, and alignment between international and franchise cricket.
That distinction matters. The defeats were embarrassing, but treating Scotland and Ireland as anonymous minnows would conceal their achievement and excuse West Indies. Both opponents had developed coherent systems, understood their roles, and played the conditions. West Indies had more famous individuals. They did not have the better teams.
The 2012 champions had danced in Colombo. The 2016 champions had conquered Kolkata. But by 2022, the legend of West Indian T20 cricket had become a dangerous substitute for current evidence.
Four days in Hobart did not cause the fall. They merely made it impossible to look away.
Sources