The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Why Sobers Was So Special

spider 5/2/25, 3:59:09 PM
spider avatar image

debut: 7/11/03
4,569 runs

[b]In the pantheon of the game’s elite all-rounders, the name closest to Sobers might be Jacques Kallis. The South African was an excellent, if slightly reticent, stroke player and a highly competent pace bowler capable, at his best, of generating alarming velocity. Other members of this rarefied club include Keith Miller, Ian Botham, and Imran Khan.

Looking throughout cricket’s long history, however, it is clear that the true, top-class all-rounder has not emerged all that frequently. This is likely an indication of how taxing the all-rounder’s job can be and how difficult it is to master both batting and bowling, two markedly disparate skills requiring totally dissimilar gifts. To excel at both normally requires a lavish and varied supply of natural gifts along with an adequate expenditure of the time and effort necessary to nurture them to a high level.

Mastering both batting and bowling at the highest level is difficult in the same way that it is difficult for a top-level sprinter to become a top-level long-distance runner or for a pitcher in the major leagues in baseball to also be a champion slugger. Bits-and-pieces players abound, but the genuine article is hard to find.
[/b]
Jamaica Observer
Brerzerk 5/2/25, 8:01:10 PM
Brerzerk avatar image

debut: 3/16/21
12,340 runs

In reply to spider

You're gonna bring Dukes back... Garfield St. A. simply the greatest of the greats. On retirement his record- Highest test run-scorer, highest # of test tons,in top ten of test wkts for sure if also not batting averages. Certainly top 10 maybe even top 5 for catches. On memory I think only Cowdrey was ahead of him on catches (fielder) at the time
Drapsey 5/3/25, 12:31:29 PM
Drapsey avatar image

debut: 12/26/07
34,564 runs

In reply to spider & Brerzerk

That's why I can and will attribute one of my most flattering moments to that time when the one and only Sir Garfield St Aubrun Sobers used my camera to take a picture of yours truly conversing with Sir Everton DeCourcy Weeks along with Sir Clyde Walcott's son.

Still getting chills from the memory.