CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums > The Rum Shop > Jamaica should leave West Indies Cricket

Jamaica should leave West Indies Cricket

Page: 1 2 next
Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 10:53 AM

Jamaica has long been a land of champions, a nation whose excellence transcends its size and geography. On the global stage, we have proven that greatness is not a matter of numbers but of nurture, spirit, and national pride. Our runners have ruled the tracks of the world, from Usain Bolt’s blazing stride to Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce’s enduring brilliance. Our footballers have reached the World Cup, our musicians have moved nations, and our flag, wherever it flies, commands respect. It is this same spirit of confidence, courage, and conviction that must now be rekindled in cricket. For decades, Jamaica has served faithfully under the banner of West Indies cricket, contributing legendary names such as George Headley, Michael Holding, Courtney Walsh, and Chris Gayle. Yet, while the world remembers these men, the nation that nurtured them often fades behind the regional veil. The time has come for Jamaica to reclaim its name, its narrative, and its right to rise as an independent cricketing nation.


When our athletes sprint, they do not run for a region but for Jamaica. When our footballers play, they wear the national colors with pride. Cricket, once the heartbeat of our island, should now be restored to that same sovereign identity. The structure of West Indies cricket, though born of unity, has become a cage of compromise. Decision-making is delayed by bureaucracy, vision is diluted by regional politics, and resources are spread too thin to truly benefit our domestic game. Our young cricketers, who should be nurtured in local academies and guided by Jamaican conditions, often remain bound by external priorities. A Jamaica that controls its own cricket would be a Jamaica that shapes its own destiny.


We already possess the foundation. Our domestic competitions have produced world-class players. Sabina Park remains an iconic ground, and our people remain passionate about the game. We could begin independently with the formats that best fit modern times and financial reality: Twenty20 and fifty-over cricket. These shorter formats demand smaller squads, less infrastructure, and yield quicker commercial returns. Jamaica’s vibrant cricket culture, combined with our athletic prowess and charisma, would make us a force to be reckoned with in T20 tournaments around the world. From there, with time and development, we could build toward the longer format, establishing a Test team that competes with pride and purpose under the Jamaican flag.


This progression mirrors the path of our sporting journey. When Jamaica first entered global track and field, the world underestimated us. Yet we trained, believed, and built a system rooted in our soil and culture. The same is true of football. The Reggae Boyz and Reggae Girlz proved that an island of fewer than three million people could stand shoulder to shoulder with the world’s best. There is no reason cricket cannot follow the same course. The secret has never been our size but our spirit, never our population but our preparation. With our own board, our own sponsors, and our own governing vision, Jamaican cricket could blossom into a model of national success.


The financial potential is immense. Independence would allow Jamaica to control its own brand, its own broadcasting rights, and its own sponsorships. Every dollar earned would return to Jamaican cricket development, funding schools, clubs, and academies. Local matches could fill stadiums and drive tourism, as visitors from across the world come not to see “the West Indies,” but to witness Jamaica, a nation with charisma and culture unmatched in the Caribbean. The colors of our flag would fly proudly above Sabina Park as our players compete under one anthem, one identity, and one dream.


There will, of course, be challenges. Establishing a new national cricket structure will require funding, governance, and time. But Jamaica has never shied away from challenges. Our track record in other global sports proves that we are more than capable of creating systems of excellence. The International Cricket Council has opened its doors to new nations such as Afghanistan, Ireland, and Nepal, and Jamaica could follow a similar path, first securing associate membership, then rising through international competition. In a rapidly evolving cricket world, where T20 leagues and new formats dominate, this is not a far-fetched dream but a viable future.


The greatest victory of independence, however, is not merely political or financial. It is spiritual. It is the restoration of ownership. When a Jamaican player steps onto the field, he or she should represent the heartbeat of this island, not a composite federation. Every cheer from the stands should echo with the rhythm of our people, every victory should feel deeply Jamaican. The same pride that lifts our sprinters and singers should lift our cricketers. This is not rebellion against the West Indies but resurrection of Jamaican cricket. It is not separation for selfishness but for self-determination.


The time has come for Jamaica to stand alone in cricket, as it has in music, athletics, and football. We have the people, the passion, and the pedigree. We can begin with Twenty20 and one-day competitions, using the success and revenue from these to fund the building of a Test program. We can establish academies that train young talent in the art and discipline of the game, grounded in Jamaican culture. We can forge partnerships with other nations, host international tournaments, and restore the love of cricket to every corner of our island.


When we stand as a nation on our own cricketing feet, we will not only honor our past but secure our future. Independence will not divide the Caribbean spirit but demonstrate what a unified people can achieve when each nation develops its own excellence. Jamaica has already proven that world-class greatness can spring from small beginnings. The world has watched us run, dance, and sing our way to glory. Now it is time for them to watch us bat, bowl, and field with the same pride, under our own flag, in our own name, for our own destiny.


Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 11:08 AM

@dwinston.

Did that make you feel better when you finished posting that?

If so, it was a worthwhile exercise.


Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 11:18 AM

.

Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 1:10 PM

Well said

Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 2:38 PM

@dwinston

As poor as WI cricket is right now, they still rank higher in relative terms than the Reggae Boyz do in world football

Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 4:35 PM

@dwinston

Those who forget their past are doomed to repeat it

Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 8:24 PM

Jamaica was the first to leave the Federation, essentially breaking it up, so history may well just repeat itself.

Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 8:24 PM

@dwinston

Only way to go

Having a west Indies team playing international cricket is outdated and obsolete.

Players have no nationalistic feeling just playing for the 'West Indies' ...its probably confusing to them in 2025....it's being forced upon them.

Pure and simple there is NO anthem......Rally mih ass ....as an anthem?... with due respect to David Rudder who didn't write an anthem

On the other hand I am still in favor of Caricom mainly for trade and culture

And by the way I don't se e any European team playing a world sport...but the European Union is still powerful and important to European countries.


And BTW....the dotties can then formally own a dottie board and management and 'team'


Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 8:30 PM

@hawk

Those who forget their past are doomed to repeat it


Don't you wish a current west Indies team can repeat the past.....but that is doomed and will not happen

Sun, Oct 19, '25 at 9:13 PM

@Narper

Players have no nationalistic feeling just playing for the 'West Indies'

I believe this is a fallacy, primarily fueled by fan disappointment at results over the years

i believe the majority of players DO feel proud to wear the maroon, aspire to represent the West Indies, and live up to the great legacy of WI cricket.

The problem is when they actually experience playing for West Indies, and the incompetence, straight up bad treatment they sometimes get from their board, and the lack of structure and planning to place them in positions to be successful.

Those things combined with seemingly incessant losses, and constant criticism from the public wlll kill any initiative and is a rude awakening for thoset new players. Older players just become jaded as much as they try.



Mon, Oct 20, '25 at 6:53 AM

@Logic

Let's do a, by per capita calculation. How many teams play football...

Mon, Oct 20, '25 at 7:12 AM

...and if we qualify for the WC we will move up to at least 48. If the luck goes for Trinidad and Tobago you could see them moving to the top 48.

Mon, Oct 20, '25 at 7:14 AM

211 to 12

There are 99 associate nations, where any Caribbean Nation would slot in nicely

Mon, Oct 20, '25 at 7:18 AM

Guyana, would definitely qualify from CANOBOL, to the Olympics.

Mon, Oct 20, '25 at 9:43 AM

@natty_forever

shhh shh 😃

Page: 1 2 next