CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums The Rum Shop
Sammy & Chase to DaSilva….FORK U!!

Sammy & Chase to DaSilva….FORK U!!

Page: 1 2 next
Tue, Oct 27, '26 at 11:54 PM

Message clearly delivered

Tue, Oct 27, '26 at 11:58 PM

Really unbelievable that Tage plays before Joshua. Something doesn't right

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 12:06 AM

......................

Anon: "Da Silva still can't get a game. Jangoo isn't even the first choice keeper for Trinidad, Da Silva is. WI seem keen on playing batters first in Hope and Jangoo, and burdening them with keeping instead of allowing them to focus on batting. Note than Da Silva has been one of the top scorers regionally over the past couple of seasons, but can't get a consistent run to prove himself again. I'd rather Jangoo focus on just batting and expected one of King, Tage, and Hodge to miss out based on form."

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 12:08 AM

@Baje wrote:

Really unbelievable that Tage plays before Joshua. Something doesn't right

Dem 2 mans fixin to crush DaSilva.

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 12:11 AM

@sgtdjones wrote:

......................
Anon: "Da Silva still can't get a game. Jangoo isn't even the first choice keeper for Trinidad, Da Silva is. WI seem keen on playing batters first in Hope and Jangoo, and burdening them with keeping instead of allowing them to focus on batting. Note than Da Silva has been one of the top scorers regionally over the past couple of seasons, but can't get a consistent run to prove himself again. I'd rather Jangoo focus on just batting and expected one of King, Tage, and Hodge to miss out based on form."

Da Silva is paying for his shoddy glovework that cost us terribly in his last match. Surprise call but if I were to do that I would have handed Wickham a debut, not play Chanderpaul.

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 12:14 AM

........

Anon: Tage hasn't been as good but has only been back in the team for 2 matches and made starts in all four innings - 21, 35, 15 and 17 and faced and faced 235 balls doing it. These aren't players that are rank failures."

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 12:40 AM

Anon: "They've not been failures but Hodge has been inconsistent since his 123, King has been dropped from the white ball squads on form, and Tage has just gotten starts. It's great to finally have competition for places. But in the order of things, Da Silva was brought in against Pak, given 1 Test, and dropped to give Hope the gloves as Jangoo seized his chance. As Hope is rested, the natural order is to give Da Silva the gloves, unless we give it to Jangoo full time to free Hope's workload in Tests."

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 1:17 AM

I don’t believe Sammy wants Jangoo in the team either. He hardly gave him opportunities, even when it was obvious that Jangoo was in form. Now that Jangoo has been scoring international centuries, Sammy can’t simply ignore him, so what does he do? Give him the gloves as well. Disrupt his batting by adding wicketkeeping responsibilities, then potentially use any dip in his batting as an excuse to push him out of the team.

Why keep playing people out of their natural positions? What exactly is Chanderpaul doing at No. 3? Sammy loves to talk about defined roles, but it seems that principle only applies when it suits his favourites.

Chase is being hidden away at No. 7 when he should be batting in the middle order, yet he is also being relied on as the main spinner whenever the team plays just one specialist spinner. Meanwhile, we have Warrican, a specialist Test spinner and the squad’s vice-captain, sitting there.

So, is Sammy really selecting players based on defined roles, or does that principle only matter when it suits his agenda? Because from the outside looking in, the inconsistency is hard to ignore.

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 2:22 AM

Power in the hands of men of challenged emotional intelligence is dangerous. So just imagine absolute power. We currently have two easy examples ...

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 6:53 AM

@imusic wrote:

Dem 2 mans fixin to crush DaSilva.

Da Sailva was recalled because Imlach couldn’t bat!Then proceeded to drop 3 regulation catches and not score runs!!!

Had a flat track in the 2 day match and only made 11! If you play him and he fails again you’re forced to give Hope the gloves again when he comes back at least you now have another option with Jangoo if he’s still able to score!!!

Should Tage play in front of him absolutely not but he’s only keeping Hope’s spot warm until he returns anyways so it’s a much ado about nothing!!!

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 8:55 AM

@Baje wrote:

Really unbelievable that Tage plays before Joshua

Different position...

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 9:34 AM

@voiceofreason wrote:

Da Silva is paying for his shoddy glovework that cost us terribly in his last match. Surprise call but if I were to do that I would have handed Wickham a debut, not play Chanderpaul.

da silva's last test was an innings' victory for the WI yuh dunce

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 10:22 AM

hope should not be keeping in tests longterm when he returns i was very suprised dasilva was cut from the 11

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 10:38 AM

If Imlach makes runs in the next f/c season he will walk back into the squad. I agree that the Selectors could have played DaSilva as a batter in this Test, he deserves a chance

Wed, Oct 28, '26 at 11:38 AM

@Jumpstart wrote:

da silva's last test was an innings' victory for the WI yuh dunce

Yes the Test where he dropped three catches and made only 3 in a score of 626 Must have been greatly relieved when we scored 626.

I agree he should have played as I had him in my team. Can do no worse than Tage.

Page: 1 2 next
Forums The Rum Shop
Sammy & Chase to DaSilva….FORK U!!