The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

The Trials of the Entitled

Besar 5/29/25, 7:42:11 AM
Besar avatar image

debut: 3/18/05
302 runs

Joshua Da Silva is a wicketkeeper batsman who had lost his place to Tevin Imlach, who happened to have shown so much promise. So, based on that fact, we all expect Imlach to be the front pick for the roll in the next test that the West Indies play. I expect Da Silva to be part of the squad as well. But, why in such a scenario would any logical selectors just make him captain or vice captain? What would be the message to Imlach? You see, Joshua da Silva has to make his way back into the team, first. In the meantime, and to not send the wrong message, a temporary fix in both captain and vice captain was made. The position of wicketkeeper/batsman is not a settled one as yet, and is either one or the other. This is Imlach's turn, and he does not deserve to be dropped. It is also unfair to have his main competeitor breathing down his back as captain or vice captain. That would be a wrong message. In the present circumstances, it is easier to accept Chase and Warrican as both short term measures.
Halliwell 5/29/25, 9:53:34 AM
Halliwell avatar image

debut: 5/14/05
24,530 runs

In reply to Besar

It is also unfair to have his main competeitor breathing down his back as captain or vice captain. That would be a wrong message.

Oh how times have changed
JoeGrine 5/29/25, 12:42:48 PM
JoeGrine avatar image

debut: 2/15/09
4,870 runs

In reply to Halliwell

SHOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TanteMerle 5/29/25, 1:18:11 PM
TanteMerle avatar image

debut: 2/22/04
8,771 runs

In reply to Besar

We have to accept the Chase and Warrican are there (yes for an interim period).
I see Imlach as a future captain, probably to succeed Chase in about 3 years.
Dasilva rightfully loss his place to imlach.
Although he had a good season with the bat, he should have to work his way back in to the team.
Jangoo is most likely the back up keeper, so Dasilva may not even make the squad.
Let Dasilva compete with other batsmen for a batting spot.
Good luck with that.

Openers: -
1. Braffit
2. Campbell
3. Louis

Middle:
1. Hodge
2. Athanaze
3. Carty
4. Chase (Cappo and spinna Allrounder)
5. Anderson

Allrounder:
1. Holder
2. Greaves

Spinnas:
1. Warrican
2. Mootie

Pacers:-
1. Roach
2. Seakes
3. A. Joseph
4. A. Jospeh

Keepers:
1. Impach
2. Jangoo

These are 18 players, from which 3 will be left out.
Luckily Hope is not throwing his hat in the ring.
Where does one see Dasilva fitting in the sqaud?

shock
- edited -
natty_forever 5/29/25, 1:20:08 PM
natty_forever avatar image

debut: 4/28/03
60,631 runs

In reply to Halliwell

You understood what he was rambling about?