CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums > The Rum Shop > Eldine Baptiste

Eldine Baptiste

Mon, May 25, '26 at 12:39 PM

Played 10 test matches, 10 wins.

The most underrated player?

Mon, May 25, '26 at 1:08 PM

@natty_forever

No, the team he played in was winning. His part in those wins were important not outstanding. In fact as the all-rounder @ #7 his stats may not differ much from Harper's in that '80's team. Gotta check

Mon, May 25, '26 at 7:04 PM

You need a steady man in a team and he was it. A Gomes-like player perhaps?

Mon, May 25, '26 at 7:19 PM

Sammy has better test numbers than him

Mon, May 25, '26 at 9:49 PM

@dayne

sammy played against mostly rash teams and failed against the teams that were actiually good for the most part. therev were no weak teams in the 80s in tests....perhaps SL and to a lesser extent india and australia(successive beat downs by the WI had a role to play in the decline of both sides but ironically had the opposite effect on Pakistan)

the next time Sammy had taken a five for, Ravi rampaul had already decimated the top order taking 3 for next to nothing while roach took the other wicket.

Mon, May 25, '26 at 10:28 PM

@Jumpstart

Sammy had about four 5-fers in Tests, in his very first Test he had a 5-fer against England, Baptiste never did than in 10 Tests. However, it might seem that in his days Test team were stronger but in Sammy's time teams became more advance in fitness and techniques, so things might have balanced out.

Mon, May 25, '26 at 11:34 PM

@dayne

every team that premiered after WSC that participated in some way in the tournament were exposed to the now global standards of fitness. In the middle of the 1980s, the Australians were talentless, but they were a very fit side, Pakistan was as fit as the WI, which is why they gave them so much thunder, India and SL were lagging behind but that was it.

on Sammy’s 7 for. England were more than 100 runs in front and trying to score quickly….dais like a Sachin fan boasting that sachin scored a hundred at Sydney in 1992 in the same innings Ravi Shastri had already scored a double ton in. The weight is significantly reduced by the match circumstances

Tue, May 26, '26 at 7:28 AM

@Jumpstart

Same argument can also be had around the debate as to was better Viv or Lara.

Viv could play in his style only because you the likes of Gomes and Logie to come after him.

Lara knee that it always get him out and add 30 .

Totally different mindset and set up