CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums The Rum Shop
s.springer or keemo paul?

s.springer or keemo paul?

Sun, Oct 4, '26 at 7:04 AM

who is the better player at this moment

Sun, Oct 4, '26 at 7:49 AM

@velo wrote:

who is the better player at this moment

I'm a Springer fan, so my comment maybe biased.

Sun, Oct 4, '26 at 8:33 AM

Player A

FC

Batting- 24.69

Bowling - 20.15

List A

Batting - 18.25

Bowling - 30.92

T20s

Batting - 16.93

Bowling - 31.78

Player B

FC

Batting - 32.59

Bowling - 27.87

List A

Batting - 20.80

Bowling - 34.80

T20s

Batting - 14.64

Bowling - 23.29

Who is better?

Sun, Oct 4, '26 at 9:29 AM

@anthonyp wrote:

Player A
FC
Batting- 24.69
Bowling - 20.15
List A
Batting - 18.25
Bowling - 30.92
T20s
Batting - 16.93
Bowling - 31.78
Player B
FC
Batting - 32.59
Bowling - 27.87
List A
Batting - 20.80
Bowling - 34.80
T20s
Batting - 14.64
Bowling - 23.29
Who is better?

Player B for me. B the marginally better bat. A marginally a better bowler. B T20 stats is the tie breaker for me.

Sun, Oct 4, '26 at 10:21 AM

@natty_forever wrote:

Player B for me. B the marginally better bat. A marginally a better bowler. B T20 stats is the tie breaker for me.

Forgot to add the number of matches for both.

Player A

FC - 35

List A - 68

T20s - 160

Player B

FC - 23

List A - 49

T20s - 56

Early days for Player B.. could probably improve or get worse by the time he reaches Player A number of games. In time, we will see.

Player A could walk into the test side as a specialist pacer with that bowling average. Nobody else in the region got better numbers.

To me, Player A is the better bowler and B might be slightly ahead with the bat. Not much difference in both though.

Sun, Oct 4, '26 at 3:14 PM

@velo wrote:

who is the better player at this moment

Paul for me

Sun, Oct 4, '26 at 3:56 PM

Kemo Paul and it’s not even close.

Shamar has potential and does relatively well with the ball in CPL

Kemo was one of the outstanding players for the Jamaica Kingsmen in CPL, often recording 140 plus kmh speeds with the ball.

He was also one of the best bowlers in this year’s FC tournament.

Hes a better bowler, batter, and fielder (despite some recent high profile dropped catches) than Shamar.

Overall, he’s a better cricketer.

Thats no slight on Shamar Springer. He’s a good player in his own right.

Sun, Oct 4, '26 at 6:02 PM

@anthonyp wrote

The numbers aren’t that different between them.

However, Kemo Paul is more suited for the longer game given his FC record.

As usual WI always tries to fit a square peg in a round hole.

Forums The Rum Shop
s.springer or keemo paul?