CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums The Rum Shop
We missed a golden opportunity to go 2-1 up!

We missed a golden opportunity to go 2-1 up!

Page: 1 2 3 next
Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 2:55 PM

Hetmeyer needed to make a big 50 and Rovman was disappointing again. Our bowling did well to restrict India to 223 and we only fell 14 runs yes 14 runs short so the blame falls squarely on our batsmen who failed to deliver once Hope fell cheaply. Happy that we continue to compete but need to start winning some more games.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 2:57 PM

Again I am not going to blame Kamil after 3 ODIS as our senior batsmen outside Hope and Rutherford need to step up!

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 3:01 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

Again I am not going to blame Kamil after 3 ODIS as our senior batsmen outside Hope and Rutherford need to step up!

I wonder when you will overcome your illogical and irrational tendencies?

Is 18 from 18 in the powerplay of any helpful value chasing over 220 runs?

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 3:06 PM

@Courtesy wrote:

I wonder when you will overcome your illogical and irrational tendencies?
Is 18 from 18 in the powerplay of any helpful value chasing over 220 runs?

Where did I say it was????

I simply said he has only played 3T20IS so I will cut him some slack. Regardlss of this shortcoming we fell 14 runs short! Does your arrogance allow you to understand that?? The game was winnable despite that poor start by the INEXPERIENCED Pooran.

So easy to pick on the rookie when senior guys continue to fail. Rovman and Hety have not had a consequential score this series. Oh I get it they got out because of the rookie.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 3:13 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

Where did I say it was????
I simply said he has only played 3T20IS so I will cut him some slack. Regardlss of this shortcoming we fell 14 runs short! Does your arrogance allow you to understand that?? The game was winnable despite that poor start.

I hate to engage in hypotheticals when dealing with sports. But fundamental to the argument is this: You haffi maximize the powerplay, especially when your opponent scores 223 and in their powerplay they scored 90+ runs. You are giving up too much advantage and inevitably, you put your colleague batters under pressure to take up your slack.

What is so difficult to understand in this?

We were too far behind in the powerplay. More often than not you will lose these matches.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 3:17 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

So easy to pick on the rookie when senior guys continue to fail. Rovman and Hety have not had a consequential score this series. Oh I get it they got out because of the rookie.

If I am to blame anyone it will be Sammy for persisting with him when most persons were saying he is not ready for the big stage.

I blame Sammy's stubbornness and lack of strategy. The youth should have left the pavillion with the mindset SEE BALL HIT BALL.

Further, Sammy waited for 10 overs to send out a message.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 5:03 PM

@Courtesy wrote:

I hate to engage in hypotheticals when dealing with sports. But fundamental to the argument is this: You haffi maximize the powerplay, especially when your opponent scores 223 and in their powerplay they scored 90+ runs. You are giving up too much advantage and inevitably, you put your colleague batters under pressure to take up your slack.
What is so difficult to understand in this?
We were too far behind in the powerplay. More often than not you will lose these matches.

We rely heavily on our power hitting at the back end so even if we are unable to maximize the Pp that is not the end of the world. Again despite the under- par PP we still ended up 14 runs short. You cannot throw all your marbles on the PP. West Indies have never played that way as we load our back with power hitters, even when we were champs with Sammy, Carlos, Pollard Dre Russ.

Ok last game WI were 72/3 in the PP chasing a mammoth 245 and we won the game with 9 balls to spare. Due to our 6 hitting capabilities WI teams have never been over-reliant on the PP. Try to keep up.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 5:30 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

We rely heavily on our power hitting at the back end so even if we are unable to maximize the Pp that is not the end of the world. Again despite the under- par PP we still ended up 14 runs short. You cannot throw all your marbles on the PP. West Indies have never played that way as we load our back with power hitters, even when we were champs with Sammy, Carlos, Pollard Dre Russ.
Ok last game WI were 72/3 in the PP chasing a mammoth 245 and we won the game with 9 balls to spare. Due to our 6 hitting capabilities WI teams have never been over-reliant on the PP. Try to keep up.

May I remind you about West Indies Win?Loss record over the last three years:

Overall T20I Record (Historical Cumulative) : 112 wins, 133 losses, and 12 no-results across 257 total matches.

It is unambiguously clear that our approach to the game needs recalibration.

Only old dogs would continue on this trajectory completely oblivious to the fact that there are major shortcomings to the current approach.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:00 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

Where did I say it was????
I simply said he has only played 3T20IS so I will cut him some slack. Regardlss of this shortcoming we fell 14 runs short! Does your arrogance allow you to understand that?? The game was winnable despite that poor start by the INEXPERIENCED Pooran.
So easy to pick on the rookie when senior guys continue to fail. Rovman and Hety have not had a consequential score this series. Oh I get it they got out because of the rookie.

I believe you are missing the main point. The issue isn't picking on a single player> It's understanding how a match actually develops and how an early approach impacts the entire team's pursuit. You cannot evaluate a chase purely by the final margin; you have to look at how that margin was created.

Consider how different chase dynamics affect the outcome and the rest of the batting order:

  1. A slow start followed by a late surge: Puts immense, compounding pressure on the middle and lower order, forcing incoming batsmen to take low-percentage risks from ball one just to keep up with a rapidly rising required run rate (RRR).
  2. A rapid start followed by a steady consolidation: Knocks off the pressure early, keeps the RRR manageable, and allows the middle order to build partnerships without panic.
  3. Pacing with the required rate: Keeps the game continuously within reach and avoids forcing middle-order batsmen into high-risk heroics under extreme pressure.

