The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Oz should have had to beat India 2-0

sudden 11/19/23, 6:40:49 PM
sudden avatar image

debut: 11/27/06
52,870 runs

it is quite unfair that India went unbeaten and then lose the WC to Oz who were beaten in the qualifiers

if weighted correctly India would have had only to beat OZ 1-0 or 1 clear game and OZ beat India 2-0 or 2 clear games to win
- edited -
Discourse 11/19/23, 6:56:08 PM
Discourse avatar image

debut: 1/23/13
7,529 runs

In reply to sudden

Lol

The anomalies in sports that truly confound.

I always wondered why you are fouled by an opponent in soccer your team is penalized by having to play with 10 players after you are given marching orders by the Ref to leave the playing for treatment. I guess it would seem absurd to have the guilty party leave the field as well.
- edited -
sudden 11/19/23, 7:20:05 PM
sudden avatar image

debut: 11/27/06
52,870 runs

In reply to Discourse

The vagaries of rules in sports
Discourse 11/19/23, 7:25:16 PM
Discourse avatar image

debut: 1/23/13
7,529 runs

In reply to sudden

Indeed
KTom 11/19/23, 7:40:08 PM
KTom avatar image

debut: 7/22/22
705 runs

If India lost the second game, what's next? Best of five?
sudden 11/20/23, 2:32:36 PM
sudden avatar image

debut: 11/27/06
52,870 runs

imagine in a tournament to determine which is the best team, the team that lost one match loses

and the team that lost 3 matches wins the tournament
PalsofMine 11/20/23, 4:57:35 PM
PalsofMine avatar image

debut: 2/2/23
957 runs

India just has to send a thank you note to Afghanistan for letting Oz through.
PalsofMine 11/20/23, 4:58:18 PM
PalsofMine avatar image

debut: 2/2/23
957 runs

In reply to sudden

morale of the story. Just win the important ones. India now has learnt the lesson.
sudden 11/20/23, 5:35:56 PM
sudden avatar image

debut: 11/27/06
52,870 runs

that is why such important finals should be at least a 3 game series
natty_forever 11/20/23, 6:45:34 PM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
58,944 runs

KMT
positiveg 11/20/23, 7:03:47 PM
positiveg avatar image

debut: 3/29/07
23,982 runs

In reply to KTom

Best of whatever till India wins
brians_da_best 11/21/23, 5:25:10 AM
brians_da_best avatar image

debut: 11/13/02
18,331 runs

It should be a best of overall head to heads. So if australia has won 300 games against india and India has won 250. Then they should play 50 matches to decide the overall winner big grin
TanteMerle 11/21/23, 11:30:43 AM
TanteMerle avatar image

debut: 2/22/04
7,582 runs

The rules are set before the tournament begins.

Unbeaten New England Patriots played New York Giants in Superbowl 42.
Guess which team won.
By the way, the Patriots defeated the Giants in the last regular season game that season.

The rules are the rules.

Ozz are the World champs and deserving champs.
Stop this nonsense.