debut: 11/13/02
80,119 runs
Regardless of format.
Forums:
The Rum Shop
The Back Room
Who would be the region’s top 5 cricketers today
debut: 11/13/02
80,119 runs
In reply to Conorboy
DaSilva?
Roach?
Curious selections
Ahead of Holder? King? Motie?
Disagree
DaSilva?
Roach?
Curious selections
Ahead of Holder? King? Motie?
Disagree
debut: 2/21/17
686 runs
In reply to imusic
I accept Motie but not King who has flattered to deceive and Holder who to my mind is semi retired.
Roach has always been under valued imho
I accept Motie but not King who has flattered to deceive and Holder who to my mind is semi retired.
Roach has always been under valued imho
debut: 11/13/02
80,119 runs
In reply to Conorboy
You saying Holder is semi retired but 37 year old Roach, who not even sure to make the test team unless it’s as a pity pick for a farewell, is one of the best 5 cricketers in the region?
SMH
You saying Holder is semi retired but 37 year old Roach, who not even sure to make the test team unless it’s as a pity pick for a farewell, is one of the best 5 cricketers in the region?
SMH
debut: 8/21/22
1,321 runs
Why Alzarri didn't receive a lengthy ban for horrible disrespect to fans and teammates remains a mystery.
No one is bigger than the game.
He should've been dropped from the team for months the minute he walked off the field without permission.
Now his apologists claim him as Top 5. WTF???
No one is bigger than the game.
He should've been dropped from the team for months the minute he walked off the field without permission.
Now his apologists claim him as Top 5. WTF???
debut: 11/2/09
12,902 runs
De region just got one...
Sir Kraigg Brathwaite... best opener to ever play the game.
Sir Kraigg Brathwaite... best opener to ever play the game.
debut: 12/22/15
8,268 runs
In reply to Conorboy
There are no 5 top cricketers in West Indies today, they are all struggling with consistency. Let’s look at it in a manner we could all understand, NOT ONE member of any of West Indies current team would have been considered for selection on any of WI previously great teams. Do not fool ourselves, we have fallen and cannot find a way to get back up, some might not have even make their regional teams, that’s how badly we have fallen in cricket standards.
There are no 5 top cricketers in West Indies today, they are all struggling with consistency. Let’s look at it in a manner we could all understand, NOT ONE member of any of West Indies current team would have been considered for selection on any of WI previously great teams. Do not fool ourselves, we have fallen and cannot find a way to get back up, some might not have even make their regional teams, that’s how badly we have fallen in cricket standards.
debut: 11/2/09
12,902 runs
In reply to Slipfeeler
for you it's these guys
1. Kirk McKenzie
2. Blackwood
3. Bonner
4. Campbell
5. Glenn
for you it's these guys
1. Kirk McKenzie
2. Blackwood
3. Bonner
4. Campbell
5. Glenn
- edited -
debut: 5/29/07
8,652 runs
Top five judging from last first-class season:
Hamilton- most consistent wicket-keeper batters, the best keeper and was in the top five in runs scored without making a century.
Imlach - very good wicket-keeper, a solid captain and was in the top ten in runs scored.
Layne - top wicket-taking fast bowler
Warrican- consistent wicket taking spinner
DaSilva - he had a good batting season.
Mohammed should be in that group, but not many fans look at him as a future player.
Hamilton- most consistent wicket-keeper batters, the best keeper and was in the top five in runs scored without making a century.
Imlach - very good wicket-keeper, a solid captain and was in the top ten in runs scored.
Layne - top wicket-taking fast bowler
Warrican- consistent wicket taking spinner
DaSilva - he had a good batting season.
Mohammed should be in that group, but not many fans look at him as a future player.
debut: 2/2/23
2,117 runs
In reply to dayne
Current top 5 players in the WI in any format:
Seales
Pooran
Rutherford
Hope
Warrican?
Current top 5 players in the WI in any format:
Seales
Pooran
Rutherford
Hope
Warrican?
debut: 11/13/02
80,119 runs
In reply to Slipfeeler
Top 5 in the region doesn’t mean they have to be able to make a past West Indies team.
Focus
Top 5 in the region doesn’t mean they have to be able to make a past West Indies team.
Focus
debut: 12/22/15
8,268 runs
In reply to imusic
Ok then let me simplify this for you guys, all current player’s around all WI teams, whether selected or unselected, are all on the same level, therefore there are no top 5 players. At any day, due to their equal inconsistencies, any could either make a century or a duck.
Ok then let me simplify this for you guys, all current player’s around all WI teams, whether selected or unselected, are all on the same level, therefore there are no top 5 players. At any day, due to their equal inconsistencies, any could either make a century or a duck.
- edited -
debut: 11/2/09
12,902 runs
In reply to Slipfeeler
So a player with a batting average of close to 50 in ODIs after 130+ matches is not consistent?
So a player with a batting average of close to 50 in ODIs after 130+ matches is not consistent?
debut: 11/13/02
80,119 runs
In reply to anthonyp
Leff slippy.
He knows not even he can name a yardie in the top 5 so he decides that tarnishing EVERYBODY and saying none of them any good is his workaround
Leff slippy.
He knows not even he can name a yardie in the top 5 so he decides that tarnishing EVERYBODY and saying none of them any good is his workaround
debut: 11/27/09
1,012 runs
In reply to imusic
Pooran-Bat, Confidence
Rutherford- Bat
Hope- Bat
Chase -Bat, Ball, Field
Alzahri-Ball,Passion
Pooran-Bat, Confidence
Rutherford- Bat
Hope- Bat
Chase -Bat, Ball, Field
Alzahri-Ball,Passion
debut: 12/22/15
8,268 runs
In reply to anthonyp
We are not talking about ODI team, the premise of the topic was 5 top regional playing, there was not clarification with regards to the type of team. However, with regards to the test team there are no 5 top players in the region they are all inconsistently the same.
We are not talking about ODI team, the premise of the topic was 5 top regional playing, there was not clarification with regards to the type of team. However, with regards to the test team there are no 5 top players in the region they are all inconsistently the same.
- edited -
debut: 12/22/15
8,268 runs
Additionally, you are naming top players in the region without mentioning the player who actually has a significantly higher test average than all the other names mentioned, how insular can you guys get?? 
- edited -
debut: 12/26/19
9 runs
Pooran
Rutherford
Hope
Seales
Warrican- Check his test bowling record. It is better than most bowlers in the region right now.
Rutherford
Hope
Seales
Warrican- Check his test bowling record. It is better than most bowlers in the region right now.
- edited -
Forums:
The Rum Shop
The Back Room
Search
Live Scores
- no matches