The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Message Board Archives

T&T all time XI

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 10:18:30 

Since everyone doing it why not.
Don't have all the great names but can still put out a formidable XI.

Jeff Stollmeyer
Charlie Davis
Gus Logie
Brian Lara
Larry Gomes
Gerry Gomez
Dreyck Murray
Ian Bishop
Tony Gray
Sonny Ramadhin
Didnath Ramnarine

Hon. Mentions: Learie Constantine, Herman Griffith, Bernard Julien, Merv Dillion and Darren Bravo.

 
matchstick 2016-12-07 10:22:27 

In reply to Andy99

All these greats playing in the current gen and Lara the most recent? big grin

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 10:42:58 

In reply to matchstick

Its understandable to you they might look great compared to what you've seen from Guyana in the recent past.

 
Oilah 2016-12-07 10:59:29 

In reply to Andy99

Inshan Ali, Nanan? and Constantine should be in as de allrounder

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 11:05:41 

In reply to Oilah

I tend to look more at accomplishments in the Test arena over FC.

 
doosra 2016-12-07 11:48:17 

In reply to Andy99

How Gerry Gomez ahead of Lil Bravo or Carew?

You didn't even mention Carew

 
Narper 2016-12-07 11:54:20 

In reply to Andy99

Joey Carew must cappo the side.

Richard Gabriel should be in contention for an opening spot

Rangy Nanan must play

Julien gets the allrounder spot

Jumadeen?

Richard De Souza?

 
Halliwell 2016-12-07 11:56:58 

Why is logie in that side?

 
Narper 2016-12-07 11:59:59 

In reply to Andy99

Opening bowler....Tim Gopeesingh

smile

I actually saw him open the bowling

 
Emir 2016-12-07 12:12:09 

In reply to Narper

big grin big grin big grin

 
camos 2016-12-07 12:28:39 

WTF no Ganga!
lol


Ram can't make that team over Carew or Julien.

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 13:05:04 

In reply to doosra

How Gerry Gomez ahead of Lil Bravo or Carew?


By performance.
30 bat average, 27 bowl average.
Though Carew deserved a special mention.

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 13:12:23 

In reply to Narper

Joey Carew must cappo the side.


Could probably come in for Logie.

Richard Gabriel should be in contention for an opening spot


This guy? Especially when you have Davis and Stollmeyer?

Rangy Nanan must play


He was really unfortunate not to play more but as I said rate INT over FC and Didnath did well in his Tests.

Julien gets the allrounder spot


Not over Gerry Gomez whose contributions tends to go unnoticed.

Jumadeen?


Jumadeen, Ali and Nanan would all be in contention if it was considering FC cricket for T&T but once again I looking at the highest level.

Richard De Souza


Like the trio above.

This is just my team and my conditions, feel free to post your(everyone not jus Narps) XI.

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 13:15:29 

In reply to camos

WTF no Ganga!


Although a joke, if it was regional cricket he'd certainly be in there or around.

 
Narper 2016-12-07 13:58:12 

In reply to Andy99

Didnath


Why yuh calling him this?

 
Narper 2016-12-07 14:00:53 

In reply to Andy99

Jumadeen, Ali and Nanan would all be in contention if it was considering FC cricket for T&T but once again I looking at the highest level.


But you do know...these guys were not selected for the WI on a regualr basis not because they didn't perform well at regional level...in that era a decision was made to only pick fastmen for WI..and we were winning

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 14:08:33 

In reply to Narper

Why yuh calling him this?


Guess me getting ole. shock
Thinking it was Didnath rather than Dinanath.

But you do know...these guys were not selected for the WI on a regualr basis not because they didn't perform well at regional level...in that era a decision was made to only pick fastmen for WI..and we were winning


Both Ali and Jumadeen had 12 Tests each, although it might not have been the best circumstances(A test here or there, flat pitches, not used well, etc.) they didn't do enough to do justice to their perceived talents.

Its why I said Nanan was unfortunate, he did well in his sole Test as well as being outstanding in FC.

 
Narper 2016-12-07 14:14:57 

In reply to Andy99

This is just my team and my conditions, feel free to post your(everyone not jus Narps) XI.

