a most senseless debate. Josh could make all the runs in the world but the WI admin that once touted him as a future captain now want nothing to do with him. Tage could be the most inept opening bat in test cricket but the same WI admin consider him the No 2 opener in test cricket. Why debate about how solid is a brick wall??

It is simple, Tarnish cannot bat

@sudden

if that's the criteria, the last good test batsman from the west indies is darren bravo....still not a talentless bajan pretender