The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Green is a Dunce!

Logic 9/8/24, 4:59:35 PM
Logic avatar image

debut: 6/19/05
4,774 runs

A lot of folks getting called dunce so we cant leave out Green. Dunce not just for bowling 2 spinners in last 2 overs but one spinner who does not have the height or guile to provide the variation needed and the other who does not spin the ball. Yes, ball was turning but the same tackiness that get turn for spinners will help pacers with change of pace with an old ball at the death
Speed100 9/8/24, 5:14:40 PM
Speed100 avatar image

debut: 8/30/23
301 runs

Shiv and Ambi get it wrong I believe. King is the best captain in the region. I believe he also the most educated.
- edited -
Logic 9/8/24, 5:56:02 PM
Logic avatar image

debut: 6/19/05
4,774 runs

In reply to Speed100

Shiv and Ambi? Isnt that a captain's call. You suggesting bowling spinners at depth was pre-planned?

I will leave you King comment alone until some evidence one way or the other is available
natty_forever 9/8/24, 6:19:48 PM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to Logic

He meant they should have made King captain.
natty_forever 9/8/24, 6:21:54 PM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

So goes the captain (dunce) so goes the team.
voiceofreason 9/8/24, 6:48:28 PM
voiceofreason avatar image

debut: 1/20/04
89,467 runs

Whoever is responsible for promoting Green ahead of Fabien Allen, Wasim or Primus need reprimanding. I believe that would be Greens decision.
doosra 9/8/24, 6:49:03 PM
doosra avatar image

debut: 5/26/04
94,420 runs

In reply to voiceofreason

it was a strategic move to have the better finisher at the end

a good move imho
natty_forever 9/8/24, 6:52:46 PM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to doosra

The batting order wasn't an issue. It's the batting of a few that is.
Speed100 9/8/24, 7:32:56 PM
Speed100 avatar image

debut: 8/30/23
301 runs

In reply to Logic

King captained this exact team last year!!
natty_forever 9/9/24, 12:07:42 AM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to Speed100

So that lesson would have prepared him for this year.
Logic 9/9/24, 5:21:29 PM
Logic avatar image

debut: 6/19/05
4,774 runs

In reply to Speed100

Point taken. I would agree that unless the overseas player is an accomplished captain for his own national team, or least at first class level, the captain should be selected from the region
bobby 9/10/24, 11:45:18 AM
bobby avatar image

debut: 2/14/03
6,225 runs

Do any of you guys actually watch, read or listen? King is the appointed Captain of the Falcons. However, he has been injured since the World Cup and therfore Green was appointed Captain in his absence. King eventually played the last game under Green. What is the issue? Green has also captained the Amazon Warriors and has played for quite a few years. He understands the conditions and knows the players. The conditions dictated that the spinners made no sense. That is a cricketing decision, based on pitch conditions