The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Anybody willing to put Value on Sammys

Page: previous  1 24 5 6 next 
Cheeks 9/26/24, 1:49:12 PM
Cheeks avatar image

debut: 12/3/02
15,598 runs

In reply to Jumpstart

the massive decline in west indian performances can be attributed to sammy's ascension and the behaviors of the board that caused it


Hahahahahahahahaha. Now you are just a lying skunt.

FFS.

I posit that the massive decline is due to D Ramnarine's combative hateful nonsense...and 'ascension' of a few indivduals financial interests over the sustainability Windies cricket.
- edited -
Jumpstart 9/26/24, 1:52:52 PM
Jumpstart avatar image

debut: 11/30/17
11,248 runs

In reply to Cheeks

his limited success as CPL captain/ coach


what success? dude had Kevin Pietersen in his team one year and still could not make the playoffs
Jumpstart 9/26/24, 1:59:19 PM
Jumpstart avatar image

debut: 11/30/17
11,248 runs

In reply to Cheeks

Hahahahahahahahaha. Now you are just a lying skunt.

FFS.

I posit that the massive decline is due to D Ramnarine's combative hateful nonsense...and 'ascension' of a few indivduals financial interests over the sustainability Windies cricket.

not debating any emotional dottie drivel with you homes. fact is under gayle, the captain sammy replaced, we beat england for the first time in 11 years, won a test in SA for the first and only time, did not lose in nz for the first time in 13 years and would have won or drew the test series in australia if the umpiring was better(a series where the last wicket, 33 runs adrift from the target was an umpiring error by billy bowden and also where 3 west indians scored test hundreds with gayle scoring back to back centuries, bravo scoring his second test century in australia and adrian bharath scoring a hundred on debut). does darren sammy have anything equivalent to that?
- edited -
powen001 9/26/24, 3:43:24 PM
powen001 avatar image

debut: 11/26/06
62,227 runs

In reply to Jumpstart

and that is the issue genius. the massive decline in west indian performances can be attributed to sammy's ascension and the behaviors of the board that caused it.


So you start following West Indies cricket in 2015 or so?

casuse I cant get past that first sentence
powen001 9/26/24, 3:47:03 PM
powen001 avatar image

debut: 11/26/06
62,227 runs

In reply to Onionman0

Head Coach in franchisee and international team.....two totally different........ comparison between two ....chalk and cheese......

Franchisee team is built around few very good/ great foreign T20 players..... with some locals....club and international players..... it's more a commercial entertainment event.......players are picked for commercial success, if a player or coach fail....kicked out next season...


with all due respect Onionman..

and I am serious


that is smoke and mirrors and actually makes my point all the more for me.

He still has to lead, manage now..not just Lucians , not just brothers from the region...but players from so called better set up infrastructural teams and races and cultures and practices...and get them all to produce.

I say he has been doing this so far...and funny enough the FOREIGN commentators have been saying it too.

I aint blind nor deaf-

I am keen to get posters to be honest as to why Sammy can do no good ever in their eyes.
powen001 9/26/24, 3:50:46 PM
powen001 avatar image

debut: 11/26/06
62,227 runs

let me throw this one in here to boot.

Stadium named after him

and their newly crowned Sprint Queen referenced him as a Local Hero as well.

All I am saying is that-

Sammy's story should be inspirational to everyone who has been told..you aint good enough, you aint talented enough and you will fail...and yet he somehow keeps achieving against all the odds.

that is a life story ( that still aint finished) that should be applauded and encouraged.

This is the SAME Sammy that stood up to Cameron btw ...and went on in 2016 to win that World Cup
Jumpstart 9/26/24, 4:00:18 PM
Jumpstart avatar image

debut: 11/30/17
11,248 runs

In reply to powen001
et me throw this one in here to boot.

Stadium named after him

and their newly crowned Sprint Queen referenced him as a Local Hero as well.

All I am saying is that-

Sammy's story should be inspirational to everyone who has been told..you aint good enough, you aint talented enough and you will fail...and yet he somehow keeps achieving against all the odds.

