CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Progress Amid Decline

Page: 1 2 next
Sat, Oct 31, '26 at 9:52 PM
Two seemingly contradictory things are currently true: cricket is in decline in the Caribbean, yet the West Indies have put together improving international teams that are competing at a respectable level.
Recent white-ball and red-ball results attest to this. They have just won the first Test of the Bangladesh tour by eight wickets in Dhaka. And this is after beating Sri Lanka 1-0 in their two-Test Caribbean series and drawing 1-1 against Pakistan in the Caribbean as well.

https://garfieldrobinson1.substack.com/p/progress-amid-decline

Sat, Oct 31, '26 at 10:46 PM

@spider wrote:

https://garfieldrobinson1.substack.com/p/progress-amid-decline

VOR that.

Sat, Oct 31, '26 at 11:08 PM

@spider wrote:

https://garfieldrobinson1.substack.com/p/progress-amid-decline

The article is on point for the most part although it fails to mention the fundamental issues that ail West Indies cricket and that will prohibit an extended period of success.

Sat, Oct 31, '26 at 11:44 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

The article is on point for the most part although it fails to mention the fundamental issues that ail West Indies cricket and that will prohibit an extended period of success.

So what he thinks ails West Indies cricket is here: https://garfieldrobinson1.substack.com/publish/posts/detail/209051873?referrer=%2Fpublish%2Fposts%2Fpublished%3Foffset%3D50

As to solutions: I dont think he has much specifics

Sun, Nov 1, '26 at 8:35 AM

@spider wrote:

So what he thinks ails West Indies cricket is here: https://garfieldrobinson1.substack.com/publish/posts/detail/209051873?referrer=%2Fpublish%2Fposts%2Fpublished%3Foffset%3D50
As to solutions: I dont think he has much specifics

Says the page is private.

Sun, Nov 1, '26 at 9:45 AM

@voiceofreason wrote:

Says the page is private.

https://garfieldrobinson1.substack.com/p/when-cricket-left-the-village

Sun, Nov 1, '26 at 10:29 AM

@voiceofreason wrote:

the fundamental issues that ail West Indies cricket and that will prohibit an extended period of success.

Care to expand on this besides your clear attempt to make excuses for putting square pegs in round holes?

Sun, Nov 1, '26 at 6:44 PM

@googley wrote:

Care to expand on this besides your clear attempt to make excuses for putting square pegs in round holes?

Ask Garfield Ferguson.

Sun, Nov 1, '26 at 9:01 PM

@voiceofreason wrote:

Ask Garfield Ferguson.

Who's that?

Mon, Nov 2, '26 at 5:53 AM

@spider wrote:

https://garfieldrobinson1.substack.com/p/progress-amid-decline

In Premier League, a team gets relegated..... in last match .....it draws with table topper...can it be called progress...



Mon, Nov 2, '26 at 9:35 AM

@spider wrote:

https://garfieldrobinson1.substack.com/p/progress-amid-decline

sorry bro. love your articles, but I can't agree with this. Cricket in the West Indies has been in decline since the IMF structural adjustment programs made the act of getting cricket equipment for individuals and organizations difficult. Yet still we weren't getting bowled out for 27. I was there when Christopher Henry Gayle(OD) lifted the Wisden trophy at Queen's Park Oval in 2009, the first WI captain to do that since Brian Lara 11 years earlier. I was old enough to remember our first ever test victory in South Africa in 2008, I also remember our first series in NZ that did not end in defeat in 13 years, all under the same captain. Those were triumphs over high caliber opposition. Not cellar placed teams barely treading water. What we're doing here can't even be compared to Brisbane 2024 where the WI scored 311, the then highest score by a team against Australia in a D/N test on an uneven Gabba wicket, which set the stage for our victory in that test(for the subversive elements like VOR who believe that test was only Shamar, who has not been as good as he was when Coley was there btw). Darren Sammy is just fortunate this part of the WTC didn't have SA or England or NZ touring the WI or else the results would have been the same as Australia last year, a definite regression from the 2024 contest between the sides

Mon, Nov 2, '26 at 11:38 AM

@Jumpstart wrote:

sorry bro. love your articles, but I can't agree with this. Cricket in the West Indies has been in decline since the IMF structural adjustment programs made the act of getting cricket equipment for individuals and organizations difficult. Yet still we weren't getting bowled out for 27. I was there when Christopher Henry Gayle(OD) lifted the Wisden trophy at Queen's Park Oval in 2009, the first WI captain to do that since Brian Lara 11 years earlier. I was old enough to remember our first ever test victory in South Africa in 2008, I also remember our first series in NZ that did not end in defeat in 13 years, all under the same captain. Those were triumphs over high caliber opposition. Not cellar placed teams barely treading water. What we're doing here can't even be compared to Brisbane 2024 where the WI scored 311, the then highest score by a team against Australia in a D/N test on an uneven Gabba wicket, which set the stage for our victory in that test(for the subversive elements like VOR who believe that test was only Shamar, who has not been as good as he was when Coley was there btw). Darren Sammy is just fortunate this part of the WTC didn't have SA or England or NZ touring the WI or else the results would have been the same as Australia last year, a definite regression from the 2024 contest between the sides

I hear you. But I think the team is better mainly because the batting improved. We are now getting more runs from batsmen like Campbell, King, Hodges, Greaves, Hope etc. Our bowling was already decent and so the improved batting had made us a better team I think

Mon, Nov 2, '26 at 11:44 AM

@Onionman0 wrote:

In Premier League, a team gets relegated..... in last match .....it draws with table topper...can it be called progress...


Good point. Could just be regression to the mean. So what we looking for is consistency and I believe the batting has been showing some consistency recently. If we look at the scores from Campbell, King, Hodges, Hope we see them stringing together a few reasonable scores. That is mainly why I think the team getting better

Mon, Nov 2, '26 at 4:37 PM

@Jumpstart wrote:

Yet still we weren't getting bowled out for 27

What is the difference between 27 and 47, let me hear it dummy?
Mon, Nov 2, '26 at 8:16 PM

@tc1

Can I answer. 20, which was still not near the lowest scoreS in test cricket, we now second. Question, if iceman was still in charge and you had a say in weather he stayed or go...

Page: 1 2 next