Who did Joshua Da Silva offend?
Not wanting to be a spoilsport or rain on the parade of euphoria, success, and elation currently embracing Trinidad and Tobago cricket, there is one thing that has troubled me for a while, and this is as good a time as any to raise it.Why has Joshua Da Silva fallen so far out of favour with Cricket West Indies (CWI)? He has gone from being considered a potential West Indies captain to a non-factor where the CWI selection panel is concerned. Is it that Da Silva spoke out of turn to the media (April 28, 2025 edition of the Trinidad Newsday)? Or is he paying for past sins when skin colour determined who captained the West Indies cricket team? We moved past that era with Sir Frank Worrell. However, is it that there are those who feel deep down that Da Silva, for non-cricket reasons, should never captain the regional side?
It was noticeable that, following the conclusion of the West Indies Championship, when the individual awards were announced, the category Da Silva had an excellent chance of winning eluded him. Those in the know claim it is the first time "most dismissals" weren't used. What is truth? What is fiction? What is a figment of one's imagination? It could even be a touch of insularity. However, one cannot help but wonder: who did Joshua Da Silva offend?
If you look at the batting averages of those who have maintained the confidence of head coach Daren Sammy and the selectors, it makes for interesting reading–as do the West Indies Championship statistics since 2024. Regardless of how harsh and difficult his banishment to the CWI wilderness may be, Da Silva has led T&T with class and dignity, responding to his critics and doubters as a true leader would.