The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Message Board Archives

India's cricket Militarism

 
Casper 2019-03-10 23:42:59 

What is this all about?

It's a dangerous sign.

It's just not Cricket


Information Minister Fawad Chaudhry has asked the International Cricket Council (ICC) to take action against the Indian cricket team for "politicising" the game by donning camouflage army caps during their third One-Day International (ODI) match against Australia on Friday.

 
yardman83 2019-03-11 11:32:43 

In reply to Casper

It will be interesting to see how the ICC responds although on ereport on cricinfo said that the BCCI got permission from the ICC for the players to wear them.

 
Devin 2019-03-11 11:46:44 

The NFL does the same.

 
Kay 2019-03-11 11:53:25 

They did due diligence and got the all clear from the people who matters...

Nothing to see here!!

 
Tryangle 2019-03-11 11:54:31 

In reply to Devin

NFL's also contracted with the US Dept of Defense in this.

As ICC's a global body, it may be trickier to sanction teams for expressing particular support for a country's military. That said, I can't see FIBA, FIFA, IAAF ever encouraging something along the lines that ICC/BCCI have done.

It would be interesting though, if PCB took the suggestion of having the team wear something to bring attention to Kashmir issues.

 
runout 2019-03-11 12:24:20 

Don't believe that that was militarism...that is solidarity.

Why do the players dress up in pink for Jane McGrath's charity?

 
conman 2019-03-11 12:58:30 

this honestly is one of those ugly point of cricket

how the icc could okay this, well its not too hard to believe, its the BCCI the ICC wont say no

the indian cricket team has shown that they are willing to remove comradery in favor of nationalism, and they should be lambasted for it. How could you think that military camo hats are showing support for the victims of the attack, i just dont see the connection.

shame on the indian team

 
runout 2019-03-11 13:01:56 

In reply to conman

You do realize that the military was targeted in this attack.

India will do what is best for them.

 
conman 2019-03-11 13:18:27 

In reply to runout

what does that have to do with the cricket team?

 
granite 2019-03-11 13:58:18 

India have lost 40 Army personnel to a terrorist act and I would never condone terrorism for any reason,but the way India is behaving is well OTT,what the cricketers did was foolish and ICC should take actions.If Indians are so upset about this act,why don't they show some feelings about their treatment of the "lower castes".These people are murdered and beaten daily and the authorities turn a blind eye.Just recently petrol was poured over an untouchable and set on fire,burned to cinders,not a finger was pointed at the criminal.Bringing politics into a game is stupid.

 
runout 2019-03-12 06:26:50 

In reply to conman

The cricket team, and BCCI, after obtaining the clearance from ICC, engaged in a fund raising effort and a show of solidarity in the terrorist attack involving a terrorist group domiciled in Pakistan.

PCB is making much of this. No other board voiced any concern. Begs the question, why? Ah, who is politicizing this?????

Yeah, allyuh talk nah!

 
Emir 2019-03-12 08:52:36 

In reply to Casper

I am glad you are highlighting this. I can tell you with out question the majority of Indians are embarrassed and do not support the BJP and Shiv Sena atrocious response to the entire situation.

The elections makes people do dumb things.

What was particularly bad about wearing military caps is this:

1. It happened on the same day of International Women's Day- tens of millions of Indian women are fighting to end their country inherent discrimination of women and the injustice of the caste system. The Indian team let down these tens of millions of people. Instead of wearing these gun battle caps, they could have wear pink caps to show their humanity.

2. A small group of affluent right wingers wants to copy Western behavior when terrorist activities- The typical go in TV crying, marketing lines etc.

3. The Indian cricket team and top Indian players had an opportunity to break against their tradition by ignoring the poor and injustice. As the nations's most beloved institution, if Sachin, Kohli et all were to campaign against injustice, violence against women and poor Hindus and against the oppressive strain of the caste system, Indian will be transformed overnight.

They missed that opportunity .

 
Ridge 2019-03-12 13:49:12 

Australia better be careful in the next match they might come out with something
more lethal.

 
positiveg 2019-03-12 21:49:48 

In reply to runout

Suppose Pakistani players do the same, will you support it?

 
runout 2019-03-12 23:19:53 

In reply to positiveg

Of course I will support Pakistan in their demonstration of national unity

Why should I dictate how any team supports their countrymen in their time of disaster?

This is much to do about nothing. And some folks Making tangential posts about which cause a team or players should support is being flippantly ignorant or cunningly deceptive in masking social injustices with extremist violence. Caste and poverty is prevalent in every corner of this world. It may be shrouded in different terminologies. What is not commonplace is to have a neighboring country harboring terrorists and having them kill your soldiers, and then complain that you are expressing support incorrectly by raising funds and demonstrating solidarity.

 
positiveg 2019-03-13 08:23:06 

In reply to runout

Ok fair enough.

But what do you think about the BCCI asking for the ICC to ban Pakistan Cricket from the World Cup

 
CricketLuva4 2019-03-13 08:32:42 

In reply to positiveg

Excessive....unless the Pakistani team us suspect. wink

 
runout 2019-03-13 12:20:10 

In reply to positiveg

Simple. BCCI is wrong. No need to sanction Team Pakistan.

Pakistan cricketers have always been great ambassadors of cricket, and they are truly one of the shining stars in the New Pakistan.

 
Khaga 2019-03-13 12:30:12 

Why raise funds (thru cricket) for the Caribbean territories when they are hit by Hurricanes when people continue to live there knowing those are Hurricane prone..