CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums The Rum Shop
Jangoo .Why is he keeping?

Jangoo .Why is he keeping?

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 8:31 AM

In top batting form but not accustomed to the rigours of red ball keeping

Make it make sense

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 8:55 AM

@pariaman wrote:

In top batting form but not accustomed to the rigours of red ball keeping
Make it make sense

Utterly stupid idea, we keep hearing about Trust the Process but it appears to me to be all about a whim and a prayer with Sammy .

Keeps making idiotic decisions hoping to get one right some time and then believing he is a genius.

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 8:57 AM

@pariaman wrote:

In top batting form but not accustomed to the rigours of red ball keeping
Make it make sense

If Josh were included (as the 'keeper), then Kavem Hodge would've been left out. In this day and age, you wouldn't want to see a WI team without a single Dottie, would you?

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 9:18 AM

I thought he was a keeper ....

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 9:24 AM

@pariaman wrote:

In top batting form but not accustomed to the rigours of red ball keeping
Make it make sense

It’s for the benefit of Shai Hope it’s not sustainable to have Hope keep and be your most reliable batsman!!!

I rather try Jangoo against Bangladesh than against a top team!!!

Even if you try JDS what happens if he fails Hope has to comeback and take the gloves which would be counter productive!!!

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 10:14 AM

@WIfan26 wrote:

It’s for the benefit of Shai Hope it’s not sustainable to have Hope keep and be your most reliable batsman!!!
I rather try Jangoo against Bangladesh than against a top team!!!
Even if you try JDS what happens if he fails Hope has to comeback and take the gloves which would be counter productive!!!

In my opinion. Jangoo is a better keeper than Josh. Who is the better bat, thats a different question.

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 10:45 AM

But is he ready to keep for a day and a half then come out to bat?

Does he have the fitness level and have he developed the concentration and mental mindset required?

I do not think so.

He does not keep for any local red ball side.

He should be left to develop his batting!

No one without redball keeping list A experience should be thrust into keeping for a test match

That's just crazy and an unforced error by Sammy

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 11:04 AM

@natty_forever wrote:

In my opinion. Jangoo is a better keeper than Josh. Who is the better bat, thats a different question.

The batsman issue will be solved when Shai returns what we need is a proper keeper!!!

As it stands both Jangoo & Da Silva are shop keepers.

The clear reason he was given the gloves is because as of now his place in the team is secured!!!

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 11:20 AM

........

CWI selecta  "token selections"

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 11:31 AM

@WIfan26 wrote:

The batsman issue will be solved when Shai returns what we need is a proper keeper!!!
As it stands both Jangoo & Da Silva are shop keepers.
The clear reason he was given the gloves is because as of now his place in the team is secured!!!

Looked good whenever I saw him. Did not watch last night.

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 11:41 AM

Like I said online previously, there is not much difference between DaSilva and Jangoo as w/keepers, the main reason why fans are skeptical about Jangoo keeping in a Test match is that he is not a w/keeper for any regional team. He performed competently so far in this match with the gloves.

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 11:43 AM

@dayne wrote:

Like I said online previously, there is not much difference between DaSilva and Jangoo as w/keepers, the main reason why fans are skeptical about Jangoo keeping in a Test match is that he is not a w/keeper for any regional team. He performed competently so far in this match with the gloves.

Guess everyone saw something last night to suggest Josh is on the same level as Jangoo in keeping. BS. One bad day and you all chatting shyt. How many of you knew that Bangladesh would not make 300. Take some time you fuckers to learn the game.

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 12:49 PM

@natty_forever wrote:

Guess everyone saw something last night to suggest Josh is on the same level as Jangoo in keeping. BS. One bad day and you all chatting shyt. How many of you knew that Bangladesh would not make 300. Take some time you fuckers to learn the game.

Josh has had several bad days, recently the reason why Trinidad had to play a semi-final in the regional 4-days tournament was because after setting the Leewards about 500 runs to make in over a day to bat, Trinidad seemingly was on their way to victory when on 40 something Greaves was dropped by DaSilva and he went on to make 140 and draw the match. There have been several other incidents, too many.

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 9:33 PM

@WIfan26 wrote:

The batsman issue will be solved when Shai returns what we need is a proper keeper!!!
As it stands both Jangoo & Da Silva are shop keepers.
The clear reason he was given the gloves is because as of now his place in the team is secured!!!

from what I have seen Jangoo is a pretty decent keeper. He moves a lot bettef than Dasilva. Jangoo is a way better bat.

Thu, Oct 29, '26 at 10:17 PM

@pariaman wrote:

In top batting form but not accustomed to the rigours of red ball keeping
Make it make sense

forgot about him keeping or not. he got out like a total bonehead… playing t20 shot early in the innings…

Forums The Rum Shop
Jangoo .Why is he keeping?