CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums > The Rum Shop > Pierre , permaul, miller

Pierre , permaul, miller

Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 7:55 AM
Cant tell who is the most inocuous left arm spinner of the three shows how bad wi cricket has been that these three dominated wi first class cricket.
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 7:56 AM
@velo

One test Miller. War I can
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 8:19 AM
In reply to natty_forever

It might also be one Test Pierre
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 11:13 AM
In reply to velo

Interesting you leff out Warrican in yuh innocuous list.
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 11:36 AM
In reply to imusic

Warrican is not a great spinner either ive said that in the past. but he took his opportunities
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 11:56 AM
@velo

Permaul.....most probably debut vs India in India... unfortunately, he was overtaken by Bishoo....
Who burst into scene..... Permaul never got look in again...

Miller....played few white ball games but Benn was favoured.....

Peirre....Only 9 overs....on first day pitch.... defending 163....vs India....
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 12:27 PM
In reply to velo

And after 9 overs you can tell that Pierre won’t take his opportunity?

CORNVENIENTLY IGNORE that Warrican was appointed vice captain and get DROP and hardly bowl in the 1 match he did play against Australia.

SMH
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 12:32 PM
@imusic

Lol he is no Warrican.

But I don't think Pierre should worry... he plays for 27 franchise.
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 12:40 PM
@imusic

Only in the CWI would a player like Warrican be playing International cricket and be VC.
Hosein is the best spinner in the region. He works the crease, he works the angles, and he can hit a spot 4-5 times an over
I enjoyed watching the Indian leftie last night.
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 3:21 PM
In reply to imusic

how did he look against south africa a coolunlike some people here who seem to be on some insular territorial bs i'm not on that .i have nothing against the guy and i do not wish him to fail but i see nothing in his bowling that is my opinion.unlike what i see in hossein or motie early on .he might prove me wrong but i don't believe so
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 6:00 PM
In the WI, all a spinner has to do to be successful is, be mostly accurate and have a turning ball and a straight ball. The batters or the pitch will do the rest in order for them to get wickets. That's why they look so ordinary when they move up to the Rest level
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 9:23 PM
In reply to velo

Yeah, Miller got all of 1 test. Fantastic that you made the conclusion off on 1 single test.
Fri, Oct 3, '25 at 5:45 AM
In reply to rudebway

he only needed one test coolhe also played some one days two