CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums The Rum Shop
CWI team performed well in T20 against India but,an Asterisk (*)

CWI team performed well in T20 against India but,an Asterisk (*)

Sat, Oct 17, '26 at 8:56 PM

CWI team performed well in T20 against India  but, an Asterisk (*)

For the five-match T20I series against Cricket West Indies (CWI), several major, regular players from India's senior setup were missing. The squad relied heavily on members of India's gold-winning Asian Games group and young talent.

The primary reasons for their absence included strategic workload management, retirements, injuries, and format switches:

Senior Players Rested or Excluded

Jasprit Bumrah: The elite pacer was rested for the T20 series to manage his workload after leading the bowling attack at the Asian Games.

Shubman Gill: India's Test and ODI captain for the tour was rested/omitted from the T20I leg entirely, despite anchoring the ODI series.

Yashasvi Jaiswal: The explosive opener featured in the ODI series but was omitted from the T20 squad.

Mohammed Siraj: Played the 3-match ODI series but did not participate in the T20I leg.

KL Rahul & Rishabh Pant: Left out of the T20 squad to accommodate specialized wicketkeeping options like Sanju Samson and Ishan Kishan.

Hardik Pandya: Did not feature in either leg of the white-ball tour.

Forced Injury & Last-Minute Withdrawals

Washington Sundar: Initially named to the T20 squad but was withdrawn by the BCCI so he could play red-ball cricket for his state team in the Ranji Trophy. He was replaced by Naman Dhir.

That is the ultimate debate in modern cricket, and there is definitely a massive asterisk ( *) or question mark (?) depending on how you look at it. The 2-2 series result is viewed through two entirely different lenses by fans and experts alike:

Why it feels like an Asterisk (*) for the West Indies

India's Missing Core: As you noted, when a team plays a bilateral series without modern legends like Jasprit Bumrah or retired stalwarts like Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli, the opponent isn't facing the true pinnacle of Indian cricket.

The "B-Team" Narrative: Critics will always argue that drawing against a transition-phase Indian squad heavily reliant on domestic talent isn't the same as beating a full-strength World Champion side.

Why it still feels like a massive Win for CW

Ending the Fortress Streak: Before this series, India had an unbelievable 12-series home winning streak stretching back four years. For the West Indies to walk into Indian conditions and completely shatter that flawless record is an incredible achievement, regardless of who was on the field.

Shai Hope’s Masterclass: West Indies skipper Shai Hope didn’t just scrape by, he dominated the series with two brilliant centuries, rightfully earning the Player of the Series award.

T20 is the Great Equalizer: In the shortest format, individual brilliance wins games. The West Indies didn't rely on Indian mistakes; they actively outplayed them in the second and fourth T20Is

Ultimately, because rain entirely washed out the 5th match decider in Bengaluru, both teams had to share the trophy. India can comfortably claim they are testing future depth, while the West Indies head home with immense pride for putting a massive dent in India's home dominance.

Sarge

Sun, Oct 18, '26 at 3:02 AM

@sgtdjones wrote:

CWI team performed well in T20 against India but, an Asterisk (*)
For the five-match T20I series against Cricket West Indies (CWI), several major, regular players from India's senior setup were missing. The squad relied heavily on members of India's gold-winning Asian Games group and young talent.
The primary reasons for their absence included strategic workload management, retirements, injuries, and format switches:
Senior Players Rested or Excluded
Jasprit Bumrah: The elite pacer was rested for the T20 series to manage his workload after leading the bowling attack at the Asian Games.
Shubman Gill: India's Test and ODI captain for the tour was rested/omitted from the T20I leg entirely, despite anchoring the ODI series.
Yashasvi Jaiswal: The explosive opener featured in the ODI series but was omitted from the T20 squad.
Mohammed Siraj: Played the 3-match ODI series but did not participate in the T20I leg.
KL Rahul & Rishabh Pant: Left out of the T20 squad to accommodate specialized wicketkeeping options like Sanju Samson and Ishan Kishan.
Hardik Pandya: Did not feature in either leg of the white-ball tour.
Forced Injury & Last-Minute Withdrawals
Washington Sundar: Initially named to the T20 squad but was withdrawn by the BCCI so he could play red-ball cricket for his state team in the Ranji Trophy. He was replaced by Naman Dhir.
That is the ultimate debate in modern cricket, and there is definitely a massive asterisk ( *) or question mark (?) depending on how you look at it. The 2-2 series result is viewed through two entirely different lenses by fans and experts alike:
Why it feels like an Asterisk (*) for the West Indies
India's Missing Core: As you noted, when a team plays a bilateral series without modern legends like Jasprit Bumrah or retired stalwarts like Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli, the opponent isn't facing the true pinnacle of Indian cricket.
The "B-Team" Narrative: Critics will always argue that drawing against a transition-phase Indian squad heavily reliant on domestic talent isn't the same as beating a full-strength World Champion side.
Why it still feels like a massive Win for CW
Ending the Fortress Streak: Before this series, India had an unbelievable 12-series home winning streak stretching back four years. For the West Indies to walk into Indian conditions and completely shatter that flawless record is an incredible achievement, regardless of who was on the field.
Shai Hope’s Masterclass: West Indies skipper Shai Hope didn’t just scrape by, he dominated the series with two brilliant centuries, rightfully earning the Player of the Series award.
T20 is the Great Equalizer: In the shortest format, individual brilliance wins games. The West Indies didn't rely on Indian mistakes; they actively outplayed them in the second and fourth T20Is
Ultimately, because rain entirely washed out the 5th match decider in Bengaluru, both teams had to share the trophy. India can comfortably claim they are testing future depth, while the West Indies head home with immense pride for putting a massive dent in India's home dominance.
Sarge

