The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Wow. Ump you blind

Page: 1  2 3 next 
positiveg 9/20/24, 2:45:23 AM
positiveg avatar image

debut: 3/29/07
24,775 runs

The ball hit the bat before hit his pad.and ultra edge show it
natty_forever 9/20/24, 2:46:59 AM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to positiveg

And because of that, we now have this.
positiveg 9/20/24, 2:48:29 AM
positiveg avatar image

debut: 3/29/07
24,775 runs

In reply to natty_forever

Yes and the o ly argument Knight Riders have is that Imad came off the field of play.
TanteMerle 9/20/24, 2:49:21 AM
TanteMerle avatar image

debut: 2/22/04
8,195 runs

It's amazing that Bishop and other experienced commentators don't know the rules.

If a player leaves the field he can come back.

I will look up the rule and post it.
natty_forever 9/20/24, 2:49:39 AM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to positiveg

Spoil up a very gripping game.
positiveg 9/20/24, 2:50:29 AM
positiveg avatar image

debut: 3/29/07
24,775 runs

The umpire mad the error. Ain't he fault they tell him come off the field. Just play the game. Fair is fair
positiveg 9/20/24, 2:50:58 AM
positiveg avatar image

debut: 3/29/07
24,775 runs

In reply to TanteMerle

Well Alex did say he could come back. She pointed out
- edited -
TyTy35 9/20/24, 2:51:30 AM
TyTy35 avatar image

debut: 12/6/13
575 runs

In reply to positiveg

They are right tho he should not be able to come back on the field after he leaves and the new batsman has made his way to the middle.
sgtdjones 9/20/24, 2:53:52 AM
sgtdjones avatar image

debut: 2/16/17
36,885 runs

In reply to natty_forever

Newdread doesn't know the rules...
positiveg 9/20/24, 2:54:31 AM
positiveg avatar image

debut: 3/29/07
24,775 runs

In reply to TyTy35

Yes but the umpire made an error. Was their error for not making the right call. It dine moce on.
Chill and play
natty_forever 9/20/24, 2:54:38 AM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to sgtdjones

He does, but erring on the side of fair play.
natty_forever 9/20/24, 2:55:39 AM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

The thing is I needed that wicket. FL.lol
positiveg 9/20/24, 2:57:00 AM
positiveg avatar image

debut: 3/29/07
24,775 runs

In reply to sgtdjones

Doesn't seem so cause he too like he was siding with Uncle Phil.
Phil knew was a bad call and arguing wrong and strong.

The 2rd umpire made an error then corrected it. The batsman shouldn't suffer. And ain't even matter who I supporting. Right is right
Logic 9/20/24, 2:59:26 AM
Logic avatar image

debut: 6/19/05
4,774 runs

Disgracefully weak of the umpires to not make a decision and enforce their will sooner
TanteMerle 9/20/24, 3:01:38 AM
TanteMerle avatar image

debut: 2/22/04
8,195 runs

I do not know why all the discussion and argument.

The umpires made a mistake and corrected it.

The worse part is Pollard and Simmons reactions.

I loss respect for them.
Not like I had much respect for Simmons anyway.
- edited -
sgtdjones 9/20/24, 3:02:36 AM
sgtdjones avatar image

debut: 2/16/17
36,885 runs

....TIEF, and more Tief ...against TKR...razz
TanteMerle 9/20/24, 3:04:26 AM
TanteMerle avatar image

debut: 2/22/04
8,195 runs

In reply to sgtdjones

Shut de hell up.

Bravo touched the ropes yesterday on the field and the 3rd umpire gave it as a good fielding.

Where were you and your comments then
natty_forever 9/20/24, 3:04:34 AM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,473 runs

In reply to sgtdjones

Pray tell.
sgtdjones 9/20/24, 3:05:21 AM
sgtdjones avatar image

debut: 2/16/17
36,885 runs

In reply to TanteMerle

Dat was yesterday ...dis is today....still Tief...razz
TanteMerle 9/20/24, 3:09:45 AM
TanteMerle avatar image

debut: 2/22/04
8,195 runs

In reply to sgtdjones

How de hell is it a thief when the correct decision was made in the end.

I remember a batsman going in the pavilion and being recalled in another game.

I will research it and post it here.
- edited -
TanteMerle 9/20/24, 3:12:18 AM
TanteMerle avatar image

debut: 2/22/04
8,195 runs

I said that I remember this

Suck it up.

I could not remember the match, but I knew that I was watching the game when it happened.

There was a great discussion by commentators and even umpire afterwards.

The general understanding is hat the correct decision should be sought.

In the case tonight, the batsman left the field under the mistake that he was out (umpires said he was0.

When they discovered their mistake, they recalled him.

Correct decision.

BYT: I don't support ABF team, just looking at fairness.
- edited -
Halliwell 9/20/24, 3:18:57 AM
Halliwell avatar image

debut: 5/14/05
22,802 runs

In reply to TanteMerle

The law now reads: "An umpire shall intervene if satisfied that a batsman, not having been given out, has left the wicket under a misapprehension of being out.
googley 9/20/24, 3:22:24 AM
googley avatar image

debut: 2/9/04
22,994 runs

In reply to positiveg

One ice cream would have kept him busy lol
TanteMerle 9/20/24, 3:23:13 AM
TanteMerle avatar image

debut: 2/22/04
8,195 runs

This deleted texts annoying.

ADMIN FIX THIS CRAP.
- edited -
googley 9/20/24, 3:23:23 AM
googley avatar image

debut: 2/9/04
22,994 runs

In reply to sgtdjones

How much cheating needed for the win, besides the mango flings? razz
Page: 1  2 3 next