HEADLINE: ‘What did Cornwall bring to the team? – former England quick Small mystified by off-spinners selection

Pages: 1  2  next 
link CaribbeanCricket.com Joined: Mar 5, 2003
Posts: 9995
7/30/20, 7:49:10 AM 

Former England fast bowler Gladstone Small has branded the inclusion of off-spinner Rahkeem Cornwall, for the final Test match against England, as a useless change and evidence of a West Indies squad that was overly conservative.  

The off-spinner was brought into the squad at the expense of pace bowler Alzarri Joseph for the decisive Test.  He did not do terribly in terms of economy rate but never really troubled the batsmen.

“Cornwall? What was that selection about? What did he bring to the table? You’ve already got an off-spinning batsman in Roston Chase in the team? What does Cornwall bring to that team?  You have got to have variety to take 20 wickets in a Test match," he added.

Read more at SportsMax


Full Story

link Raggs Joined: Jan 11, 2004
Posts: 32399
7/30/20, 8:17:07 AM 
avatar image
In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com

Ask him if he grow a neck yet. This is west indian bussiness, what it got to do with him?

link jacksprat Joined: Dec 17, 2002
Posts: 17550
7/30/20, 8:30:37 AM 
avatar image
I fully endorse Gladstone Small's sentiments!
He said nothing that I and others I and others have not been saying, before, during and after the test -Cornwall was a wasted pick given the circumstances.

To be frank, I am much more interested in the relative validity of Small's assertion than casting ad hominem attacks at him

link Narper Joined: Jan 3, 2003
Posts: 212447
7/30/20, 8:32:09 AM 
In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com

No neck Small should just STFU

If he is honest he would admit he has a problem with how Cornwall looks...rather than what he brings to the team

His size is the only reason Cornwall is being over scrutinized

link Maispwi Joined: Feb 3, 2003
Posts: 14724
7/30/20, 8:40:26 AM 
Size or no size what was the purpose of selecting another off spinner in weather conditions dat screamed out for an additional seamer?

Was management just playing politics? If so dey shud all be fired

link Drapsey Joined: Dec 25, 2007
Posts: 25757
7/30/20, 8:44:10 AM 
In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com

Looks like Small suffering from inferiority complex. He must be intimidated by the sheer size of The Wall.

link dayne Joined: May 28, 2007
Posts: 4987
7/30/20, 9:09:08 AM 
Well Small might have some disingenuousness in his comment, but on the morning of the last Test Holding also was commenting that the selection of the team was also illogical, the WI was a seamer short, as on analysis Chase was the only spinner in the Test to take wickets. Small IMO correctly stated that the WI came into the Test with a defensive mindset.

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 2:42:22 PM 
In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com

Despite all the "sentiments", etc, Cornwall's selection was justified, on the basis of the excellent performances in both the regional first class competition and the previous WI Test series.

He did not perform well in the only Test he played in the current series, but to question his SELECTION is to question the use of the domestic competition as the basis for WI selection. If selecting Cornwall here was wrong in any way, we might as well scrap the domestic competition and do a "friend pick" for every series.

I cannot understand why WI fans, including highly educated people, keep trampling on efforts to utilize unbiased methods for WI team selection. The route by which Cornwall, and about half the others in the current team, attained selection is the only one that could bring about improvement in the team's performance, and is fair at the same time.

All the great WI teams and players were products of the domestic competition, except maybe Gordon Greenidge. They might have been polished by English county cricket, Packer cricket, etc, but they all began in the domestic competition.

So, please stop attacking Cornwall. If that could be justified, then we should also attack Campbell, Dowrich and Hope, because they also failed badly - despite getting more chances.

link anthonyp Joined: Nov 1, 2009
Posts: 8116
7/30/20, 2:59:33 PM 
What did Campbell, Hope and the other batsmen bring to the team?

The batting failed the whole series but we quick to blame a bowler who played one match. Yes Cornwall didn't perform in the match but he earned his spot.

link Maispwi Joined: Feb 3, 2003
Posts: 14724
7/30/20, 3:03:37 PM 
In reply to Norm

So u are saying dat u wud play a second spinner in seam friendly conditions simply because he has amassed many wickets on spin friendly tracks?

Were we trying to win a match or please critics? Dis was not de match to play Cornwall

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 3:06:48 PM 
In reply to Maispwi

I am saying 2 things now:

1. Cornwall earned his spot.

2. You are trying to distort that fact with skuntery that leads to further skuntery.

link Halliwell Joined: May 13, 2005
Posts: 12425
7/30/20, 3:11:35 PM 
RCornwall v CHGayle (now) fielding at slip- Overwhelmingly Gayle
RC v CHG fielding in the circle- Overwhelmingly Gayle
RC v CHG bowling spin- marginally Cornwall
RC v CHG batting- rolleyes
RC v CHG value as an all rounder- overwhelmingly Gayle if Chase is playing

Regionals - Cornwall plays

link openning Joined: Nov 12, 2002
Posts: 36080
7/30/20, 3:18:29 PM 
In reply to Raggs

This is west indian bussines

Is Barbados not part of the West Indies, or only non Bajans living abroad are consider West Indians?
I stayed in a room at Almond hotels, he room was next door, he was in the Island bring cricket equipment for young cricketers.
Tell me what you have done for young cricketers, in your neck of the woods.