Homes. nobody thought steve waugh was any good when he started off. but he managed to turn himself into a great cricketer through will and a healthy dose of badmind. that is who people should be inspired by. steve's own brother, mark, said openly that he deserved a shot at aussie selection before steve

This is the SAME Sammy that stood up to Cameron btw ...and went on in 2016 to win that World Cup

bravo, pollard, gayle and russell had stood up to cameron a year before that. Bravo, gayle and pollard in india and again gayle and russell when the world cup team was announced, gayle openly accusing the board under cameron of victimising pollard and bravo and picking a second string team. When the board under the windward islands hydra was doing the same thing as cameron, fighting and exiling senior players, where was Darren Julius Garvey Sammy eh
- edited -
Jumpstart 9/26/24, 4:52:54 PM
Jumpstart avatar image

debut: 11/30/17
11,248 runs

In reply to powen001

Stadium named after him

ent devon smith have a pavilion named after him after an absolutely nothing career
Cheeks 9/26/24, 5:16:50 PM
Cheeks avatar image

debut: 12/3/02
15,598 runs

In reply to Jumpstart

Yeah the 'Dottie' narrative was bound to come out. You've been sussed out. My last on this is that..Windies decline started looooooong before Gayle or Sammy for that matter. You could bugger off with your revisionist nonsense. If you read what you are actually writing about how many firsts (a list of really low bar items if you ask me) happened under Gayle...then it clearly spoke to climbing out of a hole. You so hateful you tying up yourself in knots.
- edited -
Onionman0 9/26/24, 5:18:47 PM
Onionman0 avatar image

debut: 3/6/20
4,272 runs

In reply to Cheeks



https://www.espncricinfo.com/records/tournament/averages-batting-bowling-by-team/world-t20-2015-16-10291?team=4

Sammy total contribution....12 runs@ 2.66 with bat.
And 3 overs 31 runs 1 wicket @31 r.o 10....

If this stats makes any sense.....I bow down to your observation that What I stated was non sense....
- edited -
Jumpstart 9/26/24, 5:20:50 PM
Jumpstart avatar image

debut: 11/30/17
11,248 runs

In reply to Cheeks

if you read my above posts, the dottie contraption was always there. its they who appointed the imposter as captain
- edited -
nick2020 9/26/24, 5:24:16 PM
nick2020 avatar image

debut: 7/2/12
29,073 runs

In reply to Jumpstart

You are moving the goal post all over the field.

Lara's record speaks for itself. What was his test record as captain? What was his ODI record as captain?

You are such a homeboy instead of accept any failings, shortcomings, and criticisms you project this ridiculous stance that the Trinis did nothing wrong. And that weakens any point you are making.

Lara being one of the greatest cricketers ever means the teams he was cappo of were already miles better than what Sammy had to work with. Lara was a crappy captain.

I don't think Sammy was crappy. But I am not going to fight anyone on the issue.
Cheeks 9/26/24, 5:27:12 PM
Cheeks avatar image

debut: 12/3/02
15,598 runs

In reply to Jumpstart

Yeah..you've been sussed out. I don't deal well with dishonesty. All well and good to ignore facts and present opinions, but to STATE that Windies decline started with Sammy is just a nasty lie that any casual cricket fan can refute and speaks to your moral compass. I done.
- edited -
InHindsight 9/26/24, 5:27:27 PM
InHindsight avatar image

debut: 2/24/07
12,028 runs

All I sayin is dat a chain is as strong as its weakest link.


Burn dem Sammy!
nick2020 9/26/24, 5:28:43 PM
nick2020 avatar image

debut: 7/2/12
29,073 runs

In reply to Onionman0

https://www.espncricinfo.com/records/tournament/averages-batting-bowling-by-team/icc-world-twenty20-2012-13-6856?team=4

He was a specialist cappo in the second world cup.

He contributed meaningfully in the first.
Jumpstart 9/26/24, 5:44:57 PM
Jumpstart avatar image

debut: 11/30/17
11,248 runs

In reply to nick2020

Lara's record speaks for itself. What was his test record as captain? What was his ODI record as captain?

You are such a homeboy instead of accept any failings, shortcomings, and criticisms you project this ridiculous stance that the Trinis did nothing wrong. And that weakens any point you are making.

blah blah blah....yes lara was whitewashed by sa, a tour sabotaged by typical wicb pigheadeness....the same type of pig headedness that saw gayle removed and sammy given the role, beaten in nz by 13 players, beaten by south africa, aus and england....by then all teams that were much better than us. Contrary to popular belief, when we lost in england in 2000, australia a few months later, pakistan and SA in 2001 and also the sri lanka brownwash later that year, nz and India 2002, NZ IN 2005, Lara wasn't skipper. adams was captain in the year 2000, hooper in 2001, lara in 2003-2005(we lost to south africa, england and australia during that period) chanderpaul for the entirety of 2005. Can't talk about lara's example and record and totally ignore the incompetence of sammy as captain. as i said, my dog could have captained the dream teams that won the 2012 and 2016 world cups. sammy's only creditable performance was against team going through the following
Taylor says he was 'undermined' by senior teammates during the 2012 tour of the West Indies and claims he overheard Jacob Oram - who was a Central Districts teammate - tell Kyle Mills "I told you those f**kers were going to drop you" when the bowler missed selection for the fourth ODI.