Shubmn gill doesn’t ply T20s, was dropped from the T20 team and last played in December 2025

rohit and kohli have retired from this format

bumrah is rested every alternate series pretty much and is injury prone

jaiswal hasn’t played a T20 in over two years

rahul hasnt played a T20 in 4 years

this is the most disingenuous post ever

Sun, Oct 18, '26 at 1:16 PM

@brians_da_best wrote:

Shubmn gill doesn’t ply T20s, was dropped from the T20 team and last played in December 2025
rohit and kohli have retired from this format
bumrah is rested every alternate series pretty much and is injury prone
jaiswal hasn’t played a T20 in over two years
rahul hasnt played a T20 in 4 years
this is the most disingenuous post ever

Thank you. I was about to correct Sad Sack

Sun, Oct 18, '26 at 4:00 PM

@sgtdjones wrote:

CWI team performed well in T20 against India but, an Asterisk (*)
For the five-match T20I series against Cricket West Indies (CWI), several major, regular players from India's senior setup were missing. The squad relied heavily on members of India's gold-winning Asian Games group and young talent.
The primary reasons for their absence included strategic workload management, retirements, injuries, and format switches:
Senior Players Rested or Excluded
Jasprit Bumrah: The elite pacer was rested for the T20 series to manage his workload after leading the bowling attack at the Asian Games.
Shubman Gill: India's Test and ODI captain for the tour was rested/omitted from the T20I leg entirely, despite anchoring the ODI series.
Yashasvi Jaiswal: The explosive opener featured in the ODI series but was omitted from the T20 squad.
Mohammed Siraj: Played the 3-match ODI series but did not participate in the T20I leg.
KL Rahul & Rishabh Pant: Left out of the T20 squad to accommodate specialized wicketkeeping options like Sanju Samson and Ishan Kishan.
Hardik Pandya: Did not feature in either leg of the white-ball tour.
Forced Injury & Last-Minute Withdrawals
Washington Sundar: Initially named to the T20 squad but was withdrawn by the BCCI so he could play red-ball cricket for his state team in the Ranji Trophy. He was replaced by Naman Dhir.
That is the ultimate debate in modern cricket, and there is definitely a massive asterisk ( *) or question mark (?) depending on how you look at it. The 2-2 series result is viewed through two entirely different lenses by fans and experts alike:
Why it feels like an Asterisk (*) for the West Indies
India's Missing Core: As you noted, when a team plays a bilateral series without modern legends like Jasprit Bumrah or retired stalwarts like Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli, the opponent isn't facing the true pinnacle of Indian cricket.
The "B-Team" Narrative: Critics will always argue that drawing against a transition-phase Indian squad heavily reliant on domestic talent isn't the same as beating a full-strength World Champion side.
Why it still feels like a massive Win for CW
Ending the Fortress Streak: Before this series, India had an unbelievable 12-series home winning streak stretching back four years. For the West Indies to walk into Indian conditions and completely shatter that flawless record is an incredible achievement, regardless of who was on the field.
Shai Hope’s Masterclass: West Indies skipper Shai Hope didn’t just scrape by, he dominated the series with two brilliant centuries, rightfully earning the Player of the Series award.
T20 is the Great Equalizer: In the shortest format, individual brilliance wins games. The West Indies didn't rely on Indian mistakes; they actively outplayed them in the second and fourth T20Is
Ultimately, because rain entirely washed out the 5th match decider in Bengaluru, both teams had to share the trophy. India can comfortably claim they are testing future depth, while the West Indies head home with immense pride for putting a massive dent in India's home dominance.
Sarge