You know it is easier pick ON another man's team than to pick one of your own wink

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 14:16:11 

In reply to Narper

It is but it is more fun seeing all the different combinations and ideas.

 
Narper 2016-12-07 14:16:43 

In reply to Emir

Yuh know I am serious..Dr Tim Gopeesingh did open bowling for T&T in the 70s wink

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 14:18:17 

In reply to Narper

Someone I worked with told me that, wrt to Tim.
Can't find anything official on it, no cricinfo nor cricketarchive for Tim. Only a mention on a TNT site.

 
Narper 2016-12-07 14:35:02 

In reply to Andy99


I saw him live at QPO bowling against the Ozzies in this match


He played first class cricket from 1971-73 in Jamaica; in 1972, he played for the combined Universities of the West Indies team against New Zealand (the match took place in Jamaica).

In 1973, he played for the combined Universities of the West Indies team against Australia (the match took place in Jamaica), as well as playing for Jamaica against Tobago (the match took place in Tobago). From 1973-1978, he played first class cricket for Queens Park Cricket club in Trinidad. In 1975, 1976 and 1977 he topped Trinidad’s bowling average in the domestic cricket competition. In 1978 he represented Trinidad against Australia (the match took place at the Queens Park Cricket Oval) and against the combined islands (the match took place in Antigua).

Such is his fame in the international cricket world for his achievements- that, he has been featured by international sport site ESPN CRICINFO website collection of all famous cricket players worldwide with impressive fast bowler statistics.

Link

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 14:48:06 

In reply to Narper

They keep referring to what we would call local club cricket to first class cricket.

Edit: Found him, they have a different spelling to his name.

 
Narper 2016-12-07 14:49:00 

In reply to Andy99

Check out another match here with Tim Gopeesingh in 1973 against Ozzies at Sir Frank Worrel ground. Mona Campus

 
Dukes 2016-12-07 15:18:09 

JOEY CAREW had a SOLITARY GOOD TEST TOUR. Australia/New Zealand 1968-69 he had a great time but otherwise a TOTAL FAILURE!!!!!!

 
Emir 2016-12-07 15:58:26 

In reply to Narper

Yuh know I am serious..Dr Tim Gopeesingh did open bowling for T&T in the 70s wink


Yes, I actually saw him bowl live in QP oval, in was in the early 70's- I went home on vacation that year, it was a very weak team, I believe at the bottom.

He cannot make an all time C team in my opinion.

Prince Bartholomue is much better, and he still was not good to make the TT all time best.

 
imusic 2016-12-07 16:34:22 

Learie Constantine
Inshan Ali

Need to be in any all time T&T team

Honourable mention to Richard De Souza....certainly before Gus Logie....and I'm a Logie fan

 
Narper 2016-12-07 16:59:03 

Jack Noriega
Willie Rodriguezz
Rajindra dhanraj

phil simmons

ravi rampee

 
imusic 2016-12-07 17:17:35 

In reply to Narper

Phil could make it only because of the paucity of true international class openers from T&T

Aside from Jeffrey Stollmeyer....nobody really matches up....so Phil could fight up with the likes of Richard Gabriel, Ganga (who has the best FC stats of them all even though he mostly batted between 3 & 5 for T&T so he wasn't really an opener), and nephew Lendl for a spot.


The rest can't make an all time first XI

 
doosra 2016-12-07 17:47:05 

In reply to Dukes

JOEY CAREW had a SOLITARY GOOD TEST TOUR. Australia/New Zealand 1968-69 he had a great time but otherwise a TOTAL FAILURE!!!!!!


that's about 50% of his career HAHAHAHA


total failure in about 4 matches?

Let's look at some more detailed stats
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vs

Aus - 5 matches, avg 47.44

NZ - 6 matches, avg 37.27

India 3 matches, 5 innings, avg 24.2. In the 5 innings he scored: 3, 41,45,28, 4

England 5 matches, 10 innings, avg 22.5. In the 10 innings he scored: 16, 0*,40, 1,2,0, 36, 36, 40*, 1, 44
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So of his 15 innings vs England and India, he had 50% decent scores (7/cool

I do not understand how one could be labelled a "TOTAL FAILURE" with those stats

HAHAHAHA

big grin

 
methodic 2016-12-07 18:07:12 

In reply to Andy99

Thanks for putting this team together. I understand the criterion you used to pick your team. If I was to walk back through the years and take a census, from cricketers, fans, coaches and all in and around T+T cricket, the following will be highly unlikely or impossible.

