Message Board Archives

I think the cogniscenti and cricket connossieurs on here would appreciate it

Batters mostly ran singles and twos

They took the time to build an innings

Not every ball was hit out the park. Very few in fact.

Even saw defensive strokes in the T20 format. This must have been thrilling for those aficionados.

Bowling was ok with no one that I saw having suspect actions.

Lots of “spinners” who weren’t afraid to flight the ball

Sometimes hard to tell the difference between some seamers and spinners…..but decent none the less.

The overall standard of fielding needs to improve. Hope Ms Henry is ok. There are some outstanding fielders (Dottin is an example) but for the most part, those I’ve seen have been very average.

All in all, a slower, more pedestrian and……dare I say…..geriatric style of play that is bound to excite those that long for “real cricket”.

In reply to imusic

not a bad assessment

if you had a look at this team last year you might have been really disappointed

they have made a lot of strides esp on the fitness levels...

still work to do to get back to the 2016ish days

also you are looking at the NOT big 3 who either got knocked out or didn't make this round..they generally are a notch or 2 above the rest

In reply to doosra

I didn’t have much hope for them so they certainly exceeded my expectations.

But I was just going on past results. First time I’ve really seen our team in action.

Matthews and Dottin are several cuts above the rest. Didn’t see much of Taylor as I understand she too is or was in that category.

Of the others, Alleyne isn’t bad as a seamer. Ramharack is a decent spinner and not bad in the field.

But at this stage, it’s really a different game to the men. That true of most sports I guess.

In reply to imusic

they are going thru a transition phase from that 2016ish team

2 of the recent U19 players - James and Munisar are now making their way... Ramharack is now a settled fixture, replacing Anisa Mohammed, etc

Taylor has been carrying an injury or 2 for over a year now so you are not seeing her best. In this tournament she became only the 2nd woman to score 1000 WC runs...her intl record is excellent

And yes Dottin and Hayley are as good as any you'd find around the world.

There are several good young spinners coming thru the age group. What they need is a nextgen of Taylors, Matthews, Dottins, that is a hard one but fingers crossed

In reply to imusic
A really good assessment

I owe a Dottin an apology. I wanted to know how she walked right back in after a two year absence. She showed me why.

In reply to Chrissy

WHEN WERE U\YOU RIGHT TWISSY?

DEDING WID LAF ON TWISSY FACE.,.

In reply to imusic

For awhile with all the diving taking place, in the men game, on the football field, the women game was much more attractive in every sense of the word.

Are you sure, sure, sure you didn't watch 2016 final when WI were double Champs and women's game was just before the men? Sure?

In reply to doosra

In reply to imusic

you might appreciate this article a little bit

In reply to openning

she is a fighter...she is now 32 and with better health she still has much to offer, especially at this transitional stage

In reply to doosra

This is sports, not a Desk job.
Do you say an injured Taylor is better than the player she replaced?
Leave age and experience out of the conversation. From the time I saw her hobbling on the field earlier in the tournament and then opening the inning, I wondered what the hell was going on.
If you tell me, that Taylor, on one leg, is better than most of the other players, I would say you watched many blind people matches.

In reply to openning

yes to Taylor being better than anyone on the sidelines - Gajnabi, et al...

once she is fit to some extent she is still better than most in the WI

and why can she not aspire to greater fitness now? 32 is no age , it is the peak for many

In reply to doosra

In reply to doosra

Thanks Doosie

In reply to openning

She is sure as hell better than Nation (no.spring chicken herself) and that's even if she lost a whole leg

In reply to openning

Same injury, different stage of healing. Basic commonsense. We didn't need the commies to mention she was moving better, we saw it. Shemar bowled down Oz with the same injury...treated and 1 day later. Yuh smarter than that

In reply to openning

Women also swing the ball more than men

In reply to spider

That makes some sense. They bowl a lot slower than men which gives the ball time to swing

In reply to imusic

The ball is also lighter than the one men use

In reply to spider

Didnt know that. Thanks

In reply to iTito

In reply to SnoopDog

T&T nursery rhyme by Sparrow the famous Grenedian story teller

Well, ah said to meself, "that was meh last supper!"
(Ten to one is murder!)
But ah get away; and ah run, till ah reach Johnson corner
(Ten to one is murder!)
They take off in meh skin with big stick an' boulder
(Ten to one is murder!)
The fella in front was a very good pelter
(Ten to one is murder!)

In reply to doosra

I listened to a radio show last evening with the captain. One topic discussed was fitness and dot balls.
In any T20 match, a player who cannot run quick singles or is unable to chase balls has no right to be selected.
None of our ladies is in the class of Viv, Lara or the greatest.
After seeing Taylor fielding earlier in the series, I maintained that having to leave the field, return to open, retire because of that same injury, and be selected for with that same injury makes absolutely no sense.