“In terms of being undermined, that West Indies trip was actually worse than the Sri Lankan tour when it all came to a head. Some of the senior players would be down the back of the bus talking really loudly to people back home in New Zealand - the likes of Heath Mills - about me and the support staff.”


https://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/cricket/black-caps/cricket-black-caps-great-ross-taylors-racism-claim-outlined-in-new-book/4CNPTPGQIAISQN3ZDSTMHTLD6Q/
- edited -
Onionman0 9/26/24, 5:48:12 PM
Onionman0 avatar image

debut: 3/6/20
4,272 runs

In reply to powen001

that is smoke and mirrors and actually makes my point all the more for me.

He still has to lead, manage now..not just Lucians , not just brothers from the region...but players from so called better set up infrastructural teams and races and cultures and practices...and get them all to produce.


You are entitled to your opinion.....but

Facts are facts....

Franchisee team are owned by private individuals....teams have marque players....head coach knows acts within parameters not to antagonise any big player, as it impacts marketing.....

No head coach.... forget about Sammy ....transgress harming the commercial impact of franchise team.....

While working with national teams...Head Coach has much more freedom.....from choosing the team.... playing XI...... strategy.....

Sammy does not have credentials to be head coach according to CWI advertisement...

As coach, his team selection has been totally biased.....

Failed in ODI qualification in Zimbabwe....
Failed in World Cup T20

Few wins in meaningless T20....
Waiting for ODI series..... then...this discussion will move forward.....
- edited -
Onionman0 9/26/24, 6:07:01 PM
Onionman0 avatar image

debut: 3/6/20
4,272 runs

In reply to nick2020

Yes....he did meaningful contribution in 2012.... specially in final.....

2016, he passed his used by date.... understood his time gone.... became a rebel....now awarded with head coach job...
nick2020 9/26/24, 6:07:48 PM
nick2020 avatar image

debut: 7/2/12
29,073 runs

In reply to Jumpstart

Again what was his record?

I guess you care more about the internet an articles when it suits. Here is one:

However, many considered Lara’s innings to be a selfish one – Ricky Ponting was particularly critical of it. "It's generally not the way we play our cricket," he said. "Their whole first innings might have been geared around one individual performance and they could have let a Test match slip because of it. They ran out of time in the game - that's not the way the Australian team plays."

Former England captain Tony Greig too seemed to echo Ponting’s views, even attacking Lara’s captaincy credentials. "I'm certainly not raving about the innings. I have to praise it for the sheer fact that he stayed in for so long but it wasn't an innings that you could be in awe of. It was clear he had the record in mind and was just going to keep on grinding it out until he got there. As far as I'm concerned that is not a good way to play the game, especially when you're the captain. It shows that Brian Lara is not a very good captain," he said.


Source

What is next? Pollard isn't a sledger? Narine never pelt?
Jumpstart 9/26/24, 6:13:58 PM
Jumpstart avatar image

debut: 11/30/17
11,248 runs

In reply to nick2020

two people out of the entirety of the world called the record selfish.
Brian Lara was hailed by the world's media for his recent 400 not out score against England in Antigua in the final Test of the 2004 Cable and Wireless Series. Here are a selection of tributes, from the press of the United Kingdom and India:

THE DAILY TELEGRAPH (UK): "Lara's achievement is a feat of amazing endurance every bit as much as one of skill. Probably, he is not the best player in the world anymore, but he is still the best at big scores. Given that he is 35 and carrying a pound or two more than in his youth, Lara is proof of the power of the mind - he was at the wicket for 13 hours, for heaven's sake. No man cuts the ball with such precision and along such angles; few drive with equal elan; only the cricketers of the subcontinent and Mark Waugh in the modern era, use their wrists so gleefully to ease the ball through leg-side spaces. Brian Lara is a cricketer who makes magic: the surprise is how long he remains able to sustain it."

MANCHESTER EVENING NEWS (UK): "That Lara regained the record playing in a West Indies side which is a shadow of their 1994 counterparts at the fag end of a miserable series for the hosts makes the achievement more rather than less remarkable. It is far from a perfect story but when the tide goes out on the current era of cricket only a few traces will be left - Shane Warne's twisting fingers, Sachin Tendulkar's graceful power and Lara's raised-bat aggression."