Pointing out that an early slow start set a damaging tone and raised the required rate isn't about blaming a young player for everything> It’s about recognizing tactical cause and effect.

Yes, senior players need to deliver and carry their weight when the game is on the line. But when the foundation of a chase puts you well behind the 8-ball early on, every single incoming batsman, senior or not is forced to play out of position and take uncalculated risks.

The game was certainly winnable, but falling 14 runs short directly reflects how those early lost overs squeezed the rest of the innings. Looking at the final result without analyzing how the pressure was built misses the fundamental mechanics of a successful run chase.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:14 PM

@Poggy wrote:

I believe you are missing the main point. The issue isn't picking on a single player> It's understanding how a match actually develops and how an early approach impacts the entire team's pursuit. You cannot evaluate a chase purely by the final margin; you have to look at how that margin was created.
Consider how different chase dynamics affect the outcome and the rest of the batting order:
  1. A slow start followed by a late surge: Puts immense, compounding pressure on the middle and lower order, forcing incoming batsmen to take low-percentage risks from ball one just to keep up with a rapidly rising required run rate (RRR).
  2. A rapid start followed by a steady consolidation: Knocks off the pressure early, keeps the RRR manageable, and allows the middle order to build partnerships without panic.
  3. Pacing with the required rate: Keeps the game continuously within reach and avoids forcing middle-order batsmen into high-risk heroics under extreme pressure.
Pointing out that an early slow start set a damaging tone and raised the required rate isn't about blaming a young player for everything> It’s about recognizing tactical cause and effect.
Yes, senior players need to deliver and carry their weight when the game is on the line. But when the foundation of a chase puts you well behind the 8-ball early on, every single incoming batsman, senior or not is forced to play out of position and take uncalculated risks.
The game was certainly winnable, but falling 14 runs short directly reflects how those early lost overs squeezed the rest of the innings. Looking at the final result without analyzing how the pressure was built misses the fundamental mechanics of a successful run chase.

Thank you Sah.

I have my doubts that you will find agreement from VOR.

.....................

On a side note, only the late heroics of Keemo Paul closed that losing gap.

Tanks again, Sir.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:15 PM

@Courtesy wrote:

May I remind you about West Indies Win?Loss record over the last three years:
Overall T20I Record (Historical Cumulative) : 112 wins, 133 losses, and 12 no-results across 257 total matches.
It is unambiguously clear that our approach to the game needs recalibration.
Only old dogs would continue on this trajectory completely oblivious to the fact that there are major shortcomings to the current approach.

You forgot to mention the fact that we have been a team in transition over the last three years. So the power hitters of Worldcup past have all retired and gone so yes we would suffer some major losses. Sammy is rebuilding using a similar blue print hence the inclusion of Keemo, Shep, Samson,Forde and Spriunger.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:20 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

You forgot to mention the fact that we have been a team in transition over the last three years. So the power hitters of Worldcup past have all retired and gone so yes we would suffer some major losses. Sammy is rebuilding using a similar blue print hence the inclusion of Keemo, Shep, Samson,Forde and Spriunger.

See Poggy's post which is a lot more cerebral than mine. It may remove the mote from your eyes..

..........................

You are as inflexible as my father's walking stick.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:26 PM

@Poggy wrote:

A rapid start followed by a steady consolidation: Knocks off the pressure early, keeps the RRR manageable, and allows the middle order to build partnerships without panic.

You do understand that a rapid start comes with more risks. For example Shai Hope from ball one decided to go after the bowling and played an uncharacteristic hoick across the line and lost this wicket. That was very early in the game. According to your theory Shai played the right way. You rather 72/1 or 90/3 after the PP.

  1. Pacing with the required rate: Keeps the game continuously within reach and avoids forcing middle-order batsmen into high-risk heroics under extreme pressure.

This is the approach I prefer.

Again I totally understand the various approaches however I do understand that they all come with varying risks. Now in regards to Kamil, he clearly was not sent out there to strike at 100- 120 in the PP, however due to his lack of experience he is unable to execute his objective which would be a s/r 150-170.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:37 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

Now in regards to Kamil, he clearly was not sent out there to strike at 100- 120 in the PP, however due to his lack of experience he is unable to execute his objective which would be a s/r 150-170.

🙄🙄🙄

So it took Sammy all of 10 overs to bark out instructions even though there was a clear need from early for course correction?

I know you can foolishly dfend this....come on.

Sun, Oct 11, '26 at 6:41 PM

@Courtesy wrote:

  1. A slow start followed by a late surge: Puts immense, compounding pressure on the middle and lower order, forcing incoming batsmen to take low-percentage risks from ball one just to keep up with a rapidly rising required run rate (RRR).
  2. A rapid start followed by a steady consolidation: Knocks off the pressure early, keeps the RRR manageable, and allows the middle order to build partnerships without panic.
  3. Pacing with the required rate: Keeps the game continuously within reach and avoids forcing middle-order batsmen into high-risk heroics under extreme pressure.
Thank you Sah.
I have my doubts that you will find agreement from VOR.
.....................
On a side note, only the late heroics of Keemo Paul closed that losing gap.
Tanks again, Sir.

It isn’t about winning an argument for me, VOR. It’s about identifying where we need to improve to build genuine consistency.

When you fix the tactical process like managing the powerplay and controlling the required run rate early on given our backend players power, the results naturally take care of themselves. Keemo’s brilliant late effort showed the fight is there, but relying on heroics to bail us out of early holes isn't a sustainable strategy for winning regularly.

Page: 1 2 3 next
Forums The Rum Shop
We missed a golden opportunity to go 2-1 up!