Come on sarge, enough is enough, it is time to stop finding ways or excuses to reduce the success of the team, besides it is not our job to concern ourselves about who the opposition put on the field of play nor why someone isn't there, the others certainly didn't care when our best 11 was not available, they still played good cricket and pummeled us.

our west Indies team is doing well and improving, why is it so hard to accept and admit that

Sun, Oct 18, '26 at 4:05 PM

@sgtdjones wrote:

CWI team performed well in T20 against India but, an Asterisk (*)
For the five-match T20I series against Cricket West Indies (CWI), several major, regular players from India's senior setup were missing. The squad relied heavily on members of India's gold-winning Asian Games group and young talent.
The primary reasons for their absence included strategic workload management, retirements, injuries, and format switches:
Senior Players Rested or Excluded
Jasprit Bumrah: The elite pacer was rested for the T20 series to manage his workload after leading the bowling attack at the Asian Games.
Shubman Gill: India's Test and ODI captain for the tour was rested/omitted from the T20I leg entirely, despite anchoring the ODI series.
Yashasvi Jaiswal: The explosive opener featured in the ODI series but was omitted from the T20 squad.
Mohammed Siraj: Played the 3-match ODI series but did not participate in the T20I leg.
KL Rahul & Rishabh Pant: Left out of the T20 squad to accommodate specialized wicketkeeping options like Sanju Samson and Ishan Kishan.
Hardik Pandya: Did not feature in either leg of the white-ball tour.
Forced Injury & Last-Minute Withdrawals
Washington Sundar: Initially named to the T20 squad but was withdrawn by the BCCI so he could play red-ball cricket for his state team in the Ranji Trophy. He was replaced by Naman Dhir.
That is the ultimate debate in modern cricket, and there is definitely a massive asterisk ( *) or question mark (?) depending on how you look at it. The 2-2 series result is viewed through two entirely different lenses by fans and experts alike:
Why it feels like an Asterisk (*) for the West Indies
India's Missing Core: As you noted, when a team plays a bilateral series without modern legends like Jasprit Bumrah or retired stalwarts like Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli, the opponent isn't facing the true pinnacle of Indian cricket.
The "B-Team" Narrative: Critics will always argue that drawing against a transition-phase Indian squad heavily reliant on domestic talent isn't the same as beating a full-strength World Champion side.
Why it still feels like a massive Win for CW
Ending the Fortress Streak: Before this series, India had an unbelievable 12-series home winning streak stretching back four years. For the West Indies to walk into Indian conditions and completely shatter that flawless record is an incredible achievement, regardless of who was on the field.
Shai Hope’s Masterclass: West Indies skipper Shai Hope didn’t just scrape by, he dominated the series with two brilliant centuries, rightfully earning the Player of the Series award.
T20 is the Great Equalizer: In the shortest format, individual brilliance wins games. The West Indies didn't rely on Indian mistakes; they actively outplayed them in the second and fourth T20Is
Ultimately, because rain entirely washed out the 5th match decider in Bengaluru, both teams had to share the trophy. India can comfortably claim they are testing future depth, while the West Indies head home with immense pride for putting a massive dent in India's home dominance.
Sarge

I was about to rebut this but then I remembered the advice you gave me regarding the Fool.

Sun, Oct 18, '26 at 4:06 PM

@brians_da_best wrote:

Shubmn gill doesn’t ply T20s, was dropped from the T20 team and last played in December 2025
rohit and kohli have retired from this format
bumrah is rested every alternate series pretty much and is injury prone
jaiswal hasn’t played a T20 in over two years
rahul hasnt played a T20 in 4 years
this is the most disingenuous post ever

Sarge gone awol.

Sun, Oct 18, '26 at 5:00 PM

@brians_da_best wrote:

Shubmn gill doesn’t ply T20s, was dropped from the T20 team and last played in December 2025
rohit and kohli have retired from this format
bumrah is rested every alternate series pretty much and is injury prone
jaiswal hasn’t played a T20 in over two years
rahul hasnt played a T20 in 4 years
this is the most disingenuous post ever
Sun, Oct 18, '26 at 5:02 PM

Bs,no need to respond to this post.