.Anthony Gray or Gerry Gomez being considered for a T+T team ahead of Bernard Julien at his peak.

.A T+T spinner being picked ahead of Inshan Ali.

.Learie Constantine being left out of any Trinidad team.

 
imusic 2016-12-07 18:12:02 

In reply to methodic

Gray wouldn't be in competition with Bernard Julien for a spot.

Julien may have to take a back seat to Learie Constantine.

IMO, Bishop and Gray are the 2 best trini pacers ever. Period. Both unlucky with injury. Dillon and Rampaul are worthy subs.

 
doosra 2016-12-07 18:12:05 

In reply to methodic

Ramadhin not ahead of Ali?

 
Dukes 2016-12-07 18:22:54 

In reply to doosra

My friend, you clearly were not around when Joey Carew was stinking up the opening position in WI cricket.Looking at statistics without context sometimes leads to erroneous impressions
1.Joey Carew went to England in 1963 and failed as he did in 1966 and 1969
so he was 0 for 3 in terms of success on England tours

2.He failed when India toured the West Indies in 1971

3.He failed when New Zealand toured the West Indies in 1972.

Joey Carew also scored a few forties in test cricket when the matches were petering out to draws,thus giving the false impression of success.

I remember in 1971 when India toured the West Indies,Joey Carew did his usual poor imitation of a test opener and a few days before the 5th and final test match scored a blistering double century for Queen's Park in a club match and as a result Freddo was dropped and replaced by Carew who of course failed.To me that was the most outrageous selection to satisfy the local crowd in the Caribbean.

 
Dukes 2016-12-07 18:24:46 

In reply to imusic


IMO, Bishop and Gray are the 2 best trini pacers ever.


That is not merely an opinion it is an established fact!!!!!!

 
methodic 2016-12-07 18:32:57 

In reply to imusic

I am not sure Gray could bowl the new ball better than Julien. I saw Julien take a 9fer in the oval at the very back end of his career. Julien could get that extra mile of pace when he needed it and he use to swing and seam the ball. Many will also argue that at his best he could bat better than many of those contending as batsmen.

 
methodic 2016-12-07 18:38:38 

In reply to doosra

Ramadhin not ahead of Ali?


Maybe, he has a great legacy but certainly not Ramnarine.

 
imusic 2016-12-07 19:04:54 

In reply to methodic

I am not sure Gray could bowl the new ball better than Julien.



Tony Gray Test cricket


Overs - 148
Maidens - 37
Runs - 377
Wickets - 22
Average - 17.13
Strike Rate - 40.36
Econ - 2.54


Tony Gray FC cricket

Overs - 3425
Maidens - 649
Runs - 10283
Wickets - 451
Average - 22.80
Strike Rate - 45.56
Econ - 3.00


Tony Gray has the best test bowling average AND the best test bowling strike rate of ANY main west indian bowler in the history of the game.

He doesn't get the recognition because his career was severely cut short by injury.

But DAMN dude. Bernard Julien and Tony Gray in the bowling department?

No comparison boss. Gray by LIGHT YEARS.

 
methodic 2016-12-07 19:38:05 

In reply to imusic

But DAMN dude. Bernard Julien and Tony Gray in the bowling department?


Ok, 'long and long' deserves his pick. So the team might have two all-rounders.

 
methodic 2016-12-07 19:58:21 

I can't pick the best but I can pick the best I saw.


