The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Message Board Archives

King and Athanaze - what gives?

 
DirtyDan 2024-10-23 16:26:31 

Pretty Bat Floyds with no substance?

These guys flatter to deceive.

 
velo 2024-10-23 17:11:36 

In reply to DirtyDan

Athanaze is overated maybe he can become a decent player but he doing nothing in the wi team

 
voiceofreason 2024-10-23 17:15:42 

In reply to DirtyDan

King has played 38 matches @ 29.66.
Athanaze has played 11 Matches at 27.09.

So King has played twice as many matches.

 
Curtis 2024-10-23 17:31:52 

These guys may hold spots for too long if they don't start producing at a higher level, with the dreaded expectation or potential label.

 
PalsofMine 2024-10-23 17:59:21 

Sadly, King is a one performance per series player. Athanaze it now seems has had one good FC season and that is it for him. He is just not getting to terms with international standards. The most concerning, however, is Hope who has not performed at all on this tour (or on the last tour of Australia). Is it that he is playing too much substandard franchise cricket and so is not able to raise his game easily to international standard any more? Another tour to SL and the same result as always. This is why we need to do some A team tours to SL to get our players more familiar with those conditions.

 
Speed100 2024-10-23 18:10:26 

In reply to voiceofreason

Stop with your bullshit . This is International cricket and professional sports, the highest level. If you are selected it means you perform at the regional level or you’re a special talent. Athanaze is neither . He didn’t even Dominate at list A or first class. You saying only his 11th match. My question is how many more?

What about players who score debut 100/50 ?
Did they needed 2yrs in international cricket to adjust.

 
voiceofreason 2024-10-23 18:33:35 

In reply to Speed100

What about players who score debut 100/50 ?
Did they needed 2yrs in international cricket to adjust


Don't understand your point here? If a player scores a debut 100 does that make him a quality player?

After 11 innings Sarwan averaged 29.88:

https://howstat.com/Cricket/Statistics/Players/PlayerProgressSummary_ODI.asp?PlayerID=2220

Lara averaged 27.53 after 18:

https://howstat.com/Cricket/Statistics/Players/PlayerProgressSummary_ODI.asp?PlayerID=0979

Other than Shai Hope name a player who has dominated at LIST A or First class.