Message Board Archives

In this, the most unpredictable of the six seasons of  the Hero Caribbean Premier League so far, organizers will be rueing the option to forgo the Decision Review System (DRS) given several bemusing calls by umpires thus far in the tournament. Arguably, the most blatant indiscretion came as the Tallawahs hosted the Knight Riders in Florida. In this instance, Adam Zampa having apparently trapped Darren Bravo plumb in front had his appeal dismissed by standing umpire Joel Wilson.

The level of officiating in CPL18 has been substandard, leading to several instances in which viewers and players alike would have been wishing for DRS. Which begs the question as to why the Decision Review System is not being employed in CPL18. Yes, the umpires “are only humans”; obviously “they only get one look at it” and thankfully “we have replays”. But then, what excuse does CPL organizers have for whisking available technology aside, on this, one of the biggest T20 stages and allowing human error to affect the outcomes of games to such an extent. Were these not the reasons for this technology-development, to eliminate the level of human errors?

The system would have been good even for the perception of the CPL, which is also without a speed radar this season. Although each team would only be allotted one review per innings; the fact that a review cannot be lost if the decision remains umpire’s call means that if a team doesn’t have any reviews at any point of an innings it would be on the team. Even if the umpire made an incorrect decision, the perception of this would be a team wasting their review previously and not necessarily a poor decision by the umpire. Entering into the latter stages of the tournament, we hope for the quality and value of the Hero Caribbean Premier League, that the standard of officiating improves.

I wondered why posters are ignoring this article until I took a read.

So much questions asked by the writer when it is so obvious that the only answer is "cost"

I don’t think they have DRS in IPL either

In reply to Kay

"they' can't influence the result in there is DRS

In reply to imusic

The IPL just started using it from this year. PSL was the only league using it before...

In reply to Kay

Thanks for the correction. I support the use of technology in the game. To me there’s no valid excuse NOT to have it.

Why aren't the fans demanding for DRS?

Not having DRS is not the issue. The rank incompetence of the umpires is what’s undermining the CPL. Marginal decisions and one or two poor decisions are generally acceptable but there have been too many glaring bad decisions. You could have called the Bravo lbw in real time from the TV.