Message Board Archives

HEADLINE: Windies squad for Sri Lanka tour

 
CaribbeanCricket.com May 24, 2018, 12:07:09 PM 

ST JOHN’S, Antigua – Top-order, left-handed batsman, Devon Smith returns to the WINDIES squad for the series against Sri Lanka. Wicket-keeper, Jamar Hamilton has also earned selection in the elite squad for the first time becoming the second Anguillan, behind Omari Banks to do so.
first time becoming the second Anguillan, behind Omari Banks to do so.

The confirmed squad is:
Jason Holder – captain
Devendra Bishoo
Kraigg Brathwaite
Roston Chase
Miguel Cummins
Shane Dowrich
Shannon Gabriel
Jamar Hamilton
Shimron Hetmyer
Shai Hope
Kieran Powell
Kemar Roach
Devon Smith


Commenting on the make-up of this squad, Chairman of Selectors, Courtney Browne said, “we have retained the core of the Test team as they remain competitive even after a tough series in New Zealand. Devon Smith had an outstanding year and players who excel to that degree should be recognized. We are trying to improve our top order batting performances.”

Browne also noted that “Jamar Hamilton comes into the squad after consecutive strong performances over the last three years and showed even better quality in the A Team series against the England Lions. We wish the team every success.”


Full Story

 
Drapsey May 24, 2018, 12:34:51 PM 

In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com

Top-order, left-handed batsman, Devon Smith returns to the WINDIES squad for the series against Sri Lanka. Wicket-keeper, Jamar Hamilton has also earned selection in the elite squad for the first time becoming the second Anguillan, behind Omari Banks to do so.

Wow, Pollo and VOR hit ecstasy (or whatever)!

Even more so that there's not a single Yardie in sight.

 
allan May 24, 2018, 1:12:36 PM 

What happen to Cornwall? Didn't he do well for the past 2 years also

 
anthonyp May 24, 2018, 1:15:06 PM 

In reply to Drapsey

Which yardie should be in the squad?

 
Maispwi May 24, 2018, 1:17:36 PM 

Browne also noted that “Jamar Hamilton comes into the squad after consecutive strong performances over the last three years


A strong performance in the last three years dat includes 237 runs at 16.92 last year. He must have averaged over 50 in dem 2 other years to get selected for de A team.

 
Str8_Drive May 24, 2018, 1:25:55 PM 

Who will open in the 1st test Devon or Powell ?

conventional wisdom would tell me Powell should, being the incumbent, but Devon always presents such interesting questions , why bring a man almost touching 37 into the squad unless you going to play him up front ?

 
dayne May 24, 2018, 1:34:03 PM 

Well Devon Smith as the saying goes, have more lives than a cat, I wish him well, but the Selectors are acting like the man who keeps on doing the same thing over and over again, but expects different results. So is Hamilton being selected for his wicket-keeping or batting?

 
imusic May 24, 2018, 1:45:29 PM 

Devon must have impressed in the batting camp.

Congrats Devon!

How does Gabriel make the squad? Based on what?

Is not like he was a leading wicket taker in the last PCL and he performed horribly on the tour of New Zealand

 
Courtesy May 24, 2018, 3:19:24 PM 

Unadultered madness. The entire selection panel should resign on this issue alone.

Devon Smith...a proven failure at test level.

There cannot be a heavy weighting attached to a first class competition which is way,way way, below standard.

And we're not talking about a 37 year old Lara, Viv or Shiv. We are talking about a first class shithound in Devon Smith.

The selectors are visionless.

 
solidrock May 24, 2018, 3:25:16 PM 

Why on earth is Bishoo in the squad? This is insanity!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Cornwall versus Bishoo is not even close re: value to our team. Cornwall everyday of the week.

Warrican versus Bishoo is not even close also!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 
silver May 24, 2018, 3:47:11 PM 

In reply to solidrock


Brother they hired a man all the way from PAKISTAN just to teach Bishman how to bowl a googly. What does this tell you
lol lol lol

 
Courtesy May 24, 2018, 3:52:16 PM 

In reply to silver

Brother they hired a man all the way from PAKISTAN just to teach Bishman how to bowl a googly. What does this tell you

lol lol lol

I rest my case on NoGooglyshoo. He continues to take my women and he is the best leg spinner in the Caribbean.

big grin

 
jacksprat May 24, 2018, 3:57:21 PM 

Oh well.....Browne has dropped the ball - again!!! :

Forward with the Star Team -- a cast of has beens, never weres and never will bes

I thought the HPC was supposed to be the magic bullet to propel the Star Team back into relevance, if not championship contention?

