The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Message Board Archives

What is your West Indies Starting XI ?

 
LBW375 2024-05-31 11:20:49 

1. King
2. Charles
3. Pooran
4. Chase
5. Powell
6. Russell
7. Rutherford
8. Shepherd
9. Mottie
10. S Joseph
11. Mc Coy

 
anthonyp 2024-05-31 11:30:44 

1. Charles
2. King
3. Pooran
4. Powell
5. Rutherford
6. Russell
7. Shepherd
8. Chase
9. Hosein
10. Motie
11. McCoy/Alzarri

3 spinners is a must... pitches will be slower during the day..
McCoy, Shep and Russell are enough pace options.

Chase only bats early if we lose couple early wickets and we need someone to stabilize the inning.

 
Seechy 2024-05-31 11:31:20 

In reply to LBW375

For the first game or two, I will give the following XI some game time:

1. King
2. Charles
3. Hope
4. Chase
5. Powell
6. Hetmyer
7. Rutherford
8. Shepherd
9. Motie
10. Shamar
11. Alzarri

For the tougher games, we should go with our best XI with minimum of 6 bowlers:

1. King
2. Charles
3. Pooran
4. Chase
5. Powell
6. Rutherford
7. Russell
8. Shepherd
9. Hosein
10. Motie
11. Alzarri

 
Mustwin 2024-05-31 12:01:27 

1. King
2. Charles
3. Pooran
4. Chase
5. Rutherford
6. Powell
7. Russell
8. Shepherd
9. Hosein
10. Motie
11. McCoy

Alzarri is the VC so he will likely play but this is my preferred X1

 
doosra 2024-05-31 12:02:32 

In reply to LBW375

You need Hosein's bowling more than Chase's batting...mek it mek sense

 
WIForever 2024-05-31 13:23:07 

I feel this will be the XI
Hope
King
Pooran
Powell
Russell
Chase
Hetmeyer/ Shepherd/Rutherford
Hosein
Motie
McCoy
Joseph A/S

 
WIForever 2024-05-31 13:26:33 

Damn, I leave out Shepherd. He is a starter but the only person to leave out would be Hetmeyer. Provides an extra bowling option and can strike it as good as Hetty.

 
WIfan26 2024-05-31 13:32:17 

King
Charles
Pooran
Chase/Hope
Powell
Hetmyer/Rutheford
Russell
Alzari/Shepherd
Hosein
Motie
McCoy

Holy crap I’ve never seen this much headache in team selection before!!! I think we actually have a chance #Rally

 
positiveg 2024-05-31 14:02:42 

this is my XI

King
Charles
Pooran
Chase
Powell
Russell
Shepherd
Hosein
Motie
Alzarri
McKoy

and that's too start things off and see. I think when we need more batting power Rutehrford comes in and someone sits out.

 
doosra 2024-05-31 14:13:51 

In reply to positiveg

there is no way you are leaving Rutherford out

you don't need 6 bowlers and Chase

 
Baje 2024-05-31 14:19:20 

In reply to LBW375

Replace Shamar with Alzharri

 
Baje 2024-05-31 14:20:29 

In reply to anthonyp

That is my starting 11

 
DIEHARD 2024-05-31 14:57:02 

I liking the idea of playing one team for the weaker teams and bringing out the real team for the real games, the real team is unanimous and picked itself...the only issue is AlJo should be replaced by McKoy in the REAL XI

King
Charles
Pooran/ Hope
Chase
Rutherford
Powell
Russell/ Hetmyer
Shepherd
Hosein/McCoy
Motie
AlJo/ Shamar

The alternates get rotated in for the Associate matches

 
doosra 2024-05-31 15:13:51 

In reply to DIEHARD

anyone with a Pooran forward slash Hope is a mad man

 
positiveg 2024-05-31 15:36:04 

In reply to doosra

That's for the first two games. Trust me had Rutherford in and took him out before I hit send. And put in my list for first two games cause I want to see how we perform even against the lesser rank teams, cause I want us to play with intensity no matter who we playing.
I aint' wanna drop Rutherford but the thing is AlJo got to play cause hes' VC and Chase deserves his pick just from his recent performances. The thing is you have 4 group games so play and then make changes as you go along.

 
anthonyp 2024-05-31 16:10:26 

In reply to Mustwin

Alzarri was the VC... they didn't name a VC when they released th WC squad.

 
imusic 2024-05-31 16:20:19 

Allyuh obviously forget the lessons from playing against India 1983, Kenya 1996, & Ireland and Scotland in 2022.

You play your best and strongest possible team each and every match, unless the match is one where you’re already eliminated.

It’s the World Cup FFS!

SMH

 
cricketfreak 2024-05-31 16:40:32 

Whatever 11 wi play it will make no different it will be the same wi and the same result .so stop all the hype up about wi .

