Brandon King

A

He was asked to consider opening at the beginning of the tour but he did not realize it would be this soon until Tage got injured in a net session. 33, 22, 63, 67 an average 45+ are good returns , only thing missing was a century. How he scored his runs was particularly impressive where he showed his class and dominated the bowling at a good S/R.

John Campbell

E

After the Indian tour where he scored a century in the last match one expected much more but he never got used to the bounce and movement. 15, 1,44,14.45.16 ave 22.50. Just not good enough.

@voiceofreason

So, VOD were there only two players on the entire West Indies team? Where are the grades and stats for the other players? I am sure that you would not want us to post them for you. 😀

Tage Chanderpaul

Only played one game where he registered 52 and 6 before his ill- timed injury. 52 off 167 balls albeit in the first innings would have contributed to the historic drawn match. However needed something more significant.

D

Allick Athanze

E

Just one decent score of 45 and three single digit scores. Was unlucky on that 45 where he looked fluent, still disappointing returns from a batsman who looks the part.

Kavem Hodge:

C+

Good comeback with that 123*, but with 2 ducks and a 35, we would have wanted to see more. Must say that the 2innings duck was quite unfortunate as it was a special piece of fielding that got him. Another one who looks the part just lacks consistency.

Shai Hope

B+

Scored 56, 140, 47, 5, 4,3. The first two scores came in that now famous draw . The last two scores came when he was battling a tough food poisoning illness and had to bat at 9 in of the innings. A brave effort from the consummate Pro. One could only wonder what would have been the case if he could have batted at 4 in the 1st of the last test.

Justin Greaves

A

Greaves' coming out tour? 56.60 average with the bat bolstered by the monumental 202* which saved the game for WI. Looked good for his 43 as well. His bowling was decent taking 5 wickets albeit at a high ave 48.80 but with WI a bowler short in the last game that was expected.

no player on this tour gets an A

@voiceofreason

Voice of Treason(Chief Propaganda Officer)-10/10

@voiceofreason

Not one F?

Coach: Z

Chase - I don’t think there is a

letter in the alphabet for him

Imlach - struggled with the bat

Roach - Steady but didn’t get much help. Also puts value on his wicket. The one player on this tour to have some self respect

Seales - very below par with the ball and doesn’t care to play straight to help prolong an inning when batting. Just goes out and brainlessly swipes

D for the Donkey

@voiceofreason

King Avg. 27.5 against NZ top bowlers....😀

Treason logic both Atha and Campbell get F's, fine. But Campbell who faced the new ball from ball 1 and averages more DOESN'T LOOK THE PART BUT ATHA DOES! Slightest doubt on your bias out di winda. SMH

King, Hope, Greaves and Roach get pass marks.

Hodge was a mixed bag.

The rest could do better.

Imlach:

E

Really all we needed from Imlach was a 50 here or there to say I can do this but this never happened. Just never looked the part. Jut was unable to handle the pressure.

14,4 16,5 27,15* .

Good with the gloves except for the one dropped catch.

@WICFan

Agreed. That is the fairest assessment. How could anyone get a A in a tour when the other side had multiple centurions and he never scored a century. Mind you, I think that King played above his known potential to score 2 half centuries in four innings. I always peg him for a one good score per series kind of batsman. it is certainly worth investing in him as an opener and freeing up the middle order for a worthy candidate if we can ever find one