NOT CONVINCED
Lawrence: Maturity, not coaching, responsible for Test progress
“Clearly, it’s my opinion that the success is mostly due to the players maturing as opposed to coaching leadership and tactical prowess,” Lawrence said. Sammy, however, sees the rise to sixth in the Test rankings as evidence that the coaching staff’s plans are beginning to deliver results. Lawrence said nothing had yet convinced him that Sammy and his coaching team were competent, pointing instead to the progress West Indies had made before Sammy took over as all-format head coach. “Nothing has yet convinced me that Sammy and his team of coaches are competent,” former opening batter Lawrence said.
He pointed to the previous World Test Championship cycle, which ended in 2025, when West Indies drew away series in Australia and Pakistan-- results he described as “near impossible to achieve” and evidence that the team appeared to be on the right trajectory. Andre Coley was Test coach before Sammy was handed the position in December 2024 when he was appointed all-format head coach, and Lawrence said the subsequent decisions to drop players such as Amir Jangoo, then vice-captain Joshua Da Silva, Tagenarine Chanderpaul and Kavem Hodge contributed to what he described as a disastrous 2025-2027 WTC cycle.“In the most part, it’s the same players that have been re-selected in 2026 that have brought some respectability to West Indies fortunes,” Lawrence said, while noting that the improvement had come against some of the lowest-ranked Test-playing nations.
He also pointed to West Indies’ failure to qualify automatically for the ODI World Cup as further evidence against crediting the coaching staff for the overall improvement. “From 27 (all out against Australia at Sabina Park in 2025) to number six in the world (at the end of 2026). We did it, guys. We achieved our goal,” Sammy said in a CWI video release, when asked to identify his biggest highlight of the period. Sammy said his decision to accept the all-format coaching position was influenced by the confidence shown in him by the other members of the coaching staff. “It was not something I was really interested in, but they thought with the progress we were making with the ODI team, they thought that we as a staff could do it,” Sammy said.