 
TheTrail 2024-05-31 17:05:40 

West Indies need Chase's batting and bowling, period.

 
positiveg 2024-05-31 17:11:31 

In reply to imusic

You play your best and strongest possible team each and every match, unless the match is one where you’re already eliminated.

Agreed every match put your best out there.
Make slight adjustment based on form, injuries etc

 
doosra 2024-05-31 17:15:54 

In reply to TheTrail

why they need his batting and ahead of who?

and would you prefer Chase the bowler over Akeal the bowler?

 
hubert 2024-05-31 17:37:12 

In reply to imusic

Agree. establish your best 11 and play them till.....

Just make sure they know their role(s).

 
LBW375 2024-05-31 18:13:51 

In reply to DIEHARD

I liking the idea of playing one team for the weaker teams and bringing out the real team for the real games,


Nope

Next thing we get a repeat of Kenya beating us ?

Full strength team for all matches. Changes can happen, horses for courses.

 
Madmax 2024-05-31 18:43:50 

In reply to anthonyp

That’s the team right there along with ur reasoning. I think Aljo will start simply because he is the VC and no other reason.

I’d keep him on a very short leash, if he doesn’t go well early up in the tournament, McCoy next man up

 
Madmax 2024-05-31 18:46:12 

In reply to imusic

Unbelievable people would suggest we not play our best 11 at allll times.


Ur right to seh fuh f… sake

 
doosra 2024-05-31 18:48:53 

net run rate
carry forward points etc

best team to maximise

 
positiveg 2024-05-31 18:52:17 

In reply to doosra

Yeah cause even though they say if we win the group and we go into the Super 8 we'll still be ranked as team 2, summen like that. But we'll carry forward some valuable points and runs.
SO we play hard try to beat erry body bad and go from there
Me no believe in easing up off of no team
Cause what if that team have a good showing vs another team or get a rain out match then what. We shouldn't leave anything to chance. Bang all and sundry once we can and then let the bails fall where they may.

 
DIEHARD 2024-05-31 20:15:00 

In reply to imusic

This isn't 1983. Australia did it on their way to the last WC, it's a way to manage player load. With the amount of cricket these guys play and have been playing load management is a real thing. U want a man like Russel to break down playing Papau New Guinea??

C'mon man. Athletes of today are not athletes of yesterday...these guys coming off of playing a LOT of cricket.

Take the opportunity to keep the bench match sharp and ready, Shamar is too much of an unknown quantity to have him in our best XI..let him cut his teeth against the easy match ups

 
anthonyp 2024-05-31 21:23:36 

In reply to Madmax

Alzarri is not the VC... they didn't name a VC for the WC.

 
imusic 2024-05-31 21:35:35 

In reply to DIEHARD

Russell got his rest when he didn’t play any of the warm up matches after IPL.

So did Pooran, Hope, and Joseph

Is either they professional or not.

And that load management lyrics is disingenuous.

Load management is used during the NBA regular season where there are 82 matches.

You DO NOT SEE load management at playoff time. It’s too important.

This is the World Cup. No time for that load management bullshit.

You assuming that these so called lesser teams are easy pickings and we could afford to play reserves against them.

And when they kick our asses, Allyuh load management advocates will be among the first to cuss management for not taking games seriously.

 
tc1 2024-05-31 22:59:33 

In reply to imusic


Is either they professional or not



English please.

 
Madmax 2024-06-01 00:03:35 

In reply to anthonyp

Actually they did, check Cricket West Indies site. Aljo is the VC of the WC squad

 
Madmax 2024-06-01 00:10:35 

In reply to anthonyp

https://www.windiescricket.com/news/Cricket-West-Indies-Announces-Squad-Update-for-ICC-Mens-T20-World-Cup-Obed-McCoy-Replaces-Jason-Holder/

 
Arlo 2024-06-01 00:29:53 

In reply to Madmax

Alzharri is the VC.

Here is the link

World Cup Squad

 
Madmax 2024-06-01 00:36:38 

In reply to Arlo

Tnx Arlo, I made a meal out of posting the link.

 
Arlo 2024-06-01 00:46:01 

My XI

1. King
2. Charles
3. Pooran
4. Chase
5. Powell
6. Hetmyer
7. Russell
8. Sheppard
9. Hossein
10. Motie
11. A. Joseph

Chase will be used as a floater, and gets in ahead of Hope as he can bowl and you need a 6th bowler. Alzharri gets in ahead of Shamar and McCoy as he is the VC. I don't see him being named vc and being dropped for the first match. As the first two matches are in Guyana and the 3rd is in Trinidad, both Motie and Hosein will play.

Hetty v Rutherford - Hetty is lucky he is in the squad. Either can slot in at 6.

 
Da-Vincy 2024-06-01 01:30:37 

Are they really going to start with Alzarri? Why? I hope not.

