HEADLINE: ‘What did Cornwall bring to the team? – former England quick Small mystified by off-spinners selection

Pages: previous  1  2 
link Maispwi Joined: Feb 3, 2003
Posts: 14724
7/30/20, 6:25:00 PM 
In reply to Norm

Ah said dat from day 1. With rain n cloudy skies forecast for all 5 days of the match, why wud anybody play 2 spinners at de expense of a seamer?

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 6:40:03 PM 
In reply to Maispwi
why wud anybody play 2 spinners at de expense of a seamer?

That would be up to the selectors.

The point is that Cornwall EARNED his selection in the team, whenever the selectors chose to play him.

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 6:40:59 PM 
In reply to openning
There is no need for two off-spinners in the West Indies team.

Says who?

link openning Joined: Nov 12, 2002
Posts: 36080
7/30/20, 7:26:29 PM 
In reply to Norm
Says who?

Yours truly.
There is nothing wrong with two off break bowlers in Asia, with one having some variety, but see absolutely little difference in the bowling.
It is like picking Permaul, Miller or warrican.
Now if Shillingford or Narine can bowl, they could be selected together, because of what in their arsenal.

link nitro Joined: Apr 9, 2003
Posts: 12470
7/30/20, 8:50:05 PM 
In reply to CaribbeanCricket.com

He brought Guts to the team, lots of it.

By the way OBESITY is an underlying condition. They exposed the young man to the threat of Covid.

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/30/20, 10:04:56 PM 
In reply to openning
Yours truly.

The selectors wanted both Chase and Cornwall in the third Test. Looks like they chose to ignore you - just like that. smile

link openning Joined: Nov 12, 2002
Posts: 36080
7/30/20, 10:34:18 PM 
In reply to Norm
This is my first response to the thread.
I was a big supporter of him, until I watched both of them together in the third test.
Only one of them should be in any X1.

I also thought he should have been selected for the first test, after seeing them bowled together, my belief is only one them should be selected, in the playing X1.

link Sylobaby Joined: May 17, 2020
Posts: 26
7/31/20, 8:21:15 AM 
As a West Indian I must say that I was disappointed with the selection of Cornwall for the final test. However Small is not a former England cricketer and therefore he should have criticized his English selectors for not playing Broad in the first test and let us West Indians take care of our problem. He should have told Archer that he will never be celebrated as an Englishman

link pooranian Joined: Apr 11, 2020
Posts: 187
7/31/20, 8:58:25 AM 
What did he bring to the table........A plate,knife and fork.Player looking like that in 2020 is beyond shameful....Before the sensitive folks jump on me.This just shows the lack of discipline...whichever way you slice and dice it..Unless there is a serious medical condition...

link Halliwell Joined: May 13, 2005
Posts: 12425
7/31/20, 9:16:21 AM 
In reply to Norm

Norm,
I am not saying we should include Gayle.
I am saying the same arguments about out-fielding weakness, lesser spin option and fading prowess with the bat MUST apply to Cornwall equally.

link dayne Joined: May 28, 2007
Posts: 4987
7/31/20, 9:38:19 AM 
A few months ago both Hetmyer and Lewis failed a fitness test for the ODI series in India, is that same test held for Test cricket selection and is Cornwall exempt from taking it?

link camos Joined: May 5, 2003
Posts: 51189
7/31/20, 10:30:15 AM 
In reply to dayne

The test Cornwall took was a political test!

wink

link Halliwell Joined: May 13, 2005
Posts: 12425
7/31/20, 10:39:01 AM 
In reply to camos

lol

link Norm Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 31186
7/31/20, 12:53:28 PM 
In reply to camos

The way all you cussin' Cornwall, you would think that HE lost the Test that was a sure win for WI.

link Logic Joined: Jun 18, 2005
Posts: 3281
7/31/20, 1:18:24 PM 
In reply to Halliwell

Did not want to get into the Monday morning quarterbacking on Cornwall but could not let the following pass:

RCornwall v CHGayle (now) fielding at slip- Overwhelmingly Gayle

I know he dropped a catch in the match but Cornwall is an exceptional slip fielder. Gayle in his old age has been dropping nuff.

RC v CHG bowling spin- marginally Cornwall

This comment is particularly delusional, confirming that Gayle is more myth than substance in some people's minds.

link Star Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 7666
7/31/20, 1:26:14 PM 
In reply to Norm
=== is to question the use of the domestic competition as the basis for WI selection


V.Permaul, K.Powell ignored in spite of their domestic performance.

C.Holder not selected for the 3rd test although everyone knew Gabriel was spent. I am of the opinion that this young man would have created some problems for the English batsmen.

Playing people off reputation is not going to cut it anymore. I am not convinced the grunter can live up to his reputation anymore.

Mr.Jimmy Adams must read the riot act to certain people including the Chief Selector.

link analyst-kid Joined: Feb 21, 2003
Posts: 13770
7/31/20, 1:37:17 PM 
In reply to Star

Reifer instead of Cornwall for Joseph
Chemar Holder for Gabriel.
Bonner for Hope
DaSilva for Campbell

But then that would have been an all Bajan attack!

link Star Joined: Nov 27, 2002
Posts: 7666
7/31/20, 1:48:26 PM 
In reply to analyst-kid
Those selection would have been ok.

Very Happy Smile Sad Surprised Shocked Confused Cool Laughing Razz Embarassed Crying or Very sad Evil or Very Mad Twisted Evil Rolling Eyes Wink
 
Pages: previous  1  2