Message Board Archives

...reported for suspect action.

In reply to spider


Where did you get this rubbish from

In reply to silver

Check Spiderisaskunt.com fuh de news!

In reply to silver

Why do you say it's rubbish?

Are you saying is fake news?

ICC

Is this really surprising news? Hasn't there been talk about his action?

West Indian umpires are nothing but a bunch of fu#king pantyseeds. Do those useless mofos ever call anyone for pelting? Shittingford, Norine, Beatmetoaton, Sagga Skunt Samuels, Jermaine Looseone.

In reply to Devin

West Indies umpire have to eat food too... you want dem end up on sidelines?

It is not surprising, he has been doing this for years now, I do not understand why the WI seniors did not warn him about the odd ball that he throws. This is one of the reasons why WI cricket is where it is. Kenroy Williams I notice was doing the same thing, but lately he has stop throwing a few.

In reply to WestDem

Come on man. Who the fu#k will reprimand them for doing their job? Is not like anyone is watching or anyone cares. I would fu#king call them the first time I see a dodgy action. I don't even need a second delivery for confirmation.

In reply to Devin

West Indian fans bray the loudest about subcontinental pelters and many justify their own..

The cameramen were zooming in on him a lot.

Link Text

In reply to Runs

Haven't heard our Guyanese experts talk much about this Beaton guy..

nothing new

years ago he was called out right here

they use a picture of him appealing...to accompany article about suspect action?

does he have 10+ degrees of flex in appeal too?

Ouch. I was saying that his elbow looked a lil suspect to a former colleague of mine..two days ago. I feared this would happen.

In reply to Devin


forget the umpires ,what about a bowling coach you paying hundred of thousand dollars per year? Fans have said that for some time ,and you want to tell me the selectors and coach can't tell?

Was expected.. couple years ago the umps reported him in a first class match.. way way pass the 15 degrees..

He worked with some local GCB coach when he came back.. but he and the GCB got wrong and he went his own way.. he's ah big boy told dem fellas he don't have time with Guyana cricket anymore..

In reply to spider

"West Indies pacer Ronsford Beaton has been reported for a suspect bowling action during West Indies' second ODI against New Zealand on Saturday. Beaton sent down eight overs in that match and picked up 1 for 60."

More here

All a matter of degree

Kesrick WIlliams is not too far from a similar call imho

In reply to camos

Boss, I was just about to post the same thing. Once they get into camp, not only will the coaches and trainers know, but I'm sure that even the players will discuss it amongst themselves, and possibly in the open as well.

Absolutely ludicrous.

In reply to Devin
indictment of the three selectors and the bowling coach!

guys getting money for nothing,this occurs far too often in west indies cricket.

... suh the coach never know this?

In reply to camos

Yep

In reply to dayne

In reply to jen

is there a 'Keswick' also?

In reply to anthonyp

In reply to camos

Too frequent an occurrence in West Indies cricket. Almost as though they're content to let the players graduate to the highest level, and then be exposed on the big stage.

In reply to Devin

it says we are either technically incompetent or blatant thieves!

Just a reminder that there has been no testing yet. His action was reported as suspect.

The two corbeaux could at least wait for confirmation.

In reply to Headley

Have you ever seen a West Indian player get the benefit of the doubt?

We gats teif, robbed blind, fined , suspended etc etc

Others walk away free.

In reply to sgtdjones

Fast bowlers chucking is dangerous..amputate them..

In reply to Khaga

So ya spin bowlers that umps were scared to call

is ok ? huh

In reply to Khaga

In reply to TheTrail

So only a West Indian umpire with international experience has the ability/confidence to expose the blatant pelters?

I have a real issue with chuckers. They fully fu#king well know what they are doing.

In reply to doosra

And u muddies called for him to be include in all formats.

In reply to tc1

just in case that were true, it wouldn't be different from you bimbammers calling for every little-talented cricketers out of your dot

What did I say, lang time ago...alyuh moddas! Noticed it from get go...when he doesn't get wickets, he gets frustrated & would start to pelt. He got carried-away when bishop bigged him up. Done.

anodda one that Ian Bishop called


#donotcallanymore

In reply to doosra

In reply to openning

maybe you don't have to call for them because they are all there there?

but an old strategy is to recollect false facts from the past and present it as some truth

tcl is pulling facts out of his rear end, if he needs to pull them out at all

In reply to openning

Kyle Hope topped the Trinidad batting averages to get a WI pick.

In reply to analyst-kid

He must had done something to be in the Red Force team, them posters want to go alone, with Kyle Hope as one of their captains.
Never get trick by a Trickydick.

In reply to Devin

Bucknor made dat call when umpires could still call players for throwing. Its interesting dat he never called Lawson.

Umpires cannot call anybody at de FC level and above anymore.

The protocol is to report the bowler for a suspect action which must be accompanied with video of the suspected deliveries.

The FC level games in de Caribbean doh have de necessary video coverage to submit so de Board does not even publish the bowlers dat umpires consider to have suspect actions.

Doh blame de umpires

have de necessary video coverage! Jeez, do I think what you mean by that is WI don't have the necessary technology/camera equipment to properly film it?!! Those equipment too $$$ for WI or WI aren't too sophisticated to operate it??!!

In reply to BeatDball

U expect to have proper video coverage with one camera at each end of the ground? You need side one cameras and dat eh available at FC level in de Region

In reply to doosra

letpost the records of the Bim players and the muddies and see how they stacked up.Even the great Hety had a below u19 record as compare to Springer

In reply to tc1

is that why springer cant make a bajan 3rd 11?