King
Charles
Pooran
Chase
Powell
Rutherford
Russell
Shepherd
Hosein
Motie
McCoy

 
Arlo 2024-06-01 01:37:22 

In reply to Da-Vincy

Yes, they are going to go with Alzharri to start the tournament. He is the vice captain.

 
Da-Vincy 2024-06-01 02:10:48 

In reply to Arlo

What should vice captain have anything to do with selecting the best team?

 
Arlo 2024-06-01 02:34:33 

Personally, I was surprised he was made VC, definitely not my choice. I would have gone with King as I feel that King is a definite pick in the XI, and the VC should be a definite pick. I agree that Alzharri is not a sure pick.

To answer your question, what should vice captain have to do with selecting the best team. The fact that they named him vice captain shows that he is in the selectors best team. No team will name a player VC for a world cup and then drop them for the first match.

 
Raggs 2024-06-01 05:42:04 

Have you guys realise the form that the windies are in and the opposition in front of them in the first game, they will select an experimental line up still testing out the best option for latter tougher fixtures.

 
DIEHARD 2024-06-01 12:27:53 

In reply to Raggs

This makes sense to me but..... It some how makes sense to others that Andre Russell be risked in a game Vs PNG

 
imusic 2024-06-01 14:24:10 

Anyone that thinks West Indies can take any team lightly and essentially feel they just need to show up and the opposition will roll over livin in an alternative universe.

 
DIEHARD 2024-06-01 15:36:45 

In reply to imusic

Bro, facts says we have the best squad we've had in a very long time, free from some of the forkery thinking and selections that have plagued previous WC squads. Everybody is fit and in form. The last time that happened we won the title. Even the injury to Holder and retirement of Narine have not significantly weakened this team. When the weak links in your 15 are AlJo, Shamar and Hetmyer...any XI we put on the park can easily beat Papua New Guinea and Uganda, it's not like the replacements significantly weakens the team, is not.Tino Best and Darren Powell coming off the bench.

Shamar needs match time, but is not part of our best XI, Hetmyers issue seems to be mental to me, not part of our best XI but I feel like time in maroon against these teams will help to clear those mental cobwebs.

And we don't know if injury will hit us later in the tournament, so keep the guys not in the best XI match sharp, and wrap Russell in cotton wool, we need him at his best for Afghanistan, NZ and the next round

 
imusic 2024-06-01 15:42:09 

In reply to DIEHARD

We’ll…..we’ll soon see. Tournament starts today. All the best to our team.

We’ll agree to disagree on the merits of playing reserves against perceived weaker teams.

 
DIEHARD 2024-06-01 16:25:16 

In reply to imusic

All Good, we Rallying!!! I'm extremely confident in our chances this World Cup, the last two ones, I was somewhere between apprehensive and cautiously optimistic...big grin

 
doosra 2024-06-01 17:36:40 

there might be no starting XI in Guyana

 
imusic 2024-06-01 17:42:36 

In reply to doosra

Why? Guyana reputation to the fore?

 
doosra 2024-06-01 18:13:24 

In reply to imusic

yea...falling in and out all week...overcast as we speak.

 
imusic 2024-06-01 18:15:16 

In reply to doosra

Damn. Hopefully it clears up for the match

Maybe Dey could move it to Bim. Dem have state of de art cricket stadium.

Ice baths, Rain proof and ting cool

 
doosra 2024-06-01 18:18:59 

In reply to imusic

yea and deh only 20 minutes from ogle intl airport...deh can get there in 2 hours max

big grin

would be a real shame and pressure on WI if rain affects their 2 minnow games

 
anthonyp 2024-06-01 18:23:16 

In reply to doosra

I see dem chaps asphalt de new road to Providence stadium in the pouring rain so maybe they got something planned for tomorrow big grin

Ah heard they bruk down the old manual scoreboard too... not sure what they replaced it with.

 
imusic 2024-06-01 18:23:29 

In reply to doosra

As far as I concerned, there are no minnow games.

People conveniently fuhgettin we take lixx from Ireland and Scotland 2 years ago with arguably a stronger team.

 
doosra 2024-06-01 18:26:57 

In reply to imusic

not sure PNG and Uganda there yet but yes got you

 
imusic 2024-06-01 18:28:25 

In reply to doosra

Kenya certainly wasn’t wherever “there” was in 1996

Alas……..

But I do get your point. To lose points due to weather from games we supposed to win on paper will hurt

 
Onionman0 2024-06-01 18:42:52 

West Indies team totally undercooked..... adopting outdated strategy..... batting very short.... will fare poorly..... adios!!!!!!

 
doosra 2024-06-01 18:42:55 

In reply to imusic

esp if NZ and Afg get to play those teams...it means WI gotta look to beat both Afg and NZ

an interesting start before a ball is bowled