Mia Motley is the only contemporary politician we have in the Caribbean who is comparable to Manley.
All the others are spineless cowards and boot licking grifters.
The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket
Mia Motley is the only contemporary politician we have in the Caribbean who is comparable to Manley.
All the others are spineless cowards and boot licking grifters.
..............
Charisma can’t fix a broken system
A leader can be the smartest person in the room, but they can't just wish away centuries of bad economic design. The reality is that small islands are simply too small to go it alone in a massive global economy. The Caribbean has been talking about pooling its resources and fully integrating for decades, but it never actually happens. Without that teamwork, even the best leaders are just firefighting on a tiny, vulnerable ship.
All talk, no action
Caribbean politicians are world-class speakers and great at writing fancy policy papers, but when it comes to actually getting things done, everything grinds to a halt. Look at Singapore, they succeeded because they built a hyper-efficient, highly paid civil service that executed plans ruthlessly. In the Caribbean, the public sector is too often used to hand out favors and secure votes, which means even the best ideas end up dying in a sea of red tape.
The election trap
In democracies like Barbados, Jamaica, and Trinidad, politicians are always looking over their shoulders at the next election. Making the hard choices, like fixing a broken tax system, cutting bloated government waste, or actually locking up corrupt officials, is political suicide. It’s always easier for a leader to do what’s popular right now rather than what’s good for the country twenty years from now.
The bottom line on Mia Mottley
Praising Mia Mottley while admitting people are still struggling isn't a contradiction, it’s just being realistic about what one person can actually do. She is brilliant at calling out global unfairness on the world stage, but back home, she’s stuck dealing with the same old sluggish bureaucracy, corrupt political systems, and the nightmare of running a small, dependent economy. Until Caribbean leaders stop focusing on viral speeches and start doing the boring, difficult work of fixing things at home, the gap between international praise and local hardship isn't going anywhere.
Sarge
@SnoopDog wrote:
What a brilliant leader.
Mia Motley is the only contemporary politician we have in the Caribbean who is comparable to Manley.
All the others are spineless cowards and boot licking grifters.
I did a project on Manley at University...will look to see if I can find it.
@SnoopDog wrote:
What a brilliant leader.
Mia Motley is the only contemporary politician we have in the Caribbean who is comparable to Manley.
All the others are spineless cowards and boot licking grifters.
Two of the greatest sons of Jamaica…Michael Manley and Gil Noble….simply magnificent
Mama Mia is from the top echelon too…
.................Manley the Paradox
What I have read from Caribbean historians and political analysts, Manley is best described as a paradox.
One of Jamaica’s most popular PM and as one of its most economically destructive.
Among economists, fiscal conservative groups, and business historians, his 1970s administration is rated as a historic failure in economic management. When Manley took office in 1972, Jamaica was riding a post-independence boom with annual GDP growth averaging over 5%. By the time he left office in 1980, the country was plagued by hyperinflation, severe shortages, and a massive debt crisis.
Manley’s "Democratic Socialism" focused intensely on redistributing wealth rather than generating it, the state quickly began spending far more than it took in, resulting in a staggering budget deficit that peaked at over 17%. Jamaica suffered negative economic growth in seven out of the eight years Manley was in office (e.g., -6.5% in 1976 and -5.7% in 1980). Joblessness soared past 25%.
In 1974, seeking to capitalize on Jamaica's rich natural resources, Manley imposed a massive, unilateral production levy on multinational bauxite (aluminum ore) mining companies. While this initially generated a huge influx of cash for his social programs, it backfired over the medium term. Global aluminum companies rapidly cut back their investments in Jamaica and shifted production to more tax-friendly countries like Australia and Guinea, crippling Jamaica's primary export engine
While Manley's defenders argue he was the victim of terrible timing, specifically the 1973 global oil crisis, his core economic model was structurally unsustainable and fundamentally mismatched with the realities of a small, open island economy.
Manley himself adjusted his economic approach when he returned to power in 1989. He openly admitted that his 1970s policies had failed to generate growth and that the global landscape had changed. Manley embraced free-market capitalism, deregulation, and globalization. He went from a leader who wanted the state to control the economy to one who actively dismantled state control.