Sun, Oct 18, '26 at 5:53 PM

.................. 

I am setting up the "Asterisk* / B-Team" narrative as a critique that expects bitter critics and Indian media to use, only to explicitly shoot it down..

I am basically saying, "Yes, critics will try to put an asterisk * on this, but here is why they are dead wrong and why this is a massive, historic win for CWI."

Because the posters on the thread completely missed that nuance and jumped down my throat anyway

It is uncanny how posters can read this an come to such conclusions :

"You have completely misread and assimilated my post because you were too eager to grab the pitchforks.

I wasn't the one making excuses or running down the West Indies, was literally setting up the exact double standard the media and critics are going to use, just so one could smash it down.

Read the actual post again.

I explicitly gave a massive section titled 'Why it still feels like a massive Win for CWI' and praised Shai Hope's masterclass and breaking India's flawless 12-series home streak.

Posters are arguing against points I don't support!

I was just mapping out the inevitable 'B-team' narrative that will be coming from the outside, while explicitly concluding that CWI team deserve immense pride for denting India's home dominance.

Instead of calling my post disingenuous, one should be agreeing with my conclusion:

CWI went into their backyard, broke a 4-year fortress, and walked away with a shared trophy.

I am on the same side as the rest of us here!"

Sarge

Sun, Oct 18, '26 at 10:57 PM

@sgtdjones wrote:

.................. 
I am setting up the "Asterisk* / B-Team" narrative as a critique that expects bitter critics and Indian media to use, only to explicitly shoot it down..
I am basically saying, "Yes, critics will try to put an asterisk * on this, but here is why they are dead wrong and why this is a massive, historic win for CWI."
Because the posters on the thread completely missed that nuance and jumped down my throat anyway
It is uncanny how posters can read this an come to such conclusions :
"You have completely misread and assimilated my post because you were too eager to grab the pitchforks.
I wasn't the one making excuses or running down the West Indies, was literally setting up the exact double standard the media and critics are going to use, just so one could smash it down.
Read the actual post again.
I explicitly gave a massive section titled 'Why it still feels like a massive Win for CWI' and praised Shai Hope's masterclass and breaking India's flawless 12-series home streak.
Posters are arguing against points I don't support!
I was just mapping out the inevitable 'B-team' narrative that will be coming from the outside, while explicitly concluding that CWI team deserve immense pride for denting India's home dominance.
Instead of calling my post disingenuous, one should be agreeing with my conclusion:
CWI went into their backyard, broke a 4-year fortress, and walked away with a shared trophy.
I am on the same side as the rest of us here!"
Sarge

This sounds like one of the late great Calypso King of the World Sparrow aka Slinger Francisco, " Lying excuses". I am yet to hear any of the Indian Media push that narrative and if they were to that would have been out there already and you could have easily posted the link. The fact remains that most of the players you named except Bumrah and Pandya are not even features in the T20I team. Quit digging Sarge.

Mon, Oct 19, '26 at 12:28 AM

@voiceofreason wrote:

This sounds like one of the late great Calypso King of the World Sparrow aka Slinger Francisco, " Lying excuses". I am yet to hear any of the Indian Media push that narrative and if they were to that would have been out there already and you could have easily posted the link. The fact remains that most of the players you named except Bumrah and Pandya are not even features in the T20I team. Quit digging Sarge.

I am just giving a suggestion of what the consensus will be in Gandhi land metaphorically speaking.

At work I have 4 from India and its their opinions as I stated above. They are suggesting wait till the official India's T20 team are announced. In the interim they are in abuilding phase. 😎

note: I just gave you a suggestion about your next calypso to win the crown in Tortola.

Mon, Oct 19, '26 at 6:00 AM

Maybe India can play a 22 man squad next time, since everyone cannot make the playing XI.

CWI needs to include more Tits to be relevant! 😜

Mon, Oct 19, '26 at 4:25 PM

@sgtdjones wrote:

I am just giving a suggestion of what the consensus will be in Gandhi land metaphorically speaking.
At work I have 4 from India and its their opinions as I stated above. They are suggesting wait till the official India's T20 team are announced. In the interim they are in abuilding phase. 😎
note: I just gave you a suggestion about your next calypso to win the crown in Tortola.

You sound like Donald Trump

Forums The Rum Shop
CWI team performed well in T20 against India but,an Asterisk (*)