How comes Tage and Athanaze can get selected after their poor performances and failures but Kirk McKenzie who shouldered the batting against the best test team in the world cannot get back after his failures? Another example of CWI failing young players.
Forums >
The Rum Shop >
Tage and Athanaze selected but what about McKenzie?
Tage and Athanaze selected but what about McKenzie?
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 9:52 AM
debut: Apr 30, '21
2,796 runs
@Slipfeeler
Brethren you cyan be serious!!! You just watch Nepal beat us and now India is kicking our asses and that’s the best solution you got???
Will Kirk even make JA first class team???
Brethren you cyan be serious!!! You just watch Nepal beat us and now India is kicking our asses and that’s the best solution you got???
Will Kirk even make JA first class team???
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 10:03 AM
In reply to WIfan26
Slips is faithful to his position that McKenzie deserves to play for WI. Unfortunately, I dont even think that McKenzie supports his position
Slips is faithful to his position that McKenzie deserves to play for WI. Unfortunately, I dont even think that McKenzie supports his position
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 1:07 PM
In reply to Slipfeeler
Just laugh or cry. Some folks have friends in high places.
Just laugh or cry. Some folks have friends in high places.
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 6:46 PM
debut: Apr 27, '03
61,643 runs
@PalsofMine
The man saying if Tage ...why not ...
The man saying if Tage ...why not ...
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 7:04 PM
@natty_forever
Batsman A.
FC average - 27.23
Test avg. - 16.91
Last 4 day season - 26.42 (7 matches)
Batsman B
FC average - 35.27
Test avg. - 32.94
Last 4 day season - 47.50 (injured after 3 matches)
Who would you select?
Batsman A.
FC average - 27.23
Test avg. - 16.91
Last 4 day season - 26.42 (7 matches)
Batsman B
FC average - 35.27
Test avg. - 32.94
Last 4 day season - 47.50 (injured after 3 matches)
Who would you select?
Thu, Oct 2, '25 at 10:56 PM
@anthonyp
Not batting for anyone but you realize yuh using skewed stats?;3 matches vs almost full season on the assumption that but for injury batsman B's season would have continued on par or better. Neither should be there
Not batting for anyone but you realize yuh using skewed stats?;3 matches vs almost full season on the assumption that but for injury batsman B's season would have continued on par or better. Neither should be there
Fri, Oct 3, '25 at 5:12 AM
In reply to Slipfeeler
Bredren give it a rest!
You are now challenging VOR for lack of credibility. Kirk McKenzie has no one to blame for not grasping his opportunity when he got it.
I am sure if you spoke to his father Kurk "Jelly" McKenzie, Sr, he would tell you that young Kirk's performance was less than inspiring and he was rightly dropped from the West Indies team.
Bredren give it a rest!
You are now challenging VOR for lack of credibility. Kirk McKenzie has no one to blame for not grasping his opportunity when he got it.
I am sure if you spoke to his father Kurk "Jelly" McKenzie, Sr, he would tell you that young Kirk's performance was less than inspiring and he was rightly dropped from the West Indies team.