REDIFF.COM (INDIA): Indian, Pakistani stars hail Lara: "Amazing achievement," said Sachin Tendulkar, the man often racing the left-handed genius for the numero uno spot in the rankings. "One of the best batsman of my generation, if not the best ever. Such innings can never be planned, they just happen."

Sourav Ganguly: "Great knock," he said. "I was not going to be surprised if he crossed 400 and he did just that. When he is in full flow, there is no better sight in world cricket."
Virender Sehwag, the latest entry in the 300 club, said there was no comparison. "When Lara scored his 300 he was 24, I am 25," Sehwag said.

Pakistan skipper Inzamam-ul-Haq, also a member of the 300 club, said Lara's performance was out of this world and he has duly taken back what was his - the record of highest Test score.
Former Pakistan skipper and coach Javed Miandad said, "The score is not the great part of the innings, but the fact that he held the record, saw it being broken, and then snatched it back is what is so great about the innings. Any of the top three batsmen in the world like Sachin Tendulkar, Ricky Ponting, or Matthew Hayden could have done it if the conditions had suited them like they suited Lara. My guess is that one of the Indian batsmen or Inzamam-ul-Haq will break the record."

Compiled by the Sporting Life:

THE SUN (UK): "Brian Lara rewrote cricket history when he became the first batsman to score 400 in a Test."

DAILY MAIL (UK): "Brian Lara celebrated the 10th anniversary of his previous record hammering of England by again making the highest score in Test history with an unbeaten 400 yesterday in the final match of the series at St John's."

THE TIMES (UK): "To break the most famous of all batting records once might conceivably be ascribed to good fortune. To do it twice is proof of pure genius."

THE DAILY TELEGRAPH (UK): "World records are destined to be set by only a chosen few, so when Brian Lara reclaimed the world record Test score with an unbeaten 400 in Antigua yesterday, six months after it was taken off him by Australia's Matthew Hayden, something extraordinary was afoot."

THE GUARDIAN (UK): "Brian Lara promised West Indies cricket a legacy and, yesterday, in front of a cacophonous crowd at the Recreation Ground, each and every one of whom will tell their grandchildren they were there, he delivered, as if to order, the highest individual score in Test match history."

one was an uncouth oaf with serious alcohol problems earlier in his career and the other is scyld berry
nick2020 9/26/24, 6:15:03 PM
nick2020 avatar image

debut: 7/2/12
29,073 runs

In reply to Onionman0

2016, he passed his used by date.... understood his time gone.... became a rebel....now awarded with head coach job...


Awarded? He is not qualified?

Agreed on the rest. unfortunately we did not realize half that team we sent was passed the sell by date too.
nick2020 9/26/24, 6:15:56 PM
nick2020 avatar image

debut: 7/2/12
29,073 runs

In reply to Jumpstart

Does not make them wrong.

But we digress. He was a poor captain.
Jumpstart 9/26/24, 6:21:07 PM
Jumpstart avatar image

debut: 11/30/17
11,248 runs

In reply to nick2020

much better than Sammy....i can assure you of that. in fact the only captain lara wasn't better than in the last 32 years of wi cricket was Gayle
WalterWhite 9/26/24, 6:26:14 PM
WalterWhite avatar image

debut: 3/1/21
853 runs

In reply to powen001

So you start following West Indies cricket in 2015 or so?


The vile nature of these people is beyond comprehension. They never have anything to say about their nasty attitude so called stars but let them carry on.

No wonder the region will never get anywhere.
- edited -
Onionman0 9/26/24, 6:29:23 PM
Onionman0 avatar image

debut: 3/6/20
4,272 runs

In reply to nick2020

Awarded? He is not qualified?


CWI advertisment required amongst several qualification....Level 3 certification... Sammy doesn't have any.....CWI while appointing him .....stated Sammy would undergo Coaching training in Antigua.....but alas..

https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/daren-sammy-appointed-west-indies-white-ball-coach-andre-coley-to-take-charge-of-test-team-1375104

Sammy has coaching experience in the CPL and the PSL, but this will be his first assignment in international cricket. While Sammy is not a certified coach, Shallow pointed out that he fulfilled all the criteria necessary for a coaching role. "There's a different set of criteria that you know don't necessarily need to be a Level 3 [coach]," Shallow said. "It's ideal, but when we go through the different assessments, he certainly qualified to be the head coach, which is why he was shortlisted in the first place and then he was interviewed by a panel of five."
- edited -
Page: previous  1 24 5 6 next