The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Why no spinner?

TyTy35 11/24/24, 6:35:27 PM
TyTy35 avatar image

debut: 12/6/13
580 runs

On this this track you need a specialist spinner, the sameness of this attack is boring.
imusic 11/24/24, 7:04:57 PM
imusic avatar image

debut: 11/13/02
79,481 runs

In reply to TyTy35

Because Roach have to play
natty_forever 11/24/24, 7:12:01 PM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,970 runs

In reply to imusic

Cheerier going fix your raas.lol
imusic 11/24/24, 7:14:56 PM
imusic avatar image

debut: 11/13/02
79,481 runs

In reply to natty_forever

Why? I stated a fact big grin
Raggs 11/24/24, 7:19:48 PM
Raggs avatar image

debut: 1/12/04
35,522 runs

In reply to imusic

Time Roach fi sit dung...What I hate with these windies veterans you have to shame them into retirement.
natty_forever 11/24/24, 7:30:31 PM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
59,970 runs

In reply to Raggs

In his defence. Never pick himself. I have faith in my coach.
granite 11/24/24, 7:56:01 PM
granite avatar image

debut: 11/1/13
14,133 runs

In reply to imusic

Does that mean that Roach must play?lol
PalsofMine 11/24/24, 11:25:06 PM
PalsofMine avatar image

debut: 2/2/23
1,805 runs

The absence of a quality spinner is glaring. Bizarre selection by the Head Coach
anthonyp 11/24/24, 11:40:37 PM
anthonyp avatar image

debut: 11/2/09
12,514 runs

Next match they gonna drop Shamar, Alzarri or Seales and claim that they are managing their workload...

Ole man Roach gotta play.... wonder how long this transition period gonna last for him? Another 10-20 test?

They already way behind on the over rate so a spinner will definitely play in the next match... can't risk losing captain slow poke for couple matches.
WIfan26 11/24/24, 11:52:17 PM
WIfan26 avatar image

debut: 5/1/21
2,572 runs

In reply to imusic

Some would argue Roach is the spinner twisted
cumberland 11/25/24, 12:47:57 AM
cumberland avatar image

debut: 12/4/22
978 runs

In reply to Raggs

Time Roach fi sit dung...What I hate with these windies veterans you have to shame them into retirement.


The dilemma many a red ball West Indian cricketer is going to face going forward.

Now I don't know Roachie's finances, so this isn't about him per se but who would have thunk that one James Anderson would pitch his name in the ppl mega auction with the possibility of going unsold come tomorrow night.

Now JA might well ketch a couple crore which would be worth the effort.

You think Kemar has that option at his disposal? Look until the WI selectors tell him siddung let Roach bowl himself into the ground. Every dollar earned doing that matters.
imusic 11/25/24, 2:36:03 AM
imusic avatar image

debut: 11/13/02
79,481 runs

In reply to WIfan26

Some would argue Roach is the spinner twisted

Oh gorm! big grin big grin
imusic 11/25/24, 2:41:08 AM
imusic avatar image

debut: 11/13/02
79,481 runs

In reply to cumberland

Look until the WI selectors tell him siddung let Roach bowl himself into the ground. Every dollar earned doing that matters.

And in the meantime, a player like Thorne, Phillip, Mindley, Layne etc misses out on important international exposure.

People here always bawlin for players to play more red ball cricket. We not playing Australia or India. We playing Bangladesh at HOME.

What more ideal scenario to expose young promising (well Phillip eh young but you get my point) seamers to cricket at this level you going to get?

To play Roach for what purpose exactly?
- edited -
cumberland 11/25/24, 4:49:14 PM
cumberland avatar image

debut: 12/4/22
978 runs

In reply to imusic

To answer your question: aid and abet his retirement plan. Social welfare. A theme CWI seems to have embraced since they brought in red ball franchise.

The youngsters of whom you speak aren't quite there for test cricket anyhow. Their turn will come if the can find sufficient first class A Team cricket within the next 18-24 months to broaden their experience.

As it is I don't see Kemar going on for another 12-15 mths.
Yadi 11/25/24, 11:04:54 PM
Yadi avatar image

debut: 12/26/03
39,995 runs

In reply to TyTy35

Five-prong ... with Athanaze and Hodge.
GMA 11/25/24, 11:07:15 PM
GMA avatar image

debut: 3/1/03
486 runs

In reply to imusic

Because he is worth his place. People have to earn the right to play. Roach was a massive loss in England too. He is a class act.
imusic 11/25/24, 11:54:52 PM
imusic avatar image

debut: 11/13/02
79,481 runs

In reply to GMA

We disagree on this