The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Player of the Series

nick2020 8/28/24, 1:44:28 AM
nick2020 avatar image

debut: 7/2/12
28,787 runs

Shai Hope.

Interesting.
tc1 8/28/24, 1:47:10 AM
tc1 avatar image

debut: 6/12/04
17,840 runs

In reply to nick2020

Interesting


Why?
imusic 8/28/24, 2:04:49 AM
imusic avatar image

debut: 11/13/02
78,713 runs

In reply to tc1

Interesting


Why?

Because the player that undisputably won WI 2 of the 3 matches is Pooran
Chrissy 8/28/24, 2:10:37 AM
Chrissy avatar image

debut: 11/14/02
195,336 runs

In reply to imusic
I agree
natty_forever 8/28/24, 2:19:44 AM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

Who scored more runs and had the higher average? Shud be Stubbs.
- edited -
nick2020 8/28/24, 2:30:07 AM
nick2020 avatar image

debut: 7/2/12
28,787 runs

In reply to natty_forever

Can't have a guy party to a blank be MoS
nick2020 8/28/24, 2:31:56 AM
nick2020 avatar image

debut: 7/2/12
28,787 runs

In reply to tc1

Pooran had higher top score, significantly better SR and only was around 14 runs shy of Shai's total.

I guess they went with consistency.
chantilly 8/28/24, 3:19:37 AM
chantilly avatar image

debut: 12/8/06
5,088 runs

In reply to natty_forever

Except he got black washed 3-0��������
WIfan26 8/28/24, 3:29:12 AM
WIfan26 avatar image

debut: 5/1/21
2,449 runs

In reply to nick2020

Yea it doesn't make any sense

Nikhil, Vernon, SA female commentator

Vs

Bish, Ganga, Badree, Stacy Ann

Unless Nikhil was given the tie breaking vote lol
tc1 8/28/24, 3:57:03 AM
tc1 avatar image

debut: 6/12/04
17,840 runs

In reply to nick2020

Did Pooran complete the job in any game. Shai SR while batting with Pooran was statistically the same, lastly Shai's aggregate and avg was better than Pooran's.
TanteMerle 8/28/24, 9:12:29 AM
TanteMerle avatar image

debut: 2/22/04
8,195 runs

Come on, really?

Any fair minded person would have given Pooran a failing grade in the 2nd game.
Poor, very poor batting.
Wasted 2 reviews.

Give him props for the 1 st and last game.

Now look at Shai Hope.
High strike rates in all games.
Teef out in 1st game.
important catch in 2nd game off Shepherd.

The insularity here is amazing.
Hope had 3 great games,
Pooran had 2.
Shepherd had 2.
Cappo had 2 great captaincy games.
Stubbs loss 3 nil.
Now who is MOS, really?

Sometimes, I wonder about the intelligence level of some posters here.
- edited -
nick2020 8/28/24, 9:34:17 AM
nick2020 avatar image

debut: 7/2/12
28,787 runs

In reply to TanteMerle

Fair
natty_forever 8/28/24, 10:06:57 AM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to nick2020

Series...
natty_forever 8/28/24, 10:09:01 AM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to TanteMerle

I only mentioned Stubbs to rubbish the Pooran argument. Losing team member never gets that unless record breaking.
tc1 8/28/24, 5:04:34 PM
tc1 avatar image

debut: 6/12/04
17,840 runs

In reply to natty_forever

You came back from sabbatical, sounding like Sudden.
natty_forever 8/28/24, 10:30:48 PM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to tc1

Thanks for the compliment!
- edited -
PalsofMine 8/29/24, 11:09:40 PM
PalsofMine avatar image

debut: 2/2/23
1,596 runs

Let's have a conversation about Cappo. When last has he really performed as a batsman? Statistically he is the worst by far of the top 7 (inclusive of Chase and Hety) and some would say that he doesnt even clapbig grin