The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Message Board Archives

Kallicharan,Kanhai, both better than Chanderpaul

 
outside_edge 2017-05-12 23:48:19 

Discuss.....but it is so plainly obvious.

 
mikesiva 2017-05-13 05:00:09 

In reply to outside_edge

All three are better than this current bunch of jokers.

 
doosra 2017-05-13 05:03:17 

In reply to mikesiva

is that an underhand way to discredit those 3 gentlemen?

ok let's see what the picture might say

Shiv {Kraigg, Hope, Chase, Singh, Hety, Blackwood}

Kanhai {Kraigg, Hope, Chase, Singh, Hety, Blackwood}

Kali {Kraigg, Hope, Chase, Singh, Hety, Blackwood} big grin

 
dayne 2017-05-13 07:03:37 

IMO and the number proves it, Chenderpaul was more consistent than Kallicharran, but Kallicharran was more entertaining to watch. Because their batting styles were different, it would be difficult to say who was better technically.

 
doosra 2017-05-13 09:07:05 

In reply to dayne

Kali averaged 50 at 50 tests with 12 hundreds or so. ...

 
ray 2017-05-13 10:53:29 

I like SHiv, but I'll watch Kalli & Kanhai over him

 
jacksparrow 2017-05-13 11:05:31 

Different era different team different roles.Each remarkable in their own right, not a valid comparision in my opinion.End of the day Shiv numbers speak for themselves, facts versus fiction.

 
johndom90 2017-05-13 12:43:56 

In reply to outside_edge

Stupid comparison.....shiv is totally different player...in style and character while at the pitch.

Kalli and Kanhai were adventurous.....Shiv is more of a conservatist

 
Seechy 2017-05-13 12:47:53 

Shiv all the way.