What Arteta has on other current managers is that he is the Former Captain of a Team (the other is Carrick) that he has been managing for 7 years. He is also the longest serving, continuous stint, manager for a team. Moyes has the longest at a Club (Everton) but he has bounced around before coming back.
He understands the core values of the club and has been given time. The 1st 2 years , under him, Arsenal finished 8th and 8th. He had a task to clear out some challenging players (Senior Players) and replaced them with academy players (Saka, Reiss Nelson, Eddie Nketiah, Emile Smith-Rowe, Joe Willock) and then astute recruiting starting with the Goal Keeper and Defence. He builds his team around that back line.
He spent the hard work of rebuilding the team and now has gotten a solid International core (currently 5 players selected by England excluding Madueke and an injured Saka, 3 current World Cup winners and then starters for Brasil, France, Sweden, Norway Captain, Holland and Greece).
Also he has very good squad depth. The main area is still to recruit that top level striker.
Now, I would also rate Moyes and Emery as top managers too. Their challenges are their Directors seem to sell their best players each season.
None of the other current managers in the Premier League have shown any top level performance in the Premier League.