CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums The Rum Shop
And Why Isn't Vitel Lawes

And Why Isn't Vitel Lawes

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 6:04 AM

playing test cricket?

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 12:27 PM

@jamcricket wrote:

playing test cricket?

CWI management decides what type of series is best for its players.

He should be here , on such wickets.

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 4:48 PM

@jamcricket wrote:

playing test cricket?

The more pertinent question would be why he was never selected for Jamaica to play FC cricket. He is yet to play FC cricket but you want him to make his FC debut in TESTS???

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 4:59 PM

@jamcricket wrote:

playing test cricket?

Vitel needs to play more 1st class cricket (wherever that might be)....its all well an good bowling 4 over spells in t20's but test cricket is a different ball game an obviously more physically demanding whereby he may be called upon to bowl 25 overs in a day assuming he's not targeted an hit out of the attack prior ....he's a good prospect but will be a few years before he's the finished article hence needs careful handling an loads more red ball cricket wherever he can get it!

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 5:10 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

The more pertinent question would be why he was never selected for Jamaica to play FC cricket. He is yet to play FC cricket but you want him to make his FC debut in TESTS???

There is no pertinence to it. Both things are true. Jamaica and West Indies should be playing him the game’s longer versions.

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 6:04 PM

Marlon Samuels played test cricket with no first class experience and so did Fidel Edwards...Good enough, just play them.

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 7:04 PM

At this point he's not good enough....his skillset needs a lot more work to perfect than either Fidel's raw pace did or Marlon's natural ability.....like I said he's a good prospect no doubt but he's not as great as some ppl seem think he is at this point...no need to rush him as if he's the answer to all our prayers in our desperation an destroy the yute steeeeew!!!

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 7:49 PM

@CCW wrote:

At this point he's not good enough....his skillset needs a lot more work to perfect than either Fidel's raw pace did or Marlon's natural ability.....like I said he's a good prospect no doubt but he's not as great as some ppl seem think he is at this point...no need to rush him as if he's the answer to all our prayers in our desperation an destroy the yute steeeeew!!!

Thank you sir!!! I swear people are just trying to find new ways to say that they’re Dunce!!!

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 11:10 PM

swear people are just trying to find new ways to say that they’re Dunce!!!

Unnecessary! However, VOR's hypocrisy isn't. I did say l/still think Vitel would've been better off playing FC/List A 1st. Vor praises Sammy having him bowl 10 overs in a 3 1/4hr. innings under pressure with no close to the wjcket attacking fielders but opposes him playing tests. In nets I'm sure he bowls 20-30 overs.

Had Sammy done the opposite VOR would've agreed wholeheartedly.

By the way Marlon played 1 FC match at age 15 or 16.

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 12:15 AM

@Brerzerk wrote:

swear people are just trying to find new ways to say that they’re Dunce!!!
Unnecessary! However, VOR's hypocrisy isn't. I did say l/still think Vitel would've been better off playing FC/List A 1st. Vor praises Sammy having him bowl 10 overs in a 3 1/4hr. innings under pressure with no close to the wjcket attacking fielders but opposes him playing tests. In nets I'm sure he bowls 20-30 overs.
Had Sammy done the opposite VOR would've agreed wholeheartedly.
By the way Marlon played 1 FC match at age 15 or 16.

Jamcricket is that you?

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 8:10 AM

@sgtdjones wrote:

CWI management decides what type of series is best for its players.
He should be here , on such wickets.

you never miss an opportunity

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 9:33 AM

@Brerzerk wrote:

swear people are just trying to find new ways to say that they’re Dunce!!!
Unnecessary! However, VOR's hypocrisy isn't. I did say l/still think Vitel would've been better off playing FC/List A 1st. Vor praises Sammy having him bowl 10 overs in a 3 1/4hr. innings under pressure with no close to the wjcket attacking fielders but opposes him playing tests. In nets I'm sure he bowls 20-30 overs.
Had Sammy done the opposite VOR would've agreed wholeheartedly.
By the way Marlon played 1 FC match at age 15 or 16.

You’re singling out exceptions to the norm!!! Why wouldn’t you want the kid to develop properly??? He’s a part of the A team white ball setup which will give us a better idea of where he’s at!!!

I personally believe the kid is talented but at the same time he hasn’t really set the place on fire so he clearly needs more time!!!

Would you place Marlon Samuels or even Fidel Edwards in the top 20 best WI Test Players????

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 11:41 AM

@CCW wrote:

Vitel needs to play more 1st class cricket (wherever that might be)....its all well an good bowling 4 over spells in t20's but test cricket is a different ball game an obviously more physically demanding whereby he may be called upon to bowl 25 overs in a day assuming he's not targeted an hit out of the attack prior ....he's a good prospect but will be a few years before he's the finished article hence needs careful handling an loads more red ball cricket wherever he can get it!

Nothing wrong with that reasoning. All I ask for is consistency. Favouritism has no place in our cricket

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 11:50 AM

Would you place Marlon Samuels or even Fidel Edwards in the top 20 best WI Test Players????

What's the relevance to this discussion, why not too 10, top 100...?

I think consistency, hypocrisy, logic and common sense are being discussed

Forums The Rum Shop
And Why Isn't Vitel Lawes