Wasn't it the late Tony Cozier who once said in one of his articles that the local umpires and coaches knew Jermaine Lawson was pelting as a younger, and they had a chance to correct his action, but instead, they did nothing about it?

We knew the outcome of that fiasco against Bangladesh.
Overs:------6.5------wickets----6-----Runs----3

What also triggered it was when the WI played Australia in 2003. Those Aussies weren't going to take that pelting lying down.

7 for 78

Did the local coaches destroy Lawson's bowling career?

In reply to TheTrail

Attempts were made to correct Lawson's action, though more probably should have been done. His action was under scrutiny from school days. After remedial work at one point his action seemed ok though his pace wasn't so hot. But then the pace went up again and you could see the deterioration in his action.

In reply to TheTrail

My feeling is that it is extremely difficult to change the action you grew up with and remain as effective. Not sure I've ever seen it done.

No surprise, it was a matter of time. Hopefully this doesn't ruin his career.

In reply to doosra

Thanks, for confirming Bim 3rd team, u see Springer ain't get out yet in dung
Heap

I’ve been chastised from the beginning of time on this MB, for relaying my observations of the similarity of Beaton and the great Dale Steyn. To me they appear IDENTICAL when SOMETIMES chucking the short deliveries and SOMETIMES when striving for extra pace. I was told by the “experts” back then, that for STEYN it was simply all the wrist. Steyn was subsequently tested if I recall correctly. He was cleared, because to me he simply didn’t go for extra pace during testing. Let’s see what happens with Beaton. I expect the same.

Typical WI culture?
If you can't beat dem, pelt dem down, shoot dem down or whatever else!

Sad!
If a bowling coach cannot recognize pelting, he should be nowhere near a ball field.
Same with umpires who could at least tell the local back street club administrators, if they exist or willing to get off their backsides and do something about it, in the interest of cricket.

Many nurses don't know how to accurately check blood pressure anymore as they just press the button form the electronic gadget to do it. Gadgets malfunction a lot and also need calibrating.
I was thinking cricket umpires lost practice in recognizing or calling no balls or are just part of the corrupt, primitive culture till I read this from Maispwi:

I saw it clearly in the first ODI abd knew it was a matter of time. Suspected before but the footage was not clear. Thats it for him.

In reply to jacksparrow
I am no expert but the other newcomer medium pacer looked very bad also.

Not surprising. I watched the match and felt Beaton chucked a few in between - even getting a wicket with a chucked delivery. I wouldn't say that Beaton's chucking is blatant, however, as was Jermaine Lawson's, for example.

By the same token, I am pretty sure I have seen that Aus lefty chuck a few too, but he never seems to be called.

Anyway, Beaton seems capable of bowling well without chucking. So he may yet survive this.

In reply to goofballs

Who Cotttrel? Nope he legit.

In reply to jacksparrow
Williams? I don't have him in my fantasy team, so I didn't study him.
I love Cottrell.

All this fake outrage is too funny to watch. Of course he get call for a suspect action. His action is ragged as fuq. And it's ALWAYS been that way. And if it looks suspect to the naked eye it's well past the 15 degree limit. Btw, save some of this outrage for when they call Kesrick. Cause his action worse than Beaton. What saving him is he don't have the same kind of pace. But if he ever pick up a bag of wickets he goose cook.

In reply to Norm

In reply to aliaskid13 When the actual match is going...why d fact don't alyuh speak out??

In reply to BeatDball

So...you couldn't see that for yourself? Why you think it took them so long to bring him into the senior team? Beaton been one of our brightest young prospects since he started playing. But the problem is, his action is ragged. It was inevitable. I just hope that his action is below the 15 degree limit and he can continue to play because I think he has the goods to become one of our best bowlers. He has the talent and he has the brain. I don't want him to turn into another heart breaking story like Jermaine Lawson.

In reply to aliaskid13

Start will not be called for one simple reason. His action is clean.

In reply to spider

In reply to jacksparrow
KOK Williams.
He bowled 5 overs for 18 runs and 1 wkt and was pulled.

Larrasshole awfully quiet..Beaton must be his quota pick..

In reply to goofballs

Williams flinging long now.. he's just a medium pacer and hardly takes wicket so I guess he safe for now..

In reply to anthonyp
First time seeing him.
Shameless WI Admins from captain, coach, umpire, selectors, management.
Represents what we are? Depraved, if you can't win pelt dem down, shoot dem?
If kids think their action is ok, or is ok to pelt, or don't know what a free hit is, can't totally blame them as much as the people whose job description is the governance of cricket in the region.

In reply to aliaskid13

Nonsense. So which other countries have been exempted?

It real surprising dat so many Guyanese wait till Beaton get reported to claim dat dey suspected his action was suspicious. And some ah dem who were making a case for his selection now blaming coaches

In reply to spider

So you think they going to report Starc in Aus? Did they report Brett Lee in Aus? Anyways, like I said, Starc used to throw a few. Nowadays he fling dung nearly every delivery. Nobody is going to call him in Aus. And the English wouldn't dare mention it because it would make them look like a bunch of cry baby sissies.

In reply to aliaskid13

So how does that work? Every neutral umpire that umpires in Australia conspire with CA to not report Australian bowlers they may think have suspicious actions?

In reply to Khaga
When I first heard people question his action on this MB,and that was from Caribbean posters I started to look closer,it looked suspect but I couldn't say for sure.Why was WestDem so quiet about Beaton but always reaady to pelt stones at Narine.Come WD "talk nah".