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 3:21:05 PM 
In reply to Halliwell

A few facts (seems like that is the only thing that gets thru to people here):

1. Gayle retired from Test cricket a long time ago.
2. Cornwall has a much better Test bowling record that Chase, in every way.

Logically, Cornwall should be the No. 1 WI spin option.

link camos Joined: May 5, 2003
Posts: 51189
7/30/20, 3:23:40 PM 
In reply to Norm
1. Cornwall earned his spot.


that does not make any sense! do you say the same about Permaul for the tour?

link openning Joined: Nov 12, 2002
Posts: 36080
7/30/20, 3:26:24 PM 
In reply to Norm
The team cannot afford two of them.
I was a big supporter of him, until I watched both of them together in the third test.
Only one of them should be in any X1.

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 3:32:07 PM 
In reply to camos
do you say the same about Permaul for the tour?

Yes. Permaul was dealt with very unjustly.

The fact remains that only the domestic competition and recent Test performance could be used fairly to SELECT the team.

link Maispwi Joined: Feb 3, 2003
Posts: 14724
7/30/20, 3:32:21 PM 
In reply to Norm

Cornwall earned a spot on the 15 not in the 11 for the 3rd Test.

Ah didn bring anyting into play dat shudn be considered by management when selecting teams. If dey doh think bout dese tings den heaven help us going forward.

Cornwall was not an automatic pick on the team unless dere was a spin friendly conditions available and de conditions for de 3rd Test certainly weren't

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 3:34:53 PM 
In reply to openning
I was a big supporter of him, until I watched both of them together in the third test.
Only one of them should be in any X1.

Don't confuse SELECTION with performance. Cornwall's selection was justified, based on both domestic competition and recent Test performance. His performance after selection determines his future selection.

Concerning Chase OR Cornwall, are you saying Chase cannot earn a Test spot as a batsman only? I would disagree on that.

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 3:35:43 PM 
In reply to Maispwi

Cornwall earned a spot on the 15 not in the 11 for the 3rd Test.

Hindsight whining!!!

link analyst-kid Joined: Feb 21, 2003
Posts: 13770
7/30/20, 3:56:13 PM 
After seeing how demoralised the WI top order was...I was plying for Cornwall AND Reifer.

When Wagner threatened the WI in NZ, only Reifer stood up to him and he ended up topping the WI batting averages.

Link Text

Reifer's left arm swing which caused him to rout WI in a warm up match meants he hould bolster the batting, bowling and fielding.

link jacksprat Joined: Dec 17, 2002
Posts: 17550
7/30/20, 4:25:26 PM 
avatar image
This was not about performance but about the wisdom of the team selection for the final test.

Those who know anything about cricket, and were not blinkered by the flag and plain insularity, questioned the wisdom of Cornwall's selection, beforehand; even while some were loudly braying for him to be included, even ahead of Blackwood.

That should have told us that this was based on more on passion and blind fervour rather than the best eleven and what was ultimately good for the overall balance of the team and what would have given it the best chance of success.

It was plainly idiotic to have included Cornwall, another rightarm offspinner when Chase, the incumbent was doing a more than commendable job filling that role, while West Indies' batting was always suspect.

link openning Joined: Nov 12, 2002
Posts: 36080
7/30/20, 5:24:16 PM 
In reply to Norm
If they were playing in Asai, play them together, but with tracks like the one we saw in England, no need for two of the same spinners to be in the team.
It was my first time seeing them bowled together, I saw no difference in their bowling, something the selection panel should take into consideration.
The team need a spinner, who can spin the ball, especially one with variation.

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 5:47:20 PM 
In reply to jacksprat and openning

WI should give all those who earned their spots a fair chance. If they are not good enough it will soon show, and will affect their future selection. That is the only way for WI to be fair to the players and to respect its own development plan.

Criticizing selections in hindsight is extremely unfair and counter-productive.

link openning Joined: Nov 12, 2002
Posts: 36080
7/30/20, 6:09:44 PM 
In reply to Norm
WI should give all those who earned their spots a fair chance.

In selecting any team, in any team sport, it should be balance,
There is no need for two off-spinners in the West Indies team.
One has to bring something different.

Very Happy Smile Sad Surprised Shocked Confused Cool Laughing Razz Embarassed Crying or Very sad Evil or Very Mad Twisted Evil Rolling Eyes Wink
 
Pages: 1  2  next