Manley recognized that his previous anti-capitalist rhetoric had triggered catastrophic capital flight. He actively courted the domestic business elite (the same group he had told to take "five flights to Miami" in the 70s) and invited them to help rebuild the economy. In the 1970s, Manley bought up private companies to place them under state control. In 1989, he did the exact opposite. He acknowledged that Jamaica’s high debt meant the country was entirely dependent on Western financial institutions.
Michael Manley had firmly set Jamaica on the path toward a modernized, liberalized, free-market economy, ironically completing the economic shift that his fierce capitalist rival, Edward Seaga, had spent the 1980s trying to achieve.
Sarge
References:
"The Poverty of Radicalism: The Public Career of Michael Manley" by Dr. Carl Stone
"Michael Manley: The Making of a Leader" by Arnold Bertram
"Struggle in the Periphery: Jamaica, 1972-1980" by Michael Manley
@SnoopDog wrote:
What a brilliant leader.
Mia Motley is the only contemporary politician we have in the Caribbean who is comparable to Manley.
All the others are spineless cowards and boot licking grifters.
Kudos to Mia Motley, but the others are not all spineless. If you do your research, you will find that there are others who actually stood up to Trump and refused to bow to his demands. So, Mia is a good spokesperson, but there are others who don't sacrifice principle for a data centre and bad habits (mawet)
@Besar wrote:
Kudos to Mia Motley, but the others are not all spineless. If you do your research, you will find that there are others who actually stood up to Trump and refused to bow to his demands. So, Mia is a good spokesperson, but there are others who don't sacrifice principle for a data centre and bad habits (mawet)
The biggest disappointment for me is watching that drunk woman in Tittie groveling and prostrating herself before those criminals and child rapists in Dumbfcukistan hoping to get some of their table scraps, while innocent fishermen in the region are being murdered by them.
And now we have the shameless betrayal of our Cuban brothers and sisters by her and the rest of these so-called leaders to further approve themselves to the Dotard and the rest of the criminals in his regime.
@SnoopDog wrote:
The biggest disappointment for me is watching that drunk woman in Tittie groveling and prostrating herself before those criminals and child rapists in Dumbfcukistan hoping to get some of their table scraps, while innocent fishermen in the region are being murdered by them.
And now we have the shameless betrayal of our Cuban brothers and sisters by her and the rest of these so-called leaders to further approve themselves to the Dotard and the rest of the criminals in his regime.
Snoopy....
Let’s be real about this whole situation, the entire debate is just a pointless yearly ritual by a toothless, incompetent UN that outlived its usefulness decades ago.
For over 60 years, the UN has been passing these high-sounding resolutions condemning American transgressions, and what has it actually accomplished for the people on the ground? Absolutely nothing. It hasn't done a single thing to ease the suffering of ordinary Cuban citizens because the UN has zero teeth to enforce anything against a global superpower.
Snoopy wants to reduce this to nasty personal insults about "drunk" regional leaders groveling for table scraps, and Besar wants to praise others for "standing up" to outside demands, but both of them are completely missing the bigger picture. All of that is just local gallery play. It wouldn't have made a shred of difference if the abstainers changed their minds or if T&T voted differently. No country's individual vote, whether they hide behind a cowardly abstention, pretend to hold some principled line, or flip-flop on a 30-year stance, is going to end a U.S. embargo that only the American Congress has the power to lift anyway.
It's pure delusion to mistake forum bickering and symbolic defiance for actual political results. Just like regional politicians are world-class at delivering viral speeches and mamaguying the public while failing to fix the sluggish bureaucracy and corruption back home, these UN resolutions are just empty symbolism on a global scale. Until people realize that symbolic hand-wringing and fancy policy papers don't equal tangible results, we're just going to keep watching this same hollow theater play out year after year while nothing changes.
Sarge
@SnoopDog wrote:
What a brilliant leader.
Mia Motley is the only contemporary politician we have in the Caribbean who is comparable to Manley.
All the others are spineless cowards and boot licking grifters.
di current group are mostly lucky lucky house slaves
..................
Mai talks well...Praising Mia Mottley while admitting people are still struggling isn't a contradiction, it’s just being realistic about what one person can actually do. She is brilliant at calling out global unfairness on the world stage, but.....?
Lets hear what it has achieved...just hot air !!!!
Which 1st world leader has supported her global unfairness?
They all ignore her rass....
The majority of the leaders went to UWI.....it tells a story.
Ok pseudos' I await?