debut: 1/30/09
1,952 runs
In reply to Jumpstart
Absolutely correct Jumpstart!
With regards to the test team:
2009 was the year that we had a pretty settled test team that was consistently making 300+ scores and challenging the best teams in the world. The batting was led by the big 3: Gayle, Sarwan, and Chanderpaul - the three men of power to hold the key to a successful batting innings. Take out this triumvirate early in an innings and you could well dismiss the team for 150 or less. But in 2009, a dependable supporting act was galvanising outside of the big 3, notably through the steely lower middle order batsmen of Brendan Nash, Denesh Ramdin, Jerome Taylor, and in Australia, Dwayne Bravo and Narsingh Deonarine. These understudies were able to resurrect an innings if 1, 2 or all of the big 3 had failed or were absent. They had the ability to score 50s or even 100s and build on the foundation laid by the top order. The bowling attack was the weakest aspect. We were short of two reliable seamers to support Taylor (Edwards, Best, and Powell too inconsistent...Roach's successes came later and Rampaul had fitness issues) and we were missing a world class spinner (Shillngford showed glimpses from 2010 but had issues with his action). The other major gap would have been finding an opening partner to support Gayle (Brathwaite didn't debut until 2011 and Barath had failed after his debut century at the Gabba). If the core of the team was allowed to remain the same between 2007 and 2012, West Indies test cricket may have seen different results in the 2010s, with guys like Samuels and Darren Bravo showing promise at number 4. With Sammy taking over in 2010, the whole balance of the team shifted. Gayle and eventually Sarwan were shunted from the team by 2011. When Gayle was brought back in 2012, Sarwan was ignored. So, the triumvirate of Gayle-Sarwan-Chanderpaul was no longer in existence - the last time these three played together in test cricket was in Australia 2009 - hence the team struggled ever since.
With regards to the T20 success of 2012 and 2016:
The blueprints were indeed provided by Daren Ganga's pioneering T20 teams of 2007 to 2009, which culminated in that Champions Trophy final. He was the tactical mind behind those victories, and at his disposal, he had Kieron Pollard, Sunil Narine, and Dwayne Bravo, who would go on to become three of the best all rounders T20 cricket has ever seen. Trinidad and Tobago's successes would then be translated into the West Indies successes of 2012. Throw in the other two all time greats - the Universe Boss and Dre Russ - then you have the core of the band. The supporting cast of Jonno, Spice man, Simmons, Ramdin, Rampaul, Badree, and of course MVP Samuels, were all also instrumental and played their part in WI lifting that first trophy in 2012. Sammy was just there for the ride, and to clap and toss coin. Sammy proved to be more useful in the role as finisher in the 2014 T20 world cup. 2016 West Indies came with slightly less reputation as a world class unit, with Pollard and Narine missing the tournament, but the reliability was still there in Gayle, Russell, Bravo, Simmons, and Samuels. RTN added the finishing touches and Sammy wasn't needed.