The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

The Darren Sammy Issue!!

Jammal22 7/16/25, 8:54:28 PM
Jammal22 avatar image

debut: 3/13/22
126 runs

This isn't clickbait — it's a sincere and objective take on Darren Sammy.

Let me start by saying that I’m not here to bash anyone. I actually had the chance to meet Sammy in Jamaica, and he came across as friendly and approachable — someone you'd genuinely enjoy chatting with.

That said, when it comes to assessing his cricketing career and current coaching role, honesty is important. As a player, Sammy was average at best, but he had the good fortune to lead an exceptionally talented West Indies T20 team. With world-class players like Badree, Narine, Gayle, Samuels, Bravo, Pollard, and Russell in the squad, it's no surprise the team secured two T20 World Cup titles.

Unfortunately, it seems Sammy may have misread the situation — believing those triumphs were a product of his captaincy rather than the extraordinary talent around him. Since stepping into coaching, he's shown signs of being insecure and, at times, vindictive.

Under Rovman Powell, the T20 team was showing clear signs of improvement. But Sammy, perhaps feeling threatened or needing control, dismissed Powell — reportedly because Powell stood his ground.

Accepting the Test coaching role was another questionable move. Sammy should have focused solely on white-ball cricket, where he has more experience. Instead, he made sweeping changes to a fragile but improving Test batting lineup — a unit that had recently been making progress and winning important games. Sammy replaced the unit with his "friends," ignoring Jason Holder, a proven and respected player. In my view, this raises serious questions that suggest his actions were driven more by personal vindictiveness than by sound cricketing logic.

It’s becoming increasingly clear that Sammy may have overestimated his ability to single-handedly transform West Indies cricket. His decisions have backfired, and the results speak for themselves.

This isn't written out of malice — it's a call for reflection. Darren Sammy, if you truly care about the future of West Indies cricket, stepping down as Test coach might be the best decision you can make right now.
- edited -
Slipfeeler 7/16/25, 9:03:29 PM
Slipfeeler avatar image

debut: 12/22/15
8,397 runs

In reply to Jammal22

Nothing else to add, already well-said
Drapsey 7/16/25, 9:07:57 PM
Drapsey avatar image

debut: 12/26/07
34,911 runs

In reply to Jammal22

Are you making reference to the Peter Principle, which states that one is promoted to their level of incompetence?
Cricket_101 7/16/25, 9:20:26 PM
Cricket_101 avatar image

debut: 2/15/11
5,015 runs

In reply to Jammal22

Darren Sammy, if you truly care about the future of West Indies cricket, stepping down as Test coach might be the best decision you can make right now.


Scammy ain't going no where... Dah man is king... He was an avg. cricketer, whom was elevated to captain due to cronyism and now HC/CS.big grin
Chrissy 7/16/25, 9:40:14 PM
Chrissy avatar image

debut: 11/14/02
201,695 runs

In reply to Jammal22
Let me make this clear
West Indies needs a certified coach. End of story.
Castled 7/16/25, 10:08:34 PM
Castled avatar image

debut: 8/21/22
1,375 runs

Was there an official statement from CWI why Scammy was made all fromat coach? Is it cutting edge and scientific trend in world cricket? Was it consolidation to save money? Did CWI pull the idea out of their backsides?

FFS Scammy is not a trained coach with qualifications. Scammy groping like a teenager in a cat house.
voiceofreason 7/16/25, 10:28:02 PM
voiceofreason avatar image

debut: 1/20/04
91,937 runs

In reply to Jammal22

he made sweeping changes to a fragile but improving Test batting lineup —


I really do not understand how you marry fragile and improving in the same sentence. So they improving although they still fragile? They came from what position to fragile? You lost me there. Again please provide statistical evidence to show the batting was improving.

Sammy's 'white ball' tenure started roughly too and then stabilized. Rovman Powell is now performing like a Man possessed since Sammy relieved him of his burden and he holds no ill will towards Sammy.

Sammy is not going to cure all the ills that ail Windies cricket overnight. Just like others who have been given multiple test series to prove themselves, let Sammy get his opportunity to do the same.
- edited -
natty_forever 7/16/25, 11:51:29 PM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
61,033 runs

In reply to voiceofreason

Have we improved in ODIs and T20s under Sammy?
Blackbird 7/17/25, 2:27:20 AM
Blackbird avatar image

debut: 11/13/02
2,794 runs

In reply to Jammal22

Sammy DID NOT appoint himself or made himself the "Supremo" ....

Myles Bascombe as the DOC must take this hit. If the DOC cannot guide the Coach, then he is even more unfit than Sammy.
Fivestar 7/17/25, 2:42:13 PM
Fivestar avatar image

debut: 8/31/03
1,586 runs

In reply to Jammal22

One of the biggest problems with West Indies cricket is there's neither rhyme nor reason to many things they do. They are good at giving excuses though. There's always a damage control explanation for everything.
- edited -