The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Message Board Archives

Odean Smith ...???? Wasted selection ??

 
CITYBOY 2022-09-15 17:14:25 

Not that it matters but I liked Odean Smith .. I really thought that he would develop into a good T 20 player..
Sadly he is not gonna do it...
His bowling is off .. hardly tops 140 and his batting is pathetic ( for want of a better word)..
Well he only have himself to blame as his stock / worth has drastically dropped ..

 
natty_forever 2022-09-15 17:24:51 

In reply to CITYBOY

I SHare yoUR sentiments.

 
Raskil 2022-09-15 17:25:15 

In reply to CITYBOY

He needs to bat like he’s not in a very big hurry.

These sky hitters need to play shots along the ground before OZ

 
Jumpstart 2022-09-15 19:13:10 

In reply to CITYBOY

believes his press way too much.....much in the icon style.....we see where that got him, two world cup finals aside

 
Dukes 2022-09-15 19:46:25 

In reply to CITYBOY

Odean Smith played all 3 matches in the T 20 series against New Zealand recently his most recent 3 T 20 Internationals.
In those 3 matches he bowled 4 overs at the death(defined as overs 17-20)
He took 3 wickets- and conceded 28 runs in those 4 overs.The 3 wickets were Kane Williamson, Glen Phillips and Jimmy Neesham.

The problem I have with you guys is you operate in a fact free zone and bloviate a tremendous amount of BULLCRAP with absolutely no reference to objective evidence.You are not alone so do not feel I am targeting you.Jumpy went in feet first into this bashing of Odean.He is 25 years old and learning his trade.

We have a great class of 2016 with Hetty,AlJo,the real McCoy, Odean, Carty and Keemo.

 
natty_forever 2022-09-15 19:51:59 

In reply to Dukes

Sanity.

 
CITYBOY 2022-09-15 21:46:32 

In reply to Dukes

Evidence suggests he is a wasted pick ... you are as good as your last innings ..
where does it show since the NZ series he has built on the success he had???
He drives the bus carefully one day and the next day or days he runs amok..
My mindset is a bit different .. I accept one and 2 failures but damn when it’s consistent it becomes a habit .
The
class of 2016 is deep into a sixth year .. where is the consistency??
Al jo seems to be settling down and so is Mc Coy...hopefully they all come good at some point ... 2026 is not far off

We have to qualify and I think we play 3 games to do that ... can Odean Smith he trusted to win 1 game .. just asking !!!

 
Dukes 2022-09-15 21:56:10 

In reply to CITYBOY


Evidence suggests he is a wasted pick ... you are as good as your last innings .

The New Zealand series was the most recent T 20 series that we played.It was last month!!!!!

 
CITYBOY 2022-09-15 23:09:48 

In reply to Dukes

I know bro but he has played 4 CPL games or is it 5 ??

 
JamMack 2022-09-15 23:21:44 

Odean Smith vs Andre Russell, Who is a better batsman?
Odean Smith vs Andre Russell. Who is a better bowler? shock

 
Raskil 2022-09-15 23:40:04 

In reply to JamMack

Russell did well for the West Indies.
We thank him for his services.

He’s now a league mercenary


He’s not as good as he once was.

Accept, move on.

Bravo did.

 
Barry 2022-09-15 23:49:37 

In reply to Raskil

He answers- he’s still better than Odean cool

 
Dukes 2022-09-15 23:52:16 

In reply to CITYBOY

I know bro but he has played 4 CPL games or is it 5 ??


We are picking a man to play in T 20 Internationals.
You want to ignore how a man performed in T 20 Internationals and determine his fate based on a lower standard of cricket.
I can not be too harsh on you because that is exactly what the West Indies selectors did wrt Chanderpaul vs Athereton in 1995 in England.

 
Raskil 2022-09-15 23:54:21 

In reply to Barry

We have at least 6 genuine young very talented all rounders. If they don’t get chances who will take over when Russell calls retirement very soon?

 
Logic 2022-09-17 06:07:22 

In reply to Dukes

Why do you even bother. Some of these folk got the attention span of a fly. The last match they see defines the player

 
CITYBOY 2022-09-17 08:18:47 

In reply to Logic

The last few matches should define in this case

 
CITYBOY 2022-09-17 08:26:09 

In reply to Dukes

Sir. Odean last few games has not reflected what he did against NZ ..
Was that performance a one time thing??
Only time will tell .. but let him prove me wrong ..
Here is a valid ( maybe ) point ..
The IPL is the motherlode of riches to T 20 cricketers...and hundreds want to be there...
Odean is not shaping up too good for this ..maybe he thinks he is a shoo in..it defies logic that Odean would not try to impress with match winning performances..

Anyway let’s see how it all plays out .

 
Lungidi2017 2022-09-17 20:44:57 

In reply to Raskil

6? Who all?

 
Raskil 2022-09-17 22:01:24 

In reply to Lungidi2017

Odean
Shepherd
Allen
Drakes
Akeal
Kyle
Sinclair
Paul
...

 
Brerzerk 2022-09-17 23:05:18 

In reply to Raskil
how well is well? Stuepssss
Also a man plays well in an international series 'bout 40 days ago and is now having a lil chubble in a franchise
set-up under 'dirant couch' in a different set-up and it counts for more than the international matches? Oh well.
which is couch n who is coach? Unca Fill???

 
Raskil 2022-09-17 23:11:46 

In reply to Brerzerk

Sinclair and Jr Sinclair two different people

Sinclair started out as an opening batsmen

 
Avatar 2022-09-18 03:03:39 

Would have preferred Russell instead of him...but who knows
he might surprise us down under!!

 
CITYBOY 2022-09-30 00:27:37 

Plain as day !!!!!!
Plus quite a few more ...
As I always say “” prove me wrong “”

 
bird 2022-09-30 03:39:13 

In reply to CITYBOY

You can pull a hand full of games and give stats, but what every one see is that this guy is piss poor on a consistent basis, and has no mental strength

 
grugru 2022-09-30 12:38:56 

I belive Shepherd justified his non selection and as for Smith? It was among the worst last overs I have ever seen in t20 The my man completely fell apart.
shock

 
b4u8me2 2022-09-30 15:06:59 

In reply to CITYBOY


you are as good as your last innings


Such a statement is always bull. That would mean a player isn't good once he failed in his last inning. What then would you say of Don Bradman whose last inning was a duck?

 
b4u8me2 2022-09-30 15:11:46 

In reply to Raskil


He needs to bat like he’s not in a very big hurry.


Maybe the teams he play for need to stop sending him in to bat like he is in a hurry. Take the last match for example. Match slipping away from GAW and they held Smith back until the required rate was almost 30 runs an over and only 17 balls left in the inning. How else is he to bat in such a situation?