1.Richard Gabriel - The best opener we had against genuine pace.
2.Phil Simmons - especially before he got hit.
3.Brian Lara
4.Larry Gomes
5.Dwayne Bravo
6.Bernard Julien
7.Deryck Murray
8.Ian Bishop
9.Rangy Nanan
10.Inshan Ali
11.Anthony Gray

 
Andy99 2016-12-07 20:05:40 

In reply to methodic

Thanks methodic, your criteria was the best who you saw play fair enough.
Mine was best in Internationals in our history and I think it would be hard to argue against my XI using my criteria.
Now others please pick yours and say whats your criteria.

 
methodic 2016-12-07 20:15:07 

In reply to imusic

the best bowling performance I saw in one year (by a Trini) in regional cricket was executed by Harold Joseph in his first year.

 
imusic 2016-12-07 20:22:42 

In reply to methodic

Can't argue with that. Harry Jo was special. Too bad he liked the horses more than cricket

 
openning 2016-12-07 21:02:24 

In reply to methodic

My Antiguan buddy and I called the QPO twice before lunch, twice before Tea and just before the close.
We wanted to see, how Viv batted against him.
We both lived in Calgary, and my buddy was a bigger cricket nut than me.
After Tea, Viv took him to the cleaners.
This is the match we were exited to follow,
Trinidad and Tobago v Combined Leeward and Windward IslandsShell Shield 1980/81

 
methodic 2016-12-08 09:27:42 

In reply to openning

I watched that game and it is amazing how I forgot the details of it. I remember Viv being lucky to survive early on. I remember him ripping one past Viv off stump, Viv pushed straight down the wicket.
The ball was pitched on middle and off. That year with Joseph and the year Patterson took everybody to the cleaners were the best regional bowling performances I saw in spin and pace respectively.

 
methodic 2016-12-08 09:33:19 

In reply to Emir

I saw Gopeesingh bowl many times. He was good enough to make T+T team at the time. Remember now, Trinidad were in desperate search for a pacer for many years. Just before him Balkaram Seagram and Gomes use to open the bowling together. Gomes and Seagram were the same speed.

 
granite 2016-12-08 10:40:20 

In reply to Narper
Even now they dont get selected as they should, and when they do get selected they are targeted for drop if they can't get 5 wickets.

 
tc1 2016-12-08 11:31:03 

In reply to imusic

He likes the horses more than Sobers ?

 
Narper 2016-12-09 13:32:09 

In reply to Andy99

Ganesh Mahabir was a boss of a bowler.. I believe better than Bishoo

First-class span 1975/76 - 1987/88

 
methodic 2016-12-09 15:16:09 

Trinidad fast bowlers after Gomes and Seagram opened the bowling:
Tim Gopeesingh, Alec Burns, Eric Audain, Dean St Hillaire, Anthony Gray, Ian Bishop.

I missed a few years and came back to find, Marlon Black, Merv Dillon, Ravi Rampaul, Alleyne, Marlon Richards. I don't know if I missed any. (I missed Giles Antoine.)

My four prong will be.
Bishop
Gray
Ravi
Dillon

 
methodic 2016-12-09 15:19:20 

In reply to Narper

he came after Inshan, I think he played a little with Jumadeen. He was a very steady leg spinner.

 
doosra 2016-12-09 15:42:46 

In reply to Narper

Ganesh Mahabir had a decent fc career

to have that record at the time means he was good i suppose

 
Narper 2016-12-09 16:08:46 

In reply to doosra

Mahabir was very good...wrong time...could even get a look in

Mahabir was from Tunapuna...on one side of UWI....Anil Rajah ...a middle order batsman...was from St Augustine...jus outside the campus...on de other side

I believe Anil Rajah's son is currently opening for T&t.

Prakash Moosai....a middle order batsman...who is now a high court judge...was also from Tunapuna....all de bhais played for T&T around the same time

 
Narper 2016-12-09 16:16:26 

In reply to methodic

My four prong will be.
Bishop
Gray
Ravi
Dillon


Good prong attack....with Bernard Julien the allrounder

Julien played for the WI....but he was a boss at Kent in England...he has close to 500 FC wickets

 
methodic 2016-12-09 16:46:50 

In reply to Narper

Julien was one of the best swing bowlers I see in the West Indies

 
methodic 2016-12-09 16:52:37 

In reply to Narper

aay aay! ah leave Gabriel off the list, you could imagine that! But he can't make the four prong as--------- yet.