CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums The Rum Shop
Bishop digs deeper hole again for Sampson

Bishop digs deeper hole again for Sampson

Page: 1 2 3 next
Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 12:52 PM

Started this time by Badri

Then elaborated again nauseatingly by Bishop. He did it 2 years ago pre-CPL final, Guyana vs Trinidad.

Now he says the world knows about it, through scouting, and the cloud.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 1:13 PM

..................

“Why pay a tactical analyst when you can just turn up the broadcast volume?

It is truly a philanthropic masterclass. An batsman is struggling, and before their own coach can even grab a iPad, Ian Bishop has diagnosed their exact mechanical flaw on live TV. Need to take down a world-class bowler? Don't bother studying footage; just wait for Bish to map out their precise tactical blind spots to millions of viewers. Opposition dressing rooms don’t even need to do match prep anymore, they just need to plug in some headphones and let Ian Bishop give away the entire blueprint for free.”

We have some fcking dumbarse posters here...😡

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 1:24 PM

@Curtis wrote:

Started this time by Badri
Then elaborated again nauseatingly by Bishop. He did it 2 years ago pre-CPL final, Guyana vs Trinidad.
Now he says the world knows about it, through scouting, and the cloud.

the West Indian commentators are the only ones to initiate discussions about their own batsmen weakness

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 1:27 PM

@methodic wrote:

the West Indian commentators are the only ones to initiate discussions about their own batsmen weakness

I am still awaiting word of CWI batsmen strengths ....so no coaching report states they all swing for cow corner with straight bats and cross swipes. 🤨

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 2:37 PM

@methodic wrote:

the West Indian commentators are the only ones to initiate discussions about their own batsmen weakness

After the long critique, the Indian commentator had to chime in, "Are the WI coaches working to correct it?".

That's embarrassing all around.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 2:51 PM

These are just emotional outbursts from posters. Technology finds out any deficient international player.

Stop this crap. It is not cerebrally sound.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 2:57 PM

I just asked AI "what is Quentin Sampson's weakness as a batsman?" This is what it churned out:

Vulnerability to Extreme Short-Pitch Delivery (The "Bouncer" Trap): As a hard-hitting batsman, opposing teams have exploited tactical weaknesses in his handling of aggressive, high-pace short bowling. A prominent example occurred during the 2025 CPL final, where the Trinbago Knight Riders successfully neutralized Sampson by using Andre Russell to bounce him out, resulting in a catch at short leg
Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 3:09 PM

Yes, Bishop reminding the opposition of the flaws of WI players, he is a double agent,

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 4:44 PM

@methodic wrote:

the West Indian commentators are the only ones to initiate discussions about their own batsmen weakness

WI commentators Do Not Have Any Batsmen. Whenever I hear a commie says "we need to do so n so rather than The WI or Eng etc need to do so n so I turn that commie off.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 4:49 PM

just asked AI "what is Quentin Sampson's weakness as a batsman?" This is what it churned out:

On another thread I said Yadav was too fast for him and hoped they wouldn't remember Hopes weakness to pace to the torso. Time WI batsmen learn how to evade, pull and hook successfully
Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 5:04 PM

Do India,Aussies or any of the international players have any weaknesses?

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 5:15 PM

@sgtdjones wrote:

..................
“Why pay a tactical analyst when you can just turn up the broadcast volume?
It is truly a philanthropic masterclass. An batsman is struggling, and before their own coach can even grab a iPad, Ian Bishop has diagnosed their exact mechanical flaw on live TV. Need to take down a world-class bowler? Don't bother studying footage; just wait for Bish to map out their precise tactical blind spots to millions of viewers. Opposition dressing rooms don’t even need to do match prep anymore, they just need to plug in some headphones and let Ian Bishop give away the entire blueprint for free.”
We have some fcking dumbarse posters here...😡

Why does Bishop and Ganga not describe Pooran or Jangoo weaknesses.?

It only after Bishop or Ganga's remarks does the opposition bowls such deliveries.

Yes. All teams have tapes of players weaknesses, but I never heard of the host comms articulating such in detail as Bish and Ganga does to the WI team.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:21 PM

@tc1 wrote:

Why does Bishop and Ganga not describe Pooran or Jangoo weaknesses.?
It only after Bishop or Ganga's remarks does the opposition bowls such deliveries.
Yes. All teams have tapes of players weaknesses, but I never heard of the host comms articulating such in detail as Bish and Ganga does to the WI team.

tc1 limestone....

Let’s be real: opposing teams aren't waiting around for TV commentators to tell them how to bowl.

We are living in an era of professional cricket dominated by data, video analysts, and advanced scouting. Every international team has a massive database on West Indies players. They already have the maps and the footage. To suggest that the opposition only figures out how to bowl to Pooran or Jangoo and CWI players after Ian Bishop or Daren Ganga mentions it on air is completely out of touch with modern cricket.

Instead of blaming the commentators, we need to look at the real issues holding CWI back:

We saw the failure today in the power play the moving ball....

Zero accountability: If Bish and Ganga can spot these glaring technical flaws from a commentary box, there is absolutely no excuse for the players and the CWI coaching staff to ignore them. Yet, the same players make the exact same brain-fades match after match.

Deep-rooted bad habits: These technical failures aren't new. These guys have been playing with the same flawed techniques since their Under-19 and regional days. They got away with it against weaker domestic bowling, but international cricket ruthlessly exposes it.

Failure to coach: Why haven't the CWI batting coaches fixed these well-documented errors? That is what they are paid to do.

Bishop and Ganga are paid to analyze cricket, not to be a cheerleader section for the West Indies. Their job is to tell the viewers exactly what is happening on the field. Blaming the commentary team for doing their job is just a lazy excuse that shields lazy players and failing coaches from the criticism they actually deserve.

If a batsman can't survive a commentator pointing out his weakness, he shouldn't be playing international cricket anyway, Bish and Ganga are paid to speak facts, not protect egos.

Sarge

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:23 PM

@Courtesy wrote:

I just asked AI "what is Quentin Sampson's weakness as a batsman?" This is what it churned out:

AI didn't figure out Samson's weakness. AI regurgitated what was written in public domain. Bish was the first 'press' to report this. But that's not the issue for me. The issue is that in the midst of a run chase, they chose to bring up their own team batting player's flaw and discuss it for about 5 mins. Maybe they thought they were bringing deep insight about a young player's issues. But even they acknowledged all the world knows about it. So maybe it's just poor commentary from mediocre presenters.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:31 PM

@Curtis wrote:

...The issue is that in the midst of a run chase, they chose to bring up their own team batting player's flaw and discuss it for about 5 mins...

Bruh, the above is a fallacy. Commentators are invited and paid by host broadcasters. To suggest that they.bring up "their own team batting player's flaw" and must show allegiance and partiality is rooted in absurdity. 

Page: 1 2 3 next
Forums The Rum Shop
Bishop digs deeper hole again for Sampson