Isn't that what Hilaire promised us almost a decade ago?

Now Browne has retrieved a recycled failure from the garbage heap of West Indies cricket. Talk about the lack of vision, and a plan : :

PACK OF JOKERS.....NOTHING HAS CAHANGED!!!!!

 
Courtesy May 24, 2018, 4:09:02 PM 

2018 and fellas still using gramophone and playing 78 vinyl which is stuck in one grove.

Cho man!!!...move spooning on.

 
BeatDball May 24, 2018, 4:11:47 PM 

I gWIne march with this team! Forward march! Naysayers, step aside & watch & mih nah joke!.
cool

 
sandisha May 24, 2018, 4:13:03 PM 

Those selectors were either drunk or charged when they picked the team. They are so inconsistent that I can't even predict them. Last year they brought Gayle to England and New Zealand, today he's been replaced by another grandpa by the name of Devon Smith. This is a home series and I don't see the need for Jamar Hamilton, since he had a disappointing season and, Shai Hope is on the team as a standby wicketkeeper. Pure madness!

 
Gun_Play May 24, 2018, 4:31:03 PM 

I would not have gone back to Devon.

Goodluck to him though.

This is your last chance, please take it.

Where is kemo Paul!!!!!

Paul is the glue we need to strengthen our bowling and batting.

 
sandisha May 24, 2018, 4:40:53 PM 

In a home series Commins should be replaced by a young Jamaican speedgun I sawby the name of Roshan Thomas, Bishoo by another promising young quick from Guyana by name of Romario Shepherd, Devon Smith though he had a very good series but at 37, he doesn't have much left so Warrican would be a better selection and instead of Hamilton, who had a disappointing season, Conwall would make more sense. Jermaine Blackwood got a very raw deal I must admit

 
sunfish May 24, 2018, 5:02:52 PM 

I liked Blackwood because of his fearlessness and will miss him. I hope his absence is temporary.

Not sure why Hamilton is included, perhaps to keep Dowrich on his toes?

 
sunfish May 24, 2018, 5:22:51 PM 

I also think that Holder will bat at 6 and Hamilton and Powell will be left out. This combo gives 4 main bowlers and and 2 allrounders and I'm fine with that.. Bishoo and Roach are capable of giving 20 runs each down the order.

 
dayne May 24, 2018, 6:22:30 PM 

So why was Evan Lewis not given a call up, he has proven that he is an international player, in contrast Devon Smith has not proven that he is not so far.

 
jacksprat May 24, 2018, 6:34:17 PM 

Evan Lewis is in the T20 squad to play the Rest Of the world the day before in England.

 
anandgb May 24, 2018, 6:56:38 PM 

In reply to Drapsey

lol lol lol

 
camos May 25, 2018, 5:09:41 AM 

Brung election night surprise.
wink

 
Slipfeeler May 25, 2018, 5:38:44 AM 

In reply to sandisha

Definitely we will have our hands full against Sri Lankan, apart from Braithwaite, Hope and Chase, squad is mediocre-laden.

 
VIX May 25, 2018, 5:50:10 AM 

all this moaning and groaning for what??

wwho to put??

that's the best we got.

THe least crappiest of the crap big grin

 
Slipfeeler May 25, 2018, 6:20:12 AM 

In reply to Gun_Play

I forgot, you are right. How Keemo Paul not in this squad?

 
RemainsUnknown May 25, 2018, 6:46:57 AM 

In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com

Good luck to Smith & Hammy.

Do your BEST for the Windies.

 
BeatDball May 25, 2018, 7:29:27 AM 

In reply to sunfish JB & Evin will bound to be in the ODIs.

cool

 
googley May 25, 2018, 8:02:43 AM 

In reply to Slipfeeler

apart from Braithwaite, Hope and Chase, squad is mediocre-laden.


Braithwaite? lol lol



What happened to Ramdin?

 
Walco May 25, 2018, 8:31:14 AM 

Ambris should be in this squad ...

 
imusic May 25, 2018, 8:55:26 AM 

In reply to Walco

Ambris should be in this squad

Are they going to ensure he takes his batting stance at least 2 feet outside his crease?

 
Walco May 25, 2018, 9:49:17 AM 

In reply to imusic

Ambris has been a consistent performer at the first class level over the past few years. Barring injury, he should be persisted with and given a run

 
imusic May 25, 2018, 10:15:05 AM 

In reply to Walco

Maybe move the stumps further back when he’s batting then?

And you talking about consistent FC performer.

So why is Cornwall not in the team?

Why is Nikita Miller not in the team?

No one has performed more consistently in regional FC cricket over the years, in any discipline, than Nikita Miller. If Devon Smith can get a recall and that’s the criteria being used for selection, how do you explain Miller’s omission?

By the same token, how do you explain Shannon Gabriel’s selection?

 
Walco May 25, 2018, 10:56:42 AM 

In reply to imusic

Maybe move the stumps further back when he’s batting then?

lol lol lol Ease up nuh man ...

So why is Cornwall not in the team?

Man need to lose weight and get in shape. Where can you hide Cornwall on a cricket field? Slips? What happens when the ball is edged past him or the wicketkeeper? The keeper runs after it? I'm rooting for Cornwall though ...

Why is Nikita Miller not in the team?

Killa is on the ODI team. Apparently the selectors don't see him as a test bowler ...

By the same token, how do you explain Shannon Gabriel’s selection?

The Angel has one thing that no other WI bowler has right now--consistent heat that can frighten people. He has had a run of poor form recently, but he should be persisted with based on his form over the past few years. If Gabriel had been on the WC Qualifier team, WI would have won that tournament with ease. Most of those associate batsmen would have been running towards the square leg umpire in response to Gabriel's heat.

 
jacksprat May 25, 2018, 11:48:38 AM 

In reply to Walco

The Angel has one thing that no other WI bowler has right now--consistent heat that can frighten people.

Ever heard of Leveridge, the Jamaican pacer?

He has real heat & frightens everybody, including his own 'keeper because he needs radar to find the stumps big grin big grin

 
imusic May 25, 2018, 12:03:02 PM 

In reply to Walco

Regarding Cornwall, Miller, and Gabriel....we talking performance in regional FC (4 day AKA PCL) cricket.

Cornwall and Miller are among the most consistent performers. Gabriel the opposite.

They claim regional performance should be rewarded. They never say fatness should be banned. They never say crocs should be banned from the test team (unless dem fraid Marlon).

The selection inconsistency except for one area is staggering

 
doublecentury May 25, 2018, 1:29:16 PM 

No places for ramdin( the best keeper batsman) lewis( the best opener)russell( the best all rounder) warrican( the best spinner)Darren bravo ( the best batsman) or Cornwall ( the best spinner allrounder)

None injured all playing all in good form.

Who selects the selectors and tells them who to select? May list above are too outspoken, too uppity or too fat.

 
Walco May 25, 2018, 3:35:18 PM 

In reply to jacksprat

lol lol lol

 
moneybrain May 25, 2018, 3:52:28 PM 

In reply to jacksprat

Wha yuh say the SL captain already starting out with a spinner for Dev. lol

 
tc1 May 25, 2018, 5:16:28 PM 

In reply to imusic

are you seriously comparing Miller and Cornwall to Gabriel. The angel is the quickest bowler we have.

 
Judgement May 25, 2018, 6:17:42 PM 

In reply to doublecentury

No places for ramdin( the best keeper batsman) lewis( the best opener)russell( the best all rounder) warrican( the best spinner)Darren bravo ( the best batsman) or Cornwall ( the best spinner allrounder)

Are you sure you follow cricket?
1) Lewis has openly stated he does not wish to play Test cricket and has not even played a 4-day tournament to qualify?
2) Russell has repeatedly stated he is unable to play Test cricket because of a fitness issue (that excuse would automatically disappear if CWI offered him IPL type money i'm sure) and has not played 4 day cricket for years to even be in contention.
3) Darren Bravo has been offered countless opportunities to qualify to return to the squad but has chosen overseas leagues.
4) Cornwall is required to lose weight and CWI have invested in numerous health and fitness regimes by high profile US institutions but he keeps putting weight on.
5) Warrican is being prepared for the A team tour to England.

 
doublecentury May 26, 2018, 2:42:01 AM 

In reply to Judgement

And perhaps you should examine how we have wanted resources.

Bravo plays club cricket and is deliberately snubbed by ttcb...try naming the countless opportunities he has declined.

That our best players no longer are interested in employment by wicb is the issue to be considered.

Selections of jamar Hamilton and Devon smith tells a lot...there will be few attendees.


You forgot your excuse for ignoring Ramdin razz

 
analyst-kid May 26, 2018, 3:12:36 AM 

In reply to sandisha

In a home series Commins should be replaced by a young Jamaican speedgun I sawby the name of Roshan Thomas,


Cummins is your best bowler in home conditions statswise and he did quite well against a powerful NZ batting lineup. He has to be given a chance to prove himself in a full series.

 
WICFan May 26, 2018, 3:19:02 AM 

I would like to have seen Raymon Reifer included and Sharmah Brooks.

West Indies A have a tour of England next month so maybe Blackwood, Miller, Reifer, Ambris will be on that tour.

 
InHindsight May 26, 2018, 3:22:12 AM 

In reply to jacksprat



Hilaire is gone Cameron is in. Deal with your devils.
lol lol lol

 
dayne May 26, 2018, 4:51:05 AM 

In reply to WICFan

The soap opera that is called " WI cricket " continues. Miller should only be on an A team tour if he is an assistant coach, those tours should be to develop future players. Hopefully on that tour guys like Springer, Paul, Hemraj, Odean Smith, Campbell and Bramble are included.

 
Judgement May 26, 2018, 7:57:46 AM 

In reply to doublecentury

Are YOU aware of what CWI have done to bring Darren Bravo back? You only hear and moan about what is in the media (oh yes so that MUST be true!). The fact is, Darren Bravo HAS been offered an olive branch and he has chosen not to take it. What is happening with the TTCB and Darren Bravo is a separate issue but the fact remains that he has deliberately made himself unavailable for CWI selection when he chose PSL and BPL and every other overseas league under the sun. So you're saying chase after an idiot that doesn't value his career or his worth than work with young men who actually WANT to play for West Indies??

And as for Ramdin, it is his bad attitude that is keeping him out of cricket and that is a fact. If you are so insistent on living in the past, then call for Shiv and Desmond Haynes and everyone else under the sun to return. Same way you lot shouted for Rovman Powell to be included in the ODI squad and what exactly has he achieved after all that?? The selectors are trying to build a TEAM that want to play for the West Indies not build a team around a bunch of arrogant divas that don't bother to show up to practice and think they are bigger than the game - as if we were really on some incredible winning streak having the great Ramdin and Bravo in the squad all these years right?! rolleyes rolleyes rolleyes rolleyes

 
doublecentury May 27, 2018, 3:10:23 AM 

Joel warrican took 31 wickets in the recent A series against England lions .

Dominic Bess took 5 wickets

Which one was promoted to a test team? rolleyes

 
doublecentury May 27, 2018, 3:13:54 AM 

In reply to Judgement

Judgement you rush to judgement based on attitude?

Both darren Bravo and dinesh Ramdin are both highly dedicated professionals whose careers were destroyed by Cameron....now that’s a fact.if they are lost to West Indies it was not their choice.

Olive branch baloney you may believe but it’s just not true.and no my sources are not the press..Trinidad cricket is an unholy mess caused by the Administrators and Wicb..You are familiar that Dave personally intervened to prevent Bravo playing in a practice match and the Trinidad squad?

You are entitled to disagree as there are do few facts in the public domain ( but we do know about the lack of due process) but you shouldn’t assume I have no knowledge because I disagree with you.

 
doublecentury May 27, 2018, 8:07:58 AM 


And as for Ramdin, it is his bad attitude that is keeping him out of cricket and that is a fact. If you are so insistent on living in the past, then call for Shiv and Desmond Haynes and everyone else under the sun to return”

Why not bring back a 36 year old averaging under 25 and then tell me the selectors are looking to the future.

You guys eat bs.