Good catch Shai...but your fault

If you want to be a successful keeper you have to be more positive and demonstrative. You opened the door for the tiefing third ump to turn a blind eye

In reply to Logic

Correct

To be fair……these guys don’t play enough red ball cricket etc

In reply to imusic

Hahahaha, shot through the open gyap.

Look, the man not chipid- Ramdinonce did that and get ban

In reply to Logic

Sad really…The ball clearly went to glove.

In reply to Halliwell

Look a man who regularly plays red ball cricket just took a catch at first slip.

These white ball cricketers should only field in the outfield

In reply to powen001

Obvious why Hope was not sure. But especially when you playing against Oz just claim it even if you're not sure. No reward for being decent

In reply to powen001

What game you people watching.
The ball bounced just before the middle finger and into the gloves.
Not out was the correct call.

I am supporting Windies here.
Ozz is my team, but not when they playing Windies.
Plus everyone knows that Hope is my star.

My main men in this order.
Hope
Holder
Pooran
Archer
Imlach
Seales

In reply to Logic

Exactly ....Windies very timid an amateurish when appealing....if was the other way round Oz would have got the decision so would England and India.....no consequences for umpires making bad decisions against Windies...unlike the aforementioned!!

In reply to CCW

Are you watching game?
Did you see the review and zoom in ?
The umpire made the correct decision.
Stop following espn misinfo.

The ball bounced on the grass.
Please watch the replay on Youtube tonight.

In reply to TanteMerle

Both boy scouts, Ian Bishop and Carlos Brathwaite, say the catch was clean

In reply to Logic

I am a West Indian fan but from that angle the ball bounced on the ground first. Let's move forward!

In reply to TanteMerle

Why are we blaming Hope for being honest? If you don't know you don't know. Had he claimed it and instead of the ump not being 100% sure we ended up seeing it dropped short of the gloves the world would've seen Hope as a THIEF!.
He said I'm not sure....right thing to do.

In reply to TanteMerle

I saw the bounce INTO the glove on the same finger…and that was based on the NEXT Frame clearly showing the ball 100% in the glove.

So perhaps my screen working like the other comms who also thought he was out as well.

In reply to TanteMerle

No conclusive evidence it grossed before reaching the gloves, none (conclusive) it did not either. Batsman gets benefit of the doubt. I think it went in but that's irrelevant, ump made correct decision

In reply to TanteMerle

If it was so clear why did the 3rd umpire take so long to make a decision after multiple slow-mos??.....i will watch again but to my mind the keeper had his fingers under the ball but i stand to be corrected....anyhow luckily it wasn't costly!

Clean catch but maybe third umpire had a doubt in his mind…

In reply to CCW

Watched enough cricket in recent years to understand most commies say fingers clearly under the ball, from 2D.
Out out out

In reply to Logic
Yes

Hope missed the catch because he was going backwards expecting the ball to bounce before him. if he had stood his ground he would have caught it.

In reply to Brerzerk

here here

In reply to CCW

Because it is his job to clearly see a dismissal or give the benefit to the batsman.

that is the cricket rule.

So he must/should take his time.

In reply to dayne

[quote Hope missed the catch because he was going backwards expecting the ball to bounce before him. if he had stood his ground he would have caught it. ][/quote]

You sound like someone who has never played cricket.

The most dangerous ball for a fielder/keeper is one that bounces in front of him.

I used to wicketkeep.
I got hit under my right eye with a ball that bounce short of the gloves.
Many fielders/keepers/ get hit in the face where balls dropped short of them.
The defensive thing to do it turn your face or wear a helmet while keeping.
Hope turned his face away to save being struck in the face if the ball fell dangerously short.

forward to 18 to 20 minutes

Hope turned his head defensively, as I stated before.

The replay that the 3rd umpire saw,
showed the ball bounce in front of the gloves on the grass and then into the gloves.
I say fair decision.

I am for the Windies and want Windies to win this series 2-0, with a draw.
I expect